THE HILL
 

Obama triumph ahead

By Ben Goddard - 11/11/09 07:03 PM ET

Much of the political chatter about healthcare reform in the past week has been of the glass-half-empty variety. Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.) had to make too many deals. Blue Dog Democrats who were corralled into supporting the legislation are now vulnerable. The calendar allows Republicans to organize dozens of high-profile town hall meetings to rally constituents in opposition.


Yes, there is a rocky road ahead. But I don’t think that is what most Americans are focused on. Even after all the August town halls, the marches in Washington and the campaigns being waged against the Obama proposal, Americans still want healthcare reform. A majority still support some form of a public option to provide greater competition in the insurance marketplace. Yes, there are swing districts where support for any government-run plan could cost Democrats votes. But if history provides any glimpse of the future, and it usually does, that pain will likely be mitigated once there is actually a law on the books. Runaway costs and fears of a government takeover were raised against Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid. Those programs are now virtually untouchable — the third rails of American politics.

So what message did America get from the historic weekend vote in the House? Well, I’m not sure everyone would articulate it in exactly these words, but the sense I get from the grass roots is that the president scored. The message for most Americans is that Barack Obama has done what no president has ever done before. He actually got a bill passed in one house of Congress. When the president visited Capitol Hill on Saturday there was nothing but speculation and high hopes on the part of those wanting a bill. When he left there were 220 votes — even an unexpected Republican one. Pelosi certainly deserves a lot of credit for her commitment to the cause. Her oft-derided liberalism gave her the leverage she needed to keep one wing of her caucus in line, and her last-minute pragmatic dealing kept many from the other wing in the fold. She deserves kudos for engineering that legislative victory. But it was POTUS who sank the 30-foot shot and made sure she could declare that the bill had passed.

This president certainly showed that he has learned from the mistakes made by the Clinton White House; in fact, his strategy was almost a complete reversal of the one used by president Clinton back in the day. He started by reaching out to many of the groups that had opposed the Clinton plan 15 years before. He cut deals with the pharmaceutical industry, the hospital industry and even had insurers at the table for six months or so. Most importantly, he didn’t deliver a package created in a vacuum to the Congress. He laid out the principles and goals of reform and then asked the legislators to legislate. It wasn’t always a pretty sight, and there have been stumbles along the way, but something finally got done.

There are still a lot of messy fights ahead over the details. Special interests will continue trying to carve out exceptions for themselves and, if possible, figure some way to actually make a little more money out of the system. Liberals will carp that the legislation is not good enough. Conservatives will bemoan the fact that it goes too far. But it looks like Obama actually has momentum. It now appears likely that some kind of healthcare reform will land on his desk early next year. If it does, he will sign the most important and sweeping domestic legislation in half a century.

That will, eventually, be the message America’s voters get out of this battle. They wanted reform 15 years ago — two-thirds said then that they wanted “radical reform.” Now they will happily settle for something a little less. And when the bill actually becomes law, President Obama and most of the Democrats in Congress will get the credit for it.

As a cynical old political hack and the guy who created the campaign many credit with — or blame for — the demise of Clinton healthcare, I’m supposed to be a little less of a Pollyanna about such matters. But I can’t help it. Like a lot of Americans, I’m thinking that the “skinny kid with a funny name” who grew up to be president just may pull this off. I’m going to savor that message a little before we get back into the game.

Goddard is a founding partner of political consultants Goddard Claussen. E-mail: This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it

Source:
http://thehill.com/opinion/columnists/ben-goddard/67445-obama-triumph-ahead

Comments (105)

Well said.I am equally optimistic. I've been writing for months now that the Public Option (or similar by another name) will be a reality. Not might be, will be.As you said, we will "carp". And for good reason.Single Payer, ala HR 676, would still be the best avenue.But those of us on the Left will not kick a bill with a PO intact out of bed.It's a historical victory any way you slice it. Americans will actually be better off after a legislative session. Imagine that.This legislation is exactly what many on the Right have said it is. A precursor to Medicare for all.And I hope they choke on it. ;)BY captainkona on 11/11/2009 at 21:12
I am sorry that I cannot share in your enthusiasm. As you refer to the skinny kid with the funny name, would that be the one who grew up to be an attorney for Acorn and now strives to take more taxes from us to pay for a huge healthcare takeover so that he can have a legacy of change? This is not the change that America wanted. We wanted an honest administration and bipartisan political proceedings that were open for public viewing. Instead we have more bribery and trading goodies for votes like kids bartering the contents of their lunchboxes.BY Kathi on 11/12/2009 at 00:35
Governing is not campaigning. Alas, both the Democratic Congress and the President seem incapable of grasping this simple point. To them, the point is to "win" and "triumph" in the short term, regardless of the long term consequences to the nation or their party.BY Blue Ridge on 11/12/2009 at 09:02
And yes, Obama is going to ram Health Reform through the Senate. He will telly Dingy to use Reconcilliation , and Dingy Harry has nothing to lose. This is his one shot to remake America in a new leftist image, that will remake the political landscape into a more favorable playing field for Democrats in the future. They are willing to sacrifice a lot of seats in 2010 (including Dingy's) in order to gain them back in 2012, 2014, and beyond. Once the public is dependent on a new Socialized medical system, it is impossible to ever go back. They know that this will work because it has worked to fully socialize every country it has been done in. Socialization of medicine is the keystone for the implementation of the Democrats wettest wet dreams. Bush disregarded the popular will, but his decisions have stuck, and there really is no going back. It will be the same with Obama.BY Andrew P on 11/12/2009 at 09:06
Well stated Kathi! Unfortunately the Dems and the majority of the country didn't think his past mattered last November. Hopefully it will matter to them in 2010 and 2012. IMO they all need to go Dem and Repub alike. How about some real change: term limits?BY SHAFT on 11/12/2009 at 09:15
I've worked in federal health care for over 20 years and I have a Masters in Health Administration. This bill is a complete and utter disaster and it is apparent that whomever put this together has never worked a single day in healthcare. The federal government can't handle what is on its plate today, how are we supposed to swallow this as well? We will pay more for less health care and like our public schools, we'll get dismal performance and recycled excuses every year, mostly citing a lack of funding. I do agree with one thing, we'll never get rid of this atrocious albatross once it passes which is why it needs to be defeated.BY Brian on 11/12/2009 at 09:15
The author's candor in openly acknowledging he is a political hack is refreshing.BY lance sjogren on 11/12/2009 at 09:15
Hey, Charlie Brown, did you sit up with Linus waiting for the Great Pumpkin as well? You want history? Hilary's effort didn't have half the opposition this debacle has and it fell flat on its face. And then the Dem's got booted in the next election. Wishful thinking, Mr. Goddard, is for children, like Linus.BY Reganite on 11/12/2009 at 09:16
Mr. Goddard, I suggest you take your blinders off before you go to the bathroom.BY dannielle on 11/12/2009 at 09:23
""Reform"? You mean forcing some to pay for the health care of others? Where is there any "reform" in that? Lets be honest its just yet another entitlement program and more centralized control over our lives.BY Ohio Libertarian on 11/12/2009 at 09:32

Add Comment

Name (required)

E-Mail (will not be published) (required)

Your Comments

You need Flash Player 8 (or higher) and JavaScript enabled to view this content

Get latest news from The Hill direct to your inbox, RSS reader and mobile devices.