"It would seem to me that in the holiday spirit, that both chambers should get together, the tax writing committees, and figure out a solution that is fair to all families," she added.
"It simply eludes me why those at the very top end of the income scale who have taken most of the benefit of growth in the last 20 years, why they are so adverse when they are doing so well to helping our country, and to making sure that everyone has a chance to prosper," she said.
Soon after Kaptur spoke, Rep. John Garamendi (D-Calif.) took the floor and agreed that it's time for the wealthy to "share in the burden of America."
As of late Tuesday night, Congress was struggling to find a way to extend the 2 percent payroll tax cut. Republicans so far oppose any tax hike on those earning more than $1 million a year, as Democrats have proposed.
Sen. Susan Collins (R-Maine) has proposed an extension that would tax millionaire earners, but other Republicans are cool to this proposal. House Republicans are considering other elements that could be in a bill to extend the payroll tax cut, such as language speeding up the approval of the Keystone oil pipeline.