Yearning for a brokered GOP convention

Getty Images

For years, political junkies have yearned for a brokered national convention. But to their quadrennial dismay, old-style floor fights and smoke-filled rooms have given way to a modern presidential nominating process based on hard-fought primaries and media-generated momentum.

Because of the nature of the current Republican nomination battle, however, the possibility of an open convention has become less far-fetched than usual. It could happen this time, especially if Donald TrumpDonald TrumpDNC vice chairwoman apologizes to Sanders 7 pieces of advice for Hillary Clinton Sanders optimistic on future of 'revolution' MORE wins more delegates than any other candidate, but falls short of the required majority. Rival forces would then try to take him down in the full glare of a convention brawl.

The last open GOP convention was held 68 years ago, when New York Gov. Thomas E. Dewey won the 1948 nomination on the third ballot. More recently, party elites have united around likely victors — based on key primary wins and national poll numbers — well before the eventual nominees accumulated delegate majorities. That happened with Mitt Romney in 2012, John McCainJohn McCainSyria activists cheer Kaine pick Clinton brings in the heavy hitters Guess which Cuban-American 2016 candidate best set themselves up for 2020? MORE in 2008, George W. Bush in 2000 and Bob Dole in 1996. Of course, these were all conventional politicians.

But Trump is not a conventional politician. He has never held office, voted for or against a bill in Congress or executed a public policy decision. Ideologically, he's undiscovered territory. Stylistically, he says things other politicians would never utter, and the media covers every syllable. Trump is sui generis, and that terrifies the party's high command.

Should Trump go to Cleveland with a near majority of delegates — let's say 50 or 60 votes shy of the 1,236 needed to win — it's probable he could wheel-and-deal his way to a majority. But if he's short by a couple of hundred delegates, all bets are off.

To beat Trump, his adversaries would need to unite around a single alternative. If Texas Sen. Ted CruzTed CruzTeam Clinton: Sanders will help campaign take on 'rigged system' Clinton brings in the heavy hitters Wasserman Schultz drama overshadows Dem convention MORE runs second, he would position himself as the natural choice, an outsider who is also a true conservative. Nevertheless, making the delegate math work for Cruz would be difficult as long as Trump stays in the race. Cruz would have to fuse together around Trump a coalition of his own base (ideologues, evangelicals, Tea Party supporters) with center-right establishment types (Florida Sen. Marco RubioMarco RubioClinton brings in the heavy hitters Guess which Cuban-American 2016 candidate best set themselves up for 2020? Budowsky: Why Warren masters Trump MORE, New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie, former Florida Gov. Jeb Bush, Ohio Gov. John Kasich and former Hewlett-Packard CEO Carly Fiorina). That would be a tall order, indeed.

An easier path out of deadlock would be a Trump-Cruz ticket. Such a combination would give Trump what he wants, the presidential nomination, and give the 45-year old Cruz, should he accept it, a national platform to shape a future presidential bid. Of course, it would also give party professionals palpitations. But at that point, they may not have the votes to stop it.

Should he fare well in the primaries, Rubio would be in a strong position to unite anti-Trump factions as a compromise choice. He could move right, or center, as needed, and he'd have a much better chance (at least based on current poll numbers) of convincing party activists that he would beat probably Democratic nominee Hillary ClintonHillary Rodham ClintonGore: I'm voting for Clinton Christian voters left wanting in Trump vs Clinton DNC vice chairwoman apologizes to Sanders MORE. The same could apply to Christie. His bluntness would appeal to populists looking for a strong leader and establishment types looking for a winner.

But what if nobody can break the deadlock? One option is for Trump to play kingmaker and to throw his support to someone else. Another option is to look outside the box––House Speaker Paul RyanPaul RyanTrump, Clinton intelligence briefings likely to start next week Clinton maps out first 100 days Why a bill about catfish will show whether Ryan's serious about regulatory reform MORE (R-Wis.), perhaps? But that's highly doubtful; party activists would be infuriated.

There is also party Rule 40 to consider. It requires that a GOP presidential candidate must have a majority of the delegates from each of at least eight states to be placed into nomination at the convention. If that obscure directive isn't changed, it could alter the dynamics of a floor fight in unpredictable ways.

Extraordinary nomination scenarios like these have a way of exploding in the fire of combat. But if Republicans go to Cleveland without a nominee, and have to face multiple ballots to select one, there is one thing we know for sure: Political junkies all over America will rejoice in the drama. It may even be worth the 68-year wait.

Faucheux is president of Clarus Research Group, a nonpartisan polling firm based in Washington. He has taught courses in politics at George Washington University and is the author or editor of seven books on politics, including "Running for Office." He also publishes Lunchtime Politics, a daily newsletter on polls.

More in Presidential Campaign

Which GOP pols will actually attend the convention?

Read more »