The National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) voted unanimously Thursday to finalize new rules requiring insurance companies to dedicate more revenues directly to healthcare costs.
A few technicalities aside, the NAIC kept their "medical-loss ratio" guidelines largely identical to the draft proposal the group approved in September.
The insurance lobby had fought hard to convince commissioners that the draft would harm consumers' access to coverage, but NAIC members disagreed.
Kansas Insurance Commissioner Sandy Praeger told reporters Thursday that, while there were many amendments on the table, it "wasn't clear" that any one of them would have improved the initial proposal.
HHS likes what it sees
Health and Human Services (HHS) Secretary Kathleen Sebelius was quick to issue a statement saying the rules are "reasonable, achievable for insurers and will help to ensure insurance premiums are, for the most part, supporting health benefits for consumers."
The recommendations now move to HHS, which still has to certify them. The agency plans to draft their MLR guidelines "in the coming weeks," Sebelius said.
The insurance lobby doesn't like what it sees
Karen Ignagni, head of America’s Health Insurance Plans, issued a one-sentence statement saying the current rules, if allowed to stand, "will reduce competition, disrupt coverage, and threaten patients’ access to health plans’ quality improvement services."
Consumer groups cautiously optimistic
Carmen Balber, Washington director for the advocacy group Consumer Watchdog, said the NAIC deserves a great deal of credit for resisting the pressure from insurers to alter the guidelines. Still, Balber said the final language allows plenty of opportunities for the industry to evade the consumer protections.
“Making these rules work will require tough scrutiny of insurance companies’ spending to make sure they don’t use loopholes in the law to pass off overhead costs as health care,” she said in a statement.
Brokers weigh in as well
The insurance brokers lobby had pushed NAIC to consider brokers' fees a healthcare expense for the purpose of calculating medical-loss ratios. It didn't happen, but the National Association of Insurance and Financial Advisors (NAIFA) is hoping that could change down the line.
"While disappointed the NAIC did not believe it has the authority to modify the MLR definition to accommodate agent commissions," the group's president, Terry Headley, said in a statement, "NAIFA is hopeful that the NAIC and HHS will side with consumers by recognizing that agents need to be compensated for the vital assistance they provide consumers in managing day-to-day healthcare issues." http://bit.ly/9y7Njw
Liberal group launches effort to combat misleading healthcare reform ads
A coalition of liberal health and labor advocates launched a phone campaign this week designed to combat conservative claims that the healthcare law will steal benefits from seniors — claims Health Care for America Now (HCAN) says are false.
Read more...