Every other contest winner, except Cindy McCain in 2008, went on to inhabit the White House.
And just like the presidential race, the cookie race was tight. According to the magazine, it was the smallest victory margin ever for Obama, who took 51.5 percent of the vote for her White and Dark Chocolate Chip Cookies.
Ann Romney earned 48.5 percent of the vote for her M&M cookies, with only 287 votes separating the two.
Obama credits her winning recipe to her daughters’ godmother, Mama Kaye. In 2008, Michelle ObamaMichelle ObamaFirst Nigerian girl taken by Boko Haram rescued WATCH: Obama accidentally steps on First Lady's dress at state dinner The Hill's 12:30 Report MORE entered Shortbread Cookies in the contest
Michelle Obama later tweeted about the contest, thanking the magazine while underlining the importance of voting.
The @familycircle cookie contest was a lot of fun, so thanks to those who voted. Such a close race proves that every vote counts! –mo— Michelle Obama (@MichelleObama) October 3, 2012
Both recipes and the contest results are available in the magazine’s November issue, on newsstands now, as well as online at familycircle.com/cookieresults.
Updated Oct. 3 at 9:50 a.m.