The Judiciary

Obama's Supreme legacy

I’m loving the drama that is unfolding around President Barack Obama’s nomination of Solicitor General Elena Kagan to the Supreme Court.

Conservatives are, true to form, bungling the narrative they should be rightfully pushing — an unqualified liberal just chomping at the bit to legislate from the bench. Meanwhile, Miss Kagan’s record on anything that might reveal her jurisprudence is so sparse that liberals are beginning to get a little skittish on just how she may rule on various issues.

Read More...

No chumps from the ‘heartland’ on the Supreme Court, please

If Elena Kagan is confirmed, says Christopher Edley Jr., who spent 23 years teaching law at Harvard, we will have an entire Supreme Court educated at Harvard and Yale law schools. This is good, he writes in an op-ed in The Washington Post, because our legal culture “values uncommon smarts.” The Supreme Court is not just all theater and dressing up. “At the Supreme Court level, it's all about finding oracles for Olympus,” he writes. You won’t find chumps at Harvard or Yale. These are schools for "the elite.” Better than some other law schools that would satisfy the “heartland.” But I’m not so sure about Yale. Cordelia, the archetypal pretty girl on "Buffy the Vampire Slayer," says that Yale is only a dumping ground for people who can’t get into Harvard.

Read More...

Double standard for professional women

Is she or isn’t she?

Can you believe it? Elena Kagan is such a strategically brilliant nominee to the Supreme Court — smart, centrist, popular, no paper trail, gonzo resume — that increasingly desperate opponents are reduced to asking:

Is she or isn’t she — a lesbian?

Read More...

Here we go again: Lights, camera, theater

As cameras pan in on hostile questioners on the Senate Judiciary Committee during the confirmation hearing on Solicitor General Elena Kagan’s nomination to the Supreme Court, I’ll be watching to see if Republican senators can keep a straight face.

These folks who precluded Kagan’s earlier nomination to a federal judgeship (ironically, it went instead to John Roberts, if I remember correctly) will find it difficult, I should think, not to crack a smile as they now challenge her lack of judicial experience. It’s reminiscent of the joke about the kid convicted of killing his parents asking the sentencing court for leniency because he’s an orphan.

Read More...

The Supreme Court: Gay bar?

There was a time in the not-so-distant past when some of us thought that "sexual orientation" was a briefing on getting it on ... you know, those classes in high school we loved to attend where the prune-faced teacher told us about the birds and the bees, until some puckered-up parents group would scorch the Board of Education.

But now we find it's really about the Supreme Court and TV shows and politicians pandering to those who cling to their Neanderthal cruel values. It's about who is doing it with whom ... particularly if it’s the birds and the birds or bees and the bees.

Read More...

Kagan's electoral mark on Congress

With the announcement that Solicitor General Elena Kagan has been nominated to replace retiring Justice John Paul Stevens on the Supreme Court, A.B. Stoddard is joined by Chris Kofinis and John Feehery to discuss her confirmation process and its impact on Congress.

Read More...

Obama judges

Much attention will be focused in the ensuing months on the appointment of Elena Kagan to the United States Supreme Court, deservedly. The merit of her appointment will be debated, as it should be. Unfortunately, less attention is being paid by the United States Senate, the media and the American public to the overall record of President Obama’s judicial appointments to the federal trial courts and courts of appeals. It is there where the overwhelming volume of cases is adjudicated. While the Supreme Court decided 71 cases in the 2007-08 term, for example, the trial and appellate courts during that period decided 30,000 cases.

Read More...

Courting Kagan

It is appropriate they waited for Vice President Biden to be back in town before President Obama announced Elena Kagan as his nominee to replace Justice John Paul Stevens on the Supreme Court. This is, after all, a big deal. Besides, Kagan had been an adviser to then-Sen. Biden (D-Del.).

Read More...

SCOTUS to play violent video games

Do violent video games inspire kids to commit acts of violence?

There are not two parents in this country who have not had that conversation between themselves and with their friends. But it’s soon going to go a lot higher: all the way to the Supreme Court.

This week, the court agreed to review the constitutionality of a California law banning the sale of violent video games to minors. It’s a law that sponsors say is necessary to protect children from violence, but which video game-makers denounce as a violation of the First Amendment.

Read More...

The Supreme Court: Out of its (Ivy) league

Whatever else one says about Barack Obama, we can all agree that this is a man who battles to this day to overcome the disadvantages of his youth.

I refer, of course, to his Ivy League education. We can certainly admire his commitment to mingle with the common folk, even as we witness his struggles with the sense of superiority that for many graduates is Harvard's legacy. Or Yale's, or Princeton's, or the other Ivy ivory towers’.

Read More...

Pages