THE HILL
 

Speaker Pelosi agrees to plan to scold Rep. Wilson for 'You lie' outburst

By Mike Soraghan - 09/11/09 11:32 AM ET

Speaker Nancy Pelosi has agreed the House should vote next week on scolding Rep. Joe Wilson (R-S.C.) for his outburst during President Barack Obama's speech unless he apologies on the floor of the House.

"There was a violation of the rules of the House," said Pelosi spokesman Brendan Daly. "It needs to be resolved by an apology or a resolution."

A Democrat will introduce a "resolution of disapproval" Monday or Tuesday unless Wilson formally apologizes on the House floor. The House returns Monday.

Wilson shouted "You lie!" Wednesday night during Obama's speech to a joint
session of Congress, after Obama said his health care plan would not cover
illegal immigrants.

Wilson apologized Wednesday evening and, on Thursday, Obama said he accepted Wilson’s apology.

Wilson spokesman Ryan Murphy indicated the congressman will not apologize on the House floor.

Murphy told the Associated Press Wilson "apologized to the president and the president accepted and said let's move on and have a civil discourse, and the congressman agrees."

Several House leaders and many rank-and-file Democrats pushed Thursday for some sanction against Wilson. Pelosi (D-Calif.) knocked down the idea, saying it would distract Congress from its work on healthcare.

“It’s time for us to talk about healthcare, not Joe Wilson," Pelosi said Thursday, adding, "I think his action spoke for itself. He has apologized. He will figure out what is appropriate for him to do."

Pelosi relented after her fellow Democratic leaders made their case in private during a meeting in her office Thursday afternoon, according to sources.

House Majority Whip James Clyburn – a fellow South Carolinian – was particularly angry that Wilson called the White House to apologize Wednesday night only after being pressed by Republican leaders.

"He has no remorse whatsoever, so his words have very little meaning," Clyburn said.

The line at Wilson's Capitol office was consistently busy Friday. But other Republicans say Pelosi should have stuck to her original position.

"Rep. Wilson apologized to the President, and the President accepted his apology. As the Speaker said yesterday, now it's time to talk about health care," said Michael Steel, spokesman for House Minority Leader John Boehner (R-Ohio).

It is against House rules to impugn the integrity of the president when speaking on the floor or in committee meetings.

Clyburn reportedly approached Wilson three times during a vote Thursday asking Wilson to formally apologize.

House leadership, including GOP leader John Boehner (Ohio), also talked to Wilson during Thursday's vote, which was kept open for a longer than normal period of time so that Wilson would have a chance to say "I'm sorry."

Despite Clyburn's efforts, Wilson refused to make an apology on the floor.

When asked about the conversation on the floor, Boehner told reporters "he did have a conversation with Mr. Wilson. I'm not going to relay the contents of my private conversation with him."

As for whether Wilson should apologize in the chamber, Boehner responded "I think that Mr. Wilson made it clear that he said his behavior was inappropriate, and he apologized [to the President] for it. And I'm glad he did."

After his outburst, photos of the congressman, mouth agape and finger pointing, dominated television screens and news sites.

His House website crashed and he was the No. 1 search on Yahoo on Thursday.

His Democratic opponent raised more than half a million dollars off his comment and his Democratic colleagues discussed censuring him.

On conservative Fox News commentator Sean Hannity’s show, Wilson reiterated that he shouldn’t have yelled at the president. But he added Obama’s claim that illegal immigrants not being covered in the Democrats’ heath bill was “just wrong.”

-- This article was updated at 1:37 p.m. and 4:12 p.m.


Source:
http://thehill.com/homenews/house/58331-dems-lay-plans-to-scold-wilson

Comments (188)

Don't apologize anymore Joe. Those Liberal idiots can kiss your rear end. Better yet tell them you'll do it right after Rangel apologizes for being a tax cheat and Watson apologizes for being a communist.Off I go to the Joe Wilson site to make another donation.BY MusicCityVic on 09/11/2009 at 13:06
Why would you punish Wilson, and no one punished the Dems when they booed so louding during Pres. Bush SOU in '05????? Why don't you all concentrate on the issues!!!! So hypocritcalBY Kim on 09/11/2009 at 13:12
Are they going to put him in the stocks? Dunk him in the Pond What? This is getting hillarious..Pompous A**'sI called Senator Reid and told him to personally congratulate Wilson for his honesty and integrity. Maybe everyone should call their representatives and tell them to thank Wilson for being honestBY M and M on 09/11/2009 at 13:16
WHAT HYPOCRITES!!!!! !!!!!! After all the disgusting disrespectful antics directed at President Bush for years, they have the unmitigated gall to go after Joe Wilson for expressing the honest sentiment of the majority of Americans.What a shame Wilson backed down as he would have become a hero to the majority of Americans who can't seem to be heard or believed by their ELECTED SERVANTS.BY Heather on 09/11/2009 at 13:20
I guess Freedom of Speech doesn't extend to the hallowed halls of our Congress (at least not while Democrats are "in charge")!!! I applaud Joe's outburst. You did not hear me (though half the neighborhood probably did) as I sat in my home and listened to the President. Almost every "point" he made was an out right lie or a "blame it on someone else, it wasn't me" statement. There is only so much that anyone can take from our elected officials. GOOD JOB JOE!!!!! Don't let up!!!!BY Michael Long on 09/11/2009 at 13:22
If anyone is a "LIAR", Wilson clearly is. Less than 50% of people born in the US could legally "Prove" they are citizens and thus eligible. I guess we need to cancel millions of health insurance policies. Citizenship has NEVER been a requirement for Social Security or Medicare, only prior quarterly work credits and employee contributions determine eligibility.BY Miguel on 09/11/2009 at 13:35
If there is a law that says it is illegal to allow children under the age of 18 to see an X-rated skin flick then that law pre-supposes that there is going to be somebody that will see that people who are "OBVIOUSLY" not eighteen will be stopped from going into the flick. And if in doubt, check their IDs. If on the other hand there is a policy to not check anybodys ID, even if they are "OBVIOUSLY" not 18 then the law is a lie.It is that way with the Health Care Bill. There is a law that no federal funds will be spent on illegals but there is also a statement that no one will be refused due to any personnel circumstance. No body will be checking to see if there are illegals checking into the horror movie called Obamacare.BY gazinya on 09/11/2009 at 13:36
Rep. Joe Wilson has my vote for President in 2012, and my money. I am not from So. Carolina, but I let my senators and representatives know that I want them to support Joe Wilson, and I also let them know that I donated more money to his campaign today, than I did to their campaign in the past. My state reps are going to need to be bold to get my money.BY Thanks Joe! on 09/11/2009 at 13:50
Good. Bring. It. On.Wilson should go to the floor with a television set, and play the video of the Dem caucus booing Bush during the State Of The Union address in 2005. He should then apologize and ask every Dem still seated today to apologize to Bush. He should also ask that Harry Reid apologize for calling Bush a loser. Let's see who steps up and who looks stupid.BY GJMerits on 09/11/2009 at 13:59
I agree with Dems: forget health care reform, we want to know how many NoDoz pills Wilson popped before his "behavioral outburst"?BY Caffeine forever on 09/11/2009 at 14:07

Add Comment

Name (required)

E-Mail (will not be published) (required)

Your Comments

You need Flash Player 8 (or higher) and JavaScript enabled to view this content

Get latest news from The Hill direct to your inbox, RSS reader and mobile devices.