The Hill
Sunday, September 07, 2008
SEARCH
Home
HillTube
Mobile
White Papers Portal
CONVENTIONS
Democratic
Republican
BLOGS
Pundits Blog
Congress Blog
Blog Briefing Room
NEWS
Leading The News
Business & Lobbying
K Street Insiders
John Breaux
John Engler
Vin Weber
Dave Wenhold
The Executive
Campaign 2008
Endorsements '08
COLUMNISTS
Dick Morris
A.B. Stoddard
Brent Budowsky
Ben Goddard
David Hill
David Keene
Josh Marshall
Mark Mellman
Jim Mills
Markos Moulitsas (Kos)
Byron York
COMMENT
Editorial
Letters
Op-eds
Weyant's World
CAPITAL LIVING
Today's Stories
50 Most Beautiful 2008
Other Features
In The Know
Bookshelf
Food & Drink
Onward and Upward
Hillscape
RESOURCES
Classifieds
Subscribe
Order Reprints
Last Six Issues
Useful Links
RSS


Home arrow David Hill arrow Death penalty views shifting
David Hill PDF Print E-mail
Death penalty views shifting
Posted: 12/14/05 12:00 AM [ET]

Widespread publicity given this week to the execution of ex-gang leader and convicted murderer Stanley “Tookie” Williams in California probably made many Americans think again about their views on capital punishment. Or did it? Are Americans’ views about the death penalty in transition, subject to new information or arguments? Or are opinions about capital punishment impervious to change?

Public opinion on most trendy issues is not worth considering. Voters know too little to merit much attention being given to their views. But the death penalty is different. Most Americans have well-thought-out and relatively stable views on the whole range of related issues. Do you favor or oppose the death penalty? Has administration of the death penalty been handled fairly, or not? Does the death penalty serve as a deterrent to crime, or not? For most of us, these are relatively easy questions to answer. We’ve thought about the issues, tested our views through discussions and firmed our beliefs.

The longest running time series on capital punishment is maintained by The Gallup Poll. The stability of Gallup’s results bolsters the notion that most Americans have settled views on this issue. Since 1976, Gallup has not recorded support for the death penalty below 62 percent. Typically, the percentage supporting capital punishment has been in the high 60s to low 70s.

The last Gallup sounding on the issue was taken in October of this year. In that survey, 64 percent were for the death penalty and 30 percent were against it. Six percent expressed no opinion. When that poll was released, some advocacy groups opposed to the death penalty hailed the results, saying that support for the death penalty was the lowest it had been in a quarter century. That grandiose interpretation of the poll results, of course, involved some political spin, but it’s entirely true. And it’s worth adding that the 30 percent opposing the death penalty represented only the second time since 1972 that opposition exceeded 28 percent. So something indeed may be happening regarding public opinion on the death penalty.

One factor in this shift is the visible role that DNA evidence has begun to play in the judicial process. DNA has proven just enough wrongful convictions to make more Americans suspicious. A May 2005 poll by Gallup found that 59 percent of Americans believed that an innocent man or woman had been wrongly executed in the past five years. On average, these skeptical Americans suspected that 10 to 11 percent of those executed are really innocent.

While DNA evidence and other belated discoveries of innocence will change a few hearts and minds about the appropriateness of the death penalty, these shifts are episodic, based on the latest headlines and stories. These provide no foundation for a permanent, longer-term transition in public opinion. That will only come about because of a growing culture of life in American politics.

I believe that more church-goers and people of faith are starting to make a connection between their opposition to abortion and euthanasia and their position on capital punishment. This is hard work for many, particularly for Republicans. It creates what psychologists call “cognitive dissonance.” Polls routinely show that 80 percent of Republicans approve of the death penalty. So, to champion life imprisonment as an alternative to execution requires considerable courage for any Republican.

During my career, though, I have had several GOP clients comfortably opposed to the death penalty. Three-term Gov. John Engler of Michigan steadfastly opposed the death penalty. And four-term Gov. Terry Branstad of Iowa opposed the death penalty, except in one limited circumstance, where witnesses are killed. Both men are Catholic, so they found it easy to reconcile their values with their politics.

More evangelical Christians will follow the lead of Catholics over the next decade. As in the 1960s and 1970s, the division of public opinion on the death penalty will narrow during the next decade.

Hill is director of Hill Research Consultants, a Texas-based firm that has polled for GOP candidates and causes since 1988.

 
 
 
BLOGS
ADVERTISER
Home | Privacy Policy | Terms And Conditions
The Hill
1625 K Street, NW Suite 900
Washington, DC 20006
202-628-8500 tel | 202-628-8503 fax

The contents of this site are © 2008 Capitol Hill Publishing Corp., a subsidiary of News Communications, Inc.