As a way of helping fund their health spending bill, Democrats inserted a backdoor tax known as the 1099 Mandate that forces small businesses to bear the burden of their plan. It mandates that every business and charity in the country submit 1099 forms for transactions totaling $600 or more — including routine business expenses like phones, office products, and shipping costs. And it could increase businesses’ reporting requirement by as much as 2,000 percent.
Even the White House now admits they went too far and that their health spending bill hurts small businesses. Predictably, however, their remedy is to raise taxes. So this is just one more way Democrats are holding back the economic recovery — by socking businesses with another mandate that could cost them thousands of dollars a year in the middle of a recession.
Ironically, the IRS says they won’t even be able to handle the paperwork this mandate would generate. They also say it’s likely they’ll improperly assess penalties that they’ll have to abate later.
Now, the Democratic Senator from Florida has put forth an amendment we’ll be voting on later today that aims to help small businesses get around this reporting requirement. The problem is, the Nelson Amendment only covers some small businesses and fails to address the root of the problem.
Under this amendment, for example, businesses with 26 or more employees would still be subject to mandates for transactions totaling $5,000 or more. Not only would hundreds of thousands of businesses still have to deal with this costly and burdensome new mandate, many others would presumably stop hiring once they’ve reached the magic number of 26 employees in order to avoid paying the new expense. Moreover, the Nelson Amendment does nothing to alleviate the paperwork nightmare, and it’s paid for with yet another major tax increase.
Senator Johanns has proposed a better approach. Unlike the Nelson Amendment, the Johanns Amendment fully repeals the 1099 mandate and would halt the Democrats’ backdoor attempt to further place the costs of their health care plan on the backs of small businesses. It eliminates the paperwork for all businesses instead of picking winners and losers.
The Johanns Amendment also has broad support. It’s been endorsed by The Coalition for Fairness in Tax Compliance, the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, National Federation of Independent Businesses, American Farm Bureau Federation, and the Americans for Tax Reform. And it has bipartisan support in the Senate as well.
This is a strong amendment that will actually help small businesses without hurting others. So I’ll be voting for the Johanns Amendment — and against the continued costs and mandates of the Nelson Amendment. I urge my colleagues to do the same.