November 29, 2011, 09:23 pm
By Craig Aaron and Matt Wood, Free Press
Watching AT&T try to save its proposed merger with T-Mobile is like watching a remake of The Sixth Sense: The lead character is dead but doesn’t know it yet.
As much as AT&T pretends to the contrary, the takeover flat-lined last week when the FCC indicated it would oppose the deal. While some observers framed the FCC’s move to designate the merger for an “administrative hearing” as just another setback for AT&T, it was actually a fatal blow. The Department of Justice blocks mergers with lawsuits; the FCC does the same with hearings.
More damning than what the FCC was about to do were the reasons behind that decision. The agency rejected the claims in AT&T’s advertising and lobbying blitz, concluding that the merger would be a massive jobs killer that wouldn’t lead to faster rollout of 4G services to rural America. The FCC also confirmed the Department of Justice’s analysis that the merger would do immeasurable harm to competition and innovation.
There are no priorities before Congress more pressing than spurring private sector job growth and reducing the deficit.
That’s why, under my direction, the Communications and Technology Subcommittee has dedicated the past year to exploring how spectrum policy can help accomplish these goals.
Following multiple hearings, negotiations, and input from job creators, public safety officials, and other stakeholders, I am disappointed that we could not develop a bipartisan bill. But for the sake of the economy and public safety, we decided to take the best ideas and move forward today with unveiling the Jumpstarting Opportunity with Broadband Spectrum (JOBS) Act of 2011.
November 21, 2011, 03:23 pm
By Dean Garfield, Information Technology Industry Council
Few proposals lawmakers have been considering in recent weeks aimed at restoring our fiscal discipline have the immediate ability to generate revenue for the Treasury, stimulate direct domestic investment, spur innovation, and create jobs than spectrum auctions.
At the moment, spectrum is in short supply. Currently in use for “over the air” television delivery, which is consumed by fewer than 10 percent of American households, this underutilized spectrum could be reallocated for mobile broadband usage. Cisco estimates the volume of mobile data in the United States will double every year through 2014, increasing 39 times between 2009 and 2014, for a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 108 percent.
Industry studies have determined there are currently more than 276 million wireless subscribers in the United States, which represents a penetration rate of 89 percent. The number of subscribers increased by 40 percent between June 2005 and June 2009 while the number of wireless-only households nearly tripled.
November 18, 2011, 08:11 pm
By Casey Rae-Hunter, Deputy Director of the Future of Music Coalition and a professor in Georgetown University's Communications, Culture and Technology department.
Everyone’s wallet gets light from time to time. In the late 1950s and early ‘60s, Willie Nelson was so broke, he sold the rights to several of his most well-known songs for less than what a full tank of gas would cost today. “I needed fifty dollars!” he later recalled. In hindsight, the idea of letting the rights to “Crazy” go for a paltry ten bucks seems, well, crazy. Unfortunately Congress may be on the verge of making the same sort of short-sighted mistake with its proposed plan to sell off TV broadcast spectrum as a method of raising a small amount of revenue in the short-term.
The shift to digital has opened up opportunities in the old over-the-air TV band. This part of the radio spectrum could foster innovative technologies and help bring more affordable broadband to hard-to-cover areas. That is, if the spectrum isn’t locked down by America’s dominant mobile carriers.
In the face of economic hardship, iffy decisions can be too easily justified. Currently, policymakers — including the ballyhooed Super Committee — are exploring ways to put some much-needed cash in the US Treasury. Selling America’s spectrum to established industry players might seem like a fine idea at the moment. But it could leave us singing the blues down the line.
November 16, 2011, 01:06 pm
By Rep. Greg Walden and Rep. Adam Kinzinger
The technology and communications sector is the most innovative in our country—it deserves the most innovative and open government agency.
Federal Communications Commission Chairman Julius Genachowski has taken some steps to open his agency’s processes to the public. However, only Congress can make permanent these reforms and others to ensure that the FCC is the kind of accountable federal agency that taxpayers deserve.
To that end, the Subcommittee on Communications and Technology today (Wednesday 16th Nov) will examine a bill we recently introduced, the FCC Process Reform Act, that would put good government reforms into law for the current Commission—and for all those to come in the future.
As of this summer, 1,351,898 consumer complaints, 5,328 petitions from industry stakeholders, and 4,034 license applications and renewals had been pending at the FCC for more than two years.
November 14, 2011, 03:23 pm
By Markham Erickson, Executive Director of Net Coalition
There’s a hearing in the U.S. House of Representatives this week that could determine the future of how we use the Internet. On November 16, the House Judiciary Committee will meet to discuss the Stop Online Piracy Act, referred to as SOPA. SOPA and its Senate counterpart, the Protect IP ACT (PIPA), sound innocuous enough and their goal is a good one—stopping offshore, online piracy and copyright infringement.
