|
Unions are to blame for the Big Three automakers’ problems,
according to a television ad meant to stoke public opposition to organized
labor’s number one legislative priority. “Steel, auto, airlines. What do these industries all have
in common?” asks the ad sponsored by the business-backed Employee Freedom
Action Committee, which was active in several hotly contested Senate races this
year. “Hundreds of thousands of lost jobs and union bosses that helped put them
out of business.”
The advertisement urges people to fight the Employee Free
Choice Act, which unions hope will be taken up quickly by the Democratic
Congress and President-elect Barack Obama. The bill would eliminate the requirement
for workers to cast secret ballots in deciding whether to organize, making it
easier to form unions.
Business groups are paying for the ad to run on CNN and
the Fox cable news network Monday through Wednesday, according to the group’s
spokesman, Tim Miller. He said the ad buy was “fairly substantial” but declined
to specify a figure. A similar ad ran in Mississippi and New Hampshire in
conjunction with Senate races in those states, where business groups worked to
tie Democrats to the Employee Free Choice Act.
“If Americans like what the unions did to Detroit’s
economy, they’ll love what the unions will do to the country,” said Richard
Berman, the business group’s executive director.
“The unions have played a significant role in nearly
bankrupting the Big Three automakers with untenable inefficiencies which have
put tens of thousands out of work,” Bergman said. He said the union bill, known
as “card-check legislation,” would do the same to millions of jobs across the
country.
Alan Reuther, legislative director for the United
Autoworkers, blasted the ad and Bergman’s comments. He said the auto industry’s
problems rest on a series of bad trade and healthcare policies, and that the
credit crunch is to blame for the current crisis.
Reuther also said major concessions offered by unions in
their 2005 and 2007 contracts will result in the elimination of the cost-gap
between union and non-union plants. “We feel that we’ve stepped up to the
plate,” he said.
He also pointed to a 2007 report by two auto industry
consulting firms that found nine of the 10 most-efficient auto plants in North
America have workers organized by the United Autoworkers or the Canadian
Autoworkers.
Congressional leaders have asked the cash-strapped auto
companies to come up with a business plan over the next two weeks if they want
$25 billion in aid. Executives from the three companies were in Washington this
week pleading for help.
Besides arguing that it would slow the economy, the U.S.
Chamber of Commerce, National Association of Manufacturers and other business
groups warn that card-check would let union bosses intimidate workers into
forming unions.
Labor groups charge that the current system allows
employers to use intimidation tactics to stop workers from organizing. Allowing
workers to form unions by checking cards authorizing a specific union to
represent them rather than casting secret ballots would solve the problem,
they say.
Separately, a coalition of business groups wrote to
members of Congress urging that they not sign on to card-check legislation.
“Particularly at a time of economic uncertainty, Congress
should not enact measures that threaten our economic competitiveness, including
the Employee Free Choice Act,” stated the letter, which was signed by dozens of
business groups.
|