The Honorable Eric H. Holder Jr.
Attorney General
United States Department of Justice
950 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW
Washington, D.C. 20530

Dear Attorney General Holder:

It was reported over the weekend that Osama bin Laden endorsed the attempted bombing of Northwest Airlines Flight 253 on Christmas Day.  This endorsement underscores that the successful defense of the United States against Al Qaeda requires the integration and coordination of myriad capabilities of our national security agencies.  We remain deeply troubled that this paramount requirement of national security was ignored—or worse yet, not recognized—due to the administration’s preoccupation with reading the Christmas Day bomber his Miranda rights.

Apparently there was little, if any, coordination among key components of the administration’s national security apparatus on how to treat Umar Farouk Abdulmutallab.  Shockingly, the administration then made the hasty decision to treat him as a civilian defendant—including advising him of a right in a civilian law enforcement context not to cooperate—rather than as an intelligence resource to be thoroughly interrogated in order to obtain potentially life-saving information.

The congressional inquiries into why and how this could have happened left us and the American people with more questions than answers.  Among these are:

  • Why were key national security officials not consulted on the decision to treat Abdulmutallab, first and foremost, as a civilian criminal defendant?
  • Why was this decision made so quickly, without first giving intelligence officials at least the opportunity to comment on it?
  • Has the administration developed a protocol or standard operating procedure (SOP) for interrogating terrorists captured on American soil?  If so, does the SOP give intelligence officials the opportunity to question terrorists?
  • Why was such a modest amount of time, apparently less than an hour, devoted to questioning Abdulmutallab prior to telling him that he did not have to cooperate?
  • Why was the High-Value Detainee Interrogation Group (HIG) not involved at all in his questioning?  If it is because the HIG is not yet operational, why is the HIG still not ready for use, a year after the president announced the formation of the Special Task Force on Interrogation and Transfer Policies?

  • It appears that the decision not to thoroughly interrogate Abdulmutallab was made by you or other senior officials in the Department of Justice.  Moreover, those with knowledge of this decision, like FBI Director Robert Mueller, have said they are constrained from discussing important aspects of it without prior approval from your department.  

    It is critical that the American people have a full and timely understanding of the policy and legal rationale upon which this ill-advised decision was made.  Because it appears that you are the best person to provide this information, we ask: first, that you provide written answers to the questions above and; second, that you testify promptly before the appropriate committees of jurisdiction as to these questions and any lessons your department may have learned from this incident.

    Sincerely,

    Senator Mitch McConnellMitch McConnellCould bipartisanship rise with Trump government? Senate names part of Cures bill after Beau Biden Biden raises possibility of 2020 presidential bid MORE, Republican Leader
    Senator Kit Bond, Vice Chairman of the Select Committee on Intelligence
    Senator Susan CollinsSusan CollinsSenators crafting bill to limit deportations under Trump Cornyn: ‘Virtual certainty’ Sessions and Price will be confirmed Trump's wrong to pick Bannon or Sessions for anything MORE, Ranking Member of the Senate Committee on Homeland Security and Government Affairs
    Senator John McCainJohn McCainThe trouble with Rex Tillerson   Senate: Act now to save Ukraine A Cabinet position for Petraeus; disciplinary actions for Broadwell after affair MORE Ranking Member of the Senate Armed Services Committee
    Senator Jeff SessionsJeff SessionsCould bipartisanship rise with Trump government? Top Dem signals likely opposition to Sessions nomination #NeverTrump can love him or hate him, Trump always wins MORE, Ranking Member of the Senate Judiciary Committee

    Cc:      

    The Honorable Harry ReidHarry ReidOvernight Tech: FCC eyes cybersecurity role | More trouble for spectrum auction | Google seeks 'conservative outreach' director Cures bill clears first Senate hurdle Dem senator had 'constructive' talk with Trump MORE
    The Honorable Patrick LeahyPatrick LeahyPassing US-Canada preclearance would improve security and economy GOP wants to move fast on Sessions Senate Dems pan talk of short-term spending bill MORE
    The Honorable Joseph Lieberman
    The Honorable Dianne FeinsteinDianne FeinsteinCongress strikes deal on water bill with Flint aid Top Dem signals likely opposition to Sessions nomination Senator blasts GOP push for California drought language in water bill MORE
    The Honorable Carl LevinCarl Levin'Nuclear option' for Supreme Court nominees will damage Senate McCain's Supreme Court strategy leads to nuclear Senate The Fed and a return to banking simplicity MORE