Unfortunately, this legislation severely threatens lawful, U.S. technology industries by overturning the existing laws that have helped fuel the tech boom of the last decade and instituting new regulations which would stifle innovation and job creation. Both bills gut the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA), which for over a decade has helped Internet companies grow and flourish. The DMCA is one of the big reasons companies like Facebook, YouTube, and Twitter weren’t crushed in their early days by harassing lawsuits.
November 09, 2011, 04:01 pm
By Matt Bauer, president and co-founder of BetterWorld Telecom, and board member of the American Sustainable Business COuncil and the Buisiness Alliance for Local Living Economies
From the perspective of the small, competitive telecom carrier, Net neutrality carries great weight. My company is among a relatively small but entrenched cadre of competitive “common carriers” as licensed by a decades-old regulatory structure oddly enough borne out of AT&T’s original “legalized” monopoly. This regulatory structure creates a relatively even playing field for carriers like ours to compete against the likes of AT&T, Verizon and Comcast – a brilliant mix of competition and regulatory structure. Otherwise, there would just be a handful of choices in the market – even though in practice this is mostly the net result, as a vast majority of consumers and business utilize four or five primary carriers for their landline or cellular service.
November 09, 2011, 03:58 pm
By Attorney General Jim Hood (Miss.)
Legislation is pending before Congress to combat a dangerous form of Internet fraud and abuse. Criminals are using rogue websites – often cunningly designed to resemble legitimate online destinations – to sell counterfeit goods of all kinds, as well as to offer pirated copies of copyrighted materials. By flooding the U.S. market with illicit products, these sites steal U.S. jobs, undermine our economy, and threaten consumer health and safety. These operations are often set up overseas, in countries like China that show little respect for intellectual property (IP), and are therefore effectively beyond the reach of U.S. law enforcement.
Rogue sites legislation—the Senate’s PROTECT IP Act (S. 968) and the House of Representatives’ Stop Online Piracy Act (H.R. 3261), propose measures that would enhance the tools available to fight these rogue websites and the damages they cause. If passed, the legislation would authorize the Justice Department to ask federal courts to order Internet service providers to block access to sites that have been determined to be “dedicated to [the] infringement” of IP rights.
The bills contain strict proof requirements for the “rogue site” determination, as well as strong due process safeguards to reduce any risk to legitimate online activities. But recently, a few opponents of the legislation have raised another objection: that the bill “DNS blocking” technique of blocking access to specified websites—regardless of how carefully it is done and how closely it is supervised by federal courts—is risky, unprecedented, and threatens to “break the Internet.”
November 01, 2011, 06:27 pm
By Thomas M. Lenard, president of the Technology Policy Institute.
Congress is now considering legislation to grant the FCC new authority to hold voluntary incentive auctions for spectrum. This legislation would alleviate shortages of spectrum that are threatening to hold back the development of a wireless broadband platform capable of competing with wireline platforms. It would boost the economy and advance our progress toward a more efficient, market-oriented spectrum regime.
The incentive-auction idea, which came out of the Obama Administration’s Broadband Task Force, is aimed at freeing up some of the 120 MHz of spectrum currently used by broadcast TV to make it available for the new wireless uses—primarily broadband—that consumers (and businesses) are demanding. The benefits of such a move are clear: while wireless broadband use is soaring even though consumers have to pay for it, only about 10 percent of TV viewers watch over over-the-air broadcasting even though it is free.
October 21, 2011, 02:47 pm
By Jim Kirkland, vice president and general counsel of Trimble, a founding member of the Coalition to Save Our GPS.
LightSquared has been trying for nearly a year to show that it can provide new broadband services without seriously undermining the critical GPS uses and applications Americans rely on every day. It has consistently failed to make its case. But that hasn’t slowed down a LightSquared public relations barrage proclaiming solution after solution.
This time around it’s new equipment that provides a technical fix for interference, “developed in days” by a small GPS company that has a very large commercial interest in LightSquared being allowed to proceed with its proposed nationwide terrestrial broadband network. Earlier this week, Dr. Javad Ashjaee, the developer of the claimed new technology, declared in The Hill that, “Technology has solved the problem, now we just have to wait for the politicians to catch up.” [LightSquared and GPS can coexist, 10/18/2011].
What many of the politicians Dr. Ashjaee so readily dismisses are doing is something LightSquared and Dr. Ashjaee need to emulate, and that’s wait for the facts to be established by real evidence, not press releases.