On the other hand, keeping the cap in place maintains an economic barrier to entry that protects near-monopoly status for banks that collectively control 95% of small business lending. In other words, the arbitrary cap on credit union lending is a regulation that inhibits competition and protects competitors (the banks).
Nice try, but not true. The reality is that the credit unions’ nonprofit status requires all profits go back to their customers (members), meaning that customers get lower interest on loans and higher interest on savings accounts. In other words, credit unions serve the public in a break-even manner, so they have no real profits to tax.
Similarly, banks could also operate in a break-even fashion and avoid all income taxes, but they choose not to. Instead, they freely choose to generate profits and distribute them with investors or stockholders as dividends. Alternatively, if for-profit banks chose to operate as a Subchapter S corporation, instead of a Subchapter C corporation, their investors and stockholders could also avoid dividend taxes as well. Furthermore, if nonprofit status is truly an advantage, for-profit banks should consider converting, but that won’t happen. Considering that banks control the vast majority of lending, cry of an “unlevel” playing field is just weak and disingenuous lobby-speak.
The only “unlevel” playing field is that credit unions are subject to a cap that prevents them from lending to small businesses. This is unfortunate since, compared with banks, credit union lending produces a third of the delinquency rate and bad debt. In other words, we could see more loans at lower market risk.
Public policy needs to encourage competition, remove market entry barriers, encourage investment— and do all of this without government funding. As I look across the political spectrum and hear the free-market, pro-competition and anti-regulation voices, it will be very interesting to see where politicians stand on this issue.
Steve Pociask is president of the American Consumer Institute Center for Citizen Research, an educational and research organization.