THE HILL
 

White House turns to data and Schwarzenegger to defend stimulus

By Walter Alarkon - 10/30/09 12:58 PM ET

The Obama administration on Friday touted reports of 640,000 stimulus jobs, the latest economic numbers and the backing of a Republican governor to try to undercut GOP attacks on the effect of its massive $787 billion package.

Reports released Friday afternoon showed that stimulus projects, such as highway and other infrastructure work, have directly saved or created 640,329 jobs, Vice President Joe Biden said. White House officials said a total of about 1 million jobs have been created or saved by the stimulus when taking into account the roughly 400,000 jobs that come from the economic effect of tax cuts, increased Pell Grants and other direct payments not measured in Friday's reports.

"I can say, without fear of being contradicted by a responsible source, that so far we have created over a million jobs," Biden said.

Biden also noted that the GDP grew by a 3.5 percent annualized rate in the third quarter of 2009, marking the first time the economy expanded since last year's second quarter. Economists "left, right and center have attributed [the growth] to the Recovery Act," he added.

The White House said the latest data are signs the economy is getting back on track and that "the much-maligned and battered Recovery Act," as Biden described it, is actually working.

Republicans at every turn have cast skepticism on the stimulus's positive effect. They've noted that the unemployment rate, less than 8 percent when President Barack Obama took office, is now at nearly 10 percent.

Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.) said it was "bewildering" to hear the White House's 1 million stimulus job claim. McConnell said that the Obama administration had "sold its trillion-dollar spending plan this spring as a guarantee against unemployment reaching 8 percent," a reference to White House projections in January that the stimulus would keep down the jobless rate.

"Today it's nearly 10 percent," he said.

Republicans believe their attacks on the stimulus are working. A Senate Republican aide pointed to a New York Times/CBS poll last month that found just 7 percent of Americans believe the package has already created jobs. The survey, however, did find that most Americans, 52 percent, think the act will eventually create jobs, and that a plurality, 47 percent, believe it will make things better in the long run.

The White House made a concerted effort this week to show that the latest hard count of stimulus jobs was credible and less vulnerable to attack than previously released stimulus reports. Two weeks ago, Republicans suggested that data showing that $16 billion in stimulus contracts had saved or created 30,083 jobs served as evidence that the stimulus wasn't doing much. This week, the Associated Press reviewed the contracts and found that the jobs number was "overstated by thousands." The White House Thursday issued a release calling the story "misleading" and noting that it focused on just 2 percent of stimulus spending.

Biden appeared Friday with California Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger, one of a handful of Republicans outside Washington who publicly pushed for the White House's stimulus package.

"This is not something that is a Democrat issue here or a Republican issue; this is a people's issue," Schwarzenegger said. "It's a jobs issue. It's all about jobs, jobs, jobs."

Schwarzenegger also took on GOP suggestions that the stimulus reports have shown that the package hasn't had much effect. He said the data to be posted Friday afternoon will show that California, struggling to close a $60 billion deficit, has seen more than 100,000 jobs as a direct result of the package, the most of any state.

"This is also what our numbers show," Schwarzenegger added.

The data is available online at the White House's stimulus website, recovery.gov. The reports come from all 50 states and aim to show the result of about $159 billion in stimulus spending. About $340 billion in stimulus money has been spent so far.

Administration officials said the estimate of 1 million stimulus jobs created or saved so far isn't "perfect," but they said that it's in line with independent projections by the Congressional Budget Office and Moody's.

Jared Bernstein, the chief economist to the vice president, said that reports suggest that the stimulus is "on track" to hit the White House target of ultimately saving or creating 3.5 million jobs by the end of next year. The 640,329 jobs that are a direct result of the stimulus come from just 20 percent of stimulus spending, White House officials noted.

"A lot more ammunition left in this job package," Bernstein said.

This story was updated at 6:15 p.m.

Source:
http://thehill.com/homenews/administration/65651-white-house-turns-to-data-and-schwarzenegger-to-defend-stimulus

Comments (8)

640,000 stimulus jobs…right and I have a pink pony to sell you…Where are these make believe jobs???BY bailedout on 10/30/2009 at 15:31
Biden has been drinking too much of that non alcoholic beer again. Yes, we have 320,000 people digging holes and another 320,000 people coming along and filling them up.BY tinman1967 on 10/30/2009 at 15:34
Hmmm, the number mysteriously grows again, the yarn spinning in this white house knows no bounds. What this admin and a lot of folks on the hill fail to recognize is that most of these so called jobs are government related and not a product of a healthy sustained economy. Any government can hire 100,000 people and say that unemployment fell by the same number but at the end of the job are these jobs still viable, I think not or else the gov't would have to dream up another job. The economy may not be as bad as some say and it certainly isn't as good as others say, but we absolutely don't need embellished and over-empasized stats that only creates a recovery founded upon a ready made bubble ready to burst again.BY Winfield on 10/30/2009 at 17:16
JOBS, JOBS, JOBS - THE I'LL BE BACK GUY DOESN'T KNOW WHAT THE ((*((*) HE'S TALKING ABOUT - I HAVE BEEN OUT OF WORK FOR NEARLY 2 YEARS - THE REPUBLICANS ARE STOPPIING THE EXTENSION TO UNEMPLOYMENT BENEFITS - I AM INVOLVED WITH A LARGE GROUP OF UNEMPLOYED THAT ARE NOT GOING TO VOTE IN 2012. WE ARE SO SICK OF CONGRESS WE COULD VOMIT…BY Denise on 10/30/2009 at 21:04
Denise, I'm sorry that you have been unemployed for so long, and I hope they extend the benefits for folks like you. I went thru a stint of unemployment and underemployment but luckily I'm one of the Californians who is benefiting from the stimulus. As a salesman of design software, a good percentage of my recent sales have been to companies who are working on projects that wouldn't exist if it weren't for the stimulus. Things are getting better; it just doesn't seem like it when it's YOU that doesn't have a job. Best of luck to you.BY Smilinjack on 10/30/2009 at 23:23
Yes,sunset blvd got a face lift with stimulas money,matched by local taxes.Therein lies the problem.{lies}.The stimulas is causing Calif to rob the gas tax and cig tax to do the feds bidding,just like too big to fail the calif voters are hoodwinked.We will not be able to choose our needs and reductions in state spending as the state has turned control to washington mandates.Soon there will be no need for local elections,we will just follow whatever party is in the whitehouse wants us to do.Crazy.California most likely will drag the us economy down for years.We won't hear about that though.BY jblack on 10/31/2009 at 10:21
Further proof that Schwartzy is a Democrat in disguise…BY Dred on 10/31/2009 at 13:55
Gov. S. supports the White House's, falacious claims while his state has given billions of our collective tax burdens in "sub-awards" to "Education-related Organizations that CA has not named, identified at all, as required by the alleged "Recovery Act"? These collusive statements, selective censorship and distortions of facts are an integral part of all political parties' all persuasions', all bureaucrats', all politicians' - in conjunction with all Media's- corrupt intent to herd the Middle Class towards silence and acceptance, but at the end of the canyon which is nearing will be the Middle Class's extinction.BY mimi on 11/01/2009 at 10:16

Add Comment

Name (required)

E-Mail (will not be published) (required)

Your Comments

You need Flash Player 8 (or higher) and JavaScript enabled to view this content

Get latest news from The Hill direct to your inbox, RSS reader and mobile devices.