|
As minority voters abandoned the GOP in droves this past
cycle, those who will vote on the next chairman of the Republican Party are
struggling with the difficult issue of race. The Democrats are seen as having advantages:
Traditionally they have won more minority voters, and now the party will be led
by the first African-American president. And, for Republicans, race proves to
be a particularly thorny issue that can cause problems for even the most
adept political operators. The most recent example came when former Tennessee GOP
chairman Chip Saltsman, a candidate for chairman of the Republican National
Committee, sent a CD with a parody song called "Barack the Magic
Negro" to RNC members. First reported by The Hill, the CD set off a wave
of criticism and elicited sharp rebukes from several prominent voting members.That incident came on top of a number of gaffes
throughout the 2008 election. In September, Rep. Lynn Westmoreland (R-Ga.) told
The Hill he thought then-presidential candidate Barack Obama was
"uppity," a racially tinged word. Rep. Geoff Davis (R-Ken.)
apologized in April for referring to Obama as a "boy."
At rallies held for the Republican presidential ticket,
media focused on attendees who called Obama a "terrorist" and emcees,
most famously Cincinnati radio host Bill Cunningham, who frequently invoked
Obama's middle name to rile up a crowd.
This year, outreach to African-American and Hispanic
voters is a key part of most chairman candidates' pitches to RNC members. In
2008, Sen. John McCain (R-Ariz.) attracted just 4 percent of the black vote and
31 percent of the Hispanic vote, significantly below levels of support for
previous Republican nominees.
The candidates themselves preach the importance of
casting a wider GOP net, emphasizing proximity to minority voters who are
generally more conservative on social issues. But there have been moments when
even the most experienced operatives have displayed a tone-deafness that
startles some of their fellow Republicans.
Though Saltsman told The Hill RNC members would understand
the song, written by conservative satirist Paul Shanklin, was nothing more than
parody, several other candidates issued strong statements attacking their
rival.
"I am shocked and appalled that anyone would think
this is appropriate as it clearly does not move us in the right
direction," incumbent RNC chairman Robert "Mike" Duncan said in
a statement.
"In my opinion, this isn't funny and it's in bad
taste," added Saul Anuzis, chairman of the Michigan Republican Party and a
candidate for the national job. "Just as important, anything that paints
the GOP as being motivated in our criticism of President-elect Obama by
anything other than a difference in philosophy does a disservice to our
party."
Others around the country agreed. Florida GOP chairman
Jim Greer issued an unusually strong statement, and CNN quoted outgoing RNC
online communications manager James Richardson, who wrote a surprisingly
upfront assessment of the gaffe. Sending out the CD "shows a serious lack
of judgment, tact and the necessary level of racial sensitivity expected of
public officials," Richardson wrote on a conservative blog.
Surprisingly, it has been the two African-American
candidates running to head the RNC, former Maryland Lt. Gov. Michael Steele and
ex-Ohio Secretary of State Ken Blackwell, who have been the easiest on
Saltsman.
"I know Chip Saltsman, I know his character; and
while his attempt at humor was clearly misplaced, it does not make him
indifferent to the important work of building the coalitions necessary to make
our party stronger," Steele said in a statement.
Blackwell blamed a "hypersensitivity in the press
regarding matters of race" for the most recent blowup. "I don't think
any of the concerns that have been expressed in the media about any of the
other candidates for RNC chairman should disqualify them," he said.
"All of my competitors for this leadership post are fine people."
Saltsman isn't the only candidate who has slipped up on
race issues. This summer, South Carolina GOP chairman Katon Dawson resigned his
membership from the Forest Lake Club, a prominent Columbia country club that
prohibited African-American membership in its deed.
The club's leadership said the deed was invalid, and
Dawson has a record of promoting African-American candidates for both internal
party positions and in the state legislature. (Two of the RNC's three
African-American committee members back Dawson's bid for national chairman; the
third backs Anuzis.)
Still, the lack of African-American members at the club
proved an embarrassment, one that several of Dawson's rivals don't hesitate to
bring up in private as reason to question his leadership ability.
Dawson, too, held back from attacking Saltsman, calling
him "an honorable, experienced campaign operative" Dawson considers a
friend. "Everyone makes mistakes and Chip made one last week. But for the
media to dwell on it distracts from the real issues that we must debate in
order to move the Republican Party forward," Dawson told The Hill.
But as the party saw its vote share decline, ethnic
voters are very much on the minds of top Republicans around the country.
"The [GOP] has to have Hispanic voters, African-American voters, any
minority bloc consider the party as [a] home," Greer told The Hill.
"We're talking about the issues that are important to those voters, but we
also remember that Hispanics and African-Americans and minority voters are also
Americans."
Though RNC members and those watching the chairman's contest say race will
not be a deciding factor in their votes, many are asking the two black
candidates about the issue, with sources saying it's not a faux pas to address
the elephant in the room. Steele has said publicly that he does not want voters
to consider his ethnicity when deciding whether to vote for him.
Though economic issues dominated the 2008 elections,
Republicans stress that on key social issues, they align more closely with
minority voters than do Democrats. Especially on gay rights — political
analysts credit an increased turnout among African-American voters for passage
in California of Proposition 8, which banned same-sex marriage — many in the
GOP see an opportunity to use a wedge issue among an electorate that would
otherwise vote overwhelmingly Democratic.
But just belaboring the point won't work with minority
voters, candidates and committee members alike say. Whether it's meeting with
black and Hispanic leaders, attracting new spokespeople to the party or simply
investing in new infrastructure in communities where the GOP has largely been
absent, all agree that some steps have to be taken.
The real question, then, becomes one of patience. Obama
will be on the ballot again four years from now and Republicans will likely
face initial disappointment by the early returns on those investments. If the
party decides to focus resources elsewhere, many worry they will continue to be
seen by minority voters solely as the party of white people.
Perhaps more important than a national strategy that
seeks to emulate Democratic National Committee Chairman Howard Dean's 50-state
strategy, appealing to minority voters could prove key to GOP chances among a
growing segment of the electorate. Gaffes aside, if the party doesn't seriously
commit to engaging in outreach and building common bonds, Republicans will
continue to lag behind Democrats.
How seriously RNC members and the candidates they will
vote on will take those warnings remains to be seen.
|