THE HILL
 

Pelosi: No House vote on 'single-payer' plan

By Mike Soraghan - 11/06/09 11:45 AM ET

The House will not vote on a liberal Democratic plan to have a fully government-run "single-payer" healthcare plan, House Speaker Nancy Pelosi announced Friday.
 
Pelosi (D-Calif.) declined to pursue a single-payer plan in the healthcare overhaul. But Rep. Anthony Weiner (D-N.Y.) secured a commitment from leadership in July to have an "up-or-down vote" on the single-payer approach during floor debate. He got it in exchange for liberal support of a compromise with Blue Dogs on the public health insurance option in the Energy and Commerce Committee.
 

The amendment almost certainly would have lost, but would have demonstrated what support there is among Democrats for single-payer.
 
But as the vote, now planned for Saturday, has neared, Pelosi has seemed increasingly reluctant to open the bill up for any amendments, even from her own party.
 
Weiner said Friday after Pelosi's announcement that he didn't want his push for a vote to interfere with passing the healthcare bill, which is proving difficult enough for Democratic leaders. He said that vote counting efforts turned up complaints that a single-payer vote could put some centrist lawmakers in a bind, caught between their liberal base and their more conservative constituents.
 
"I didn't want the legacy of single-payer to be that it jeopardized passage of healthcare reform this year," Weiner said.
 
Pelosi's praised Weiner as "tireless and effective advocate for progress on healthcare."
 
"His decision not to offer a single-payer amendment during consideration of H.R. 3962 is a correct one and helps advance the passage of important health reforms by this Congress," Pelosi said in a statement, which was echoed by Energy and Commerce Chairman Henry Waxman (D-Calif.), who negotiated the July deal.

Pelosi's announcement was followed a few minutes later by a news release from Weiner's office.

“I have decided not to offer a single payer alternative to the health reform bill at this time," Weiner said in the release. "Given how fluid the negotiations are on the final push to get comprehensive health care reform that covers millions of Americans and contains costs through a public option, I became concerned that my amendment might undermine that important goal.

"I've discussed the issue with Speaker Pelosi, Chairman Waxman, and agree with them that the health reform bill is so close it deserves every chance to gain a majority," he added.
 
Some members had hinted that Pelosi might schedule a vote on a stand-alone single-payer bill, but Pelosi did not mention that in her announcement.

This story was updated at 12:30 p.m.

Source:
http://thehill.com/homenews/house/66721-pelosi-no-house-vote-on-single-payer-plan

Comments (66)

So Pelosi doesn't want to allow any amendment to close the loopholes that allow illegal aliens to get health benefits — despite numerous statements from Obama that illegals wouldn't be covered. So OBAMA LIED!!BY Joe on 11/06/2009 at 12:04
This is all gamesmanship and tactical moves to get the bill passed with enough Blue Dog support to shove it over the wall to the Senate.My only real resentment is the refusal to put the few thousand pages out on the internet [as promised] so the media,lobbyists ,and interested citizens can actually make an effort to see what is really in the bill.BY bjcass on 11/06/2009 at 12:23
…and Bush never, ever lied.BY Hank Missenheim_Jr on 11/06/2009 at 12:24
This bill is not reform. This should not pass. Real reform would be tort reform, the ability to buy over state lines and Health Savings Accounts. Please keep your hands off my health care!BY Joan Ryder on 11/06/2009 at 12:26
I wonder how many arms were twisted to the breaking point to get this concession. Right, Joe. I never had any doubt that Mr. O lied and has lied and will keep on lying or to put it more politically correct "shading the truth."They are so … bent on getting this monstrosity passed that I think they would sell their souls to the devil in order to accomplish it. I hope it does not happen, not becuase I am not a liberal, but becuase it spells doom for this country, its healthcare system and its economy. Sorry mess. I sure hope Ms. Pelosi is out of that seat ASAP as she is totally out in left field and out of touch with the American people.BY moey on 11/06/2009 at 12:27
No, Obama did NOT lie. By the time he is finished, we will have widespread amnesty and there will be NO ILLEGALS. See how that works?BY Susan Haughton on 11/06/2009 at 12:32
pelosi you will be long gone and your dead end street in Baltimore will be a monument to you trying to destroy the United States of America and losing. I hope your kids and great grand kids learn to live with the destructive nature and selfish booglemucks of their grand mother.You PELLOSI AND OBAMA will pass just like gas does and we will retake the Hill and throw the incompetent MARXIST OUT OUT OUT. This Democrat Congress and Adminstration will go down as the biggest criminals in the History of the United StatesBY jake2 on 11/06/2009 at 12:34
Mr. Missenheim:Quit whining about Bush…This guy's ENTIRE PRESIDENCY IS A LIE !! Obama is an empty-suited fraud and is now illustrating his total incompetence as a leader. We all should have known (some of us, indeed, did and warned others) that he has never led or managed anything of consequence in his life. Those who voted for him deserve what they got. Unfortunately, the rest of us and, even more outrageously, our beloved Constitution and Country are burdened with this disaster!BY irishbill on 11/06/2009 at 12:37
I am surprised Pelosi sold out to the insurance companies.BY Edward Craig on 11/06/2009 at 12:42
If she had the votes she has bragged about nothing would stop her from ramming that Health Care down our throats. There are too many that are really worried about their jobs if they vote for another huge Americans budget busting bill. And they know this is a sneak attack with no input from anyone but the select small handfull that wrote this fiasco. Hopefully the Congress is finely taking notice of what the people want with their emails, calls and gatherings in DC and around America.BY Dmac/ID on 11/06/2009 at 12:44

Add Comment

Name (required)

E-Mail (will not be published) (required)

Your Comments

You need Flash Player 8 (or higher) and JavaScript enabled to view this content

Get latest news from The Hill direct to your inbox, RSS reader and mobile devices.