By J. Taylor Rushing - 10/18/09 09:20 PM EDT
In the war over healthcare reform in the Senate, a little skirmish has broken out — should Americans get vaccinated against swine flu, or is it a big-government initiative that should be avoided?
Right-wing pundits like Glenn Beck and Rush Limbaugh have recently spoken out against government direction on the H1N1 vaccine, saying that individuals should make up their own minds whether to get vaccinated or not. Some left-wing pundits, such as Bill Maher, have made similar statements.
“We have some very fine scientists,” said Sen. Bernard Sanders (I-Vt.). ”I think people ought to make the decision for themselves. But between you and me, if I had to make a choice between Rush Limbaugh and some of our government scientists, I would stay with the scientists.”
According to an analysis by The Hill, 42 Democrats in the House and Senate have followed Sanders’ lead by cutting public service announcements. Only four Republicans have followed suit — Sens. Lisa MurkowskiLisa MurkowskiThe Hill's 12:30 Report Bishop eyes new Puerto Rico bill after recess Week ahead: Senate looks to wrap up energy, water spending bill MORE of Alaska, Jim RischJim RischSen. Cory Gardner endorses Cruz GOP lawmakers vie for convention power GOP senator on endorsing Cruz: 'I guess it depends on your definition' MORE of Idaho and Mike JohannsMike JohannsTo buy a Swiss company, ChemChina must pass through Washington Republican senator vows to block nominees over ObamaCare co-ops Revisiting insurance regulatory reform in a post-crisis world MORE of Nebraska and Rep. Jo Emerson of Missouri. Former Senate Majority Leader Bill Frist (R-Tenn.) has also promoted the vaccine.
Limbaugh, on a recent radio show, lambasted the Obama administration and Health and Human Services Secretary Kathleen Sebelieus for admonishing the country to get vaccinated. Limbaugh said he has never been urged by a doctor to get vaccinated, and punctuated his commentary by saying, “Screw you, Ms. Sebelius, I’m not going to take it, precisely because you’re now telling me I must… Have you heard of the concept of liberty and freedom?”
Sebelius has stressed that the vaccinations are voluntary, and that the Obama administration is not attempting any kind of mandatory requirement.
But Senate Republicans are distancing themselves from Limbaugh’s remarks, saying they understand the concern over the vaccine and individual choice — although they plan to take it.
“It’s everybody’s individual decision they’ve got to make. I’ll probably take one. My doctor told me to,” said Sen. Saxby ChamblissSaxby ChamblissWyden hammers CIA chief over Senate spying Cruz is a liability Inside Paul Ryan’s brain trust MORE (R-Ga.). “I do think it should be everybody’s decision, like a normal flu shot. I don’t think the government ought to mandate it to anybody.”
“I would urge people to get the vaccine,” said Senate GOP Policy Chairman John ThuneJohn ThuneAir traffic control plan faces tough fight ahead GOP blasts Obama for slow economic growth Overnight Tech: Business data deals on FCC agenda MORE (R-S.D.).
Likewise, Republicans like Sen. Orrin HatchOrrin HatchInversion rule: latest example of government overreach Supreme Court wrestles with corruption law IRS: Annual unpaid tax liability was 8B MORE (R-Utah) agree, saying they understand the anxiety but plan to receive the vaccine anyway.
“People are always concerned when they see a product that is formulated so quickly, especially in the area of vaccinations,” Hatch told The Hill. “But talking to people at HHS, it’s absolutely crucial, especially for vulnerable people in our population.”
Democrats are also standing behind the Obama administration, saying the vaccinations are necessary to prevent the extreme young or old from falling ill.
“It’s a pretty deadly virus, within certain age groups,” said Sen. Mark PryorMark PryorEx-Sen. Kay Hagan joins lobby firm Top Democrats are no advocates for DC statehood Ex-Sen. Landrieu joins law and lobby firm MORE (D-Ark.). “Certainly those folks should get vaccinated. Apparently you get a really high fever, and there’s already been some reported cases in my state.”
The debate over a swine flu shot is even reaching into some Capitol Hill offices, causing an internal debate over image.
“It is an image issue,” said Sen. Sam Brownback (R-Kan.). “There’s pressure in my office for me to take it, for an image issue to show that it’s safe. I don’t know what mitigates the most, whether I should take it or I shouldn’t take it.”