THE HILL
 

In journalism, lawmaking, quality control inadequate

By Rep. Jim Cooper (D-Tenn.) - 09/23/09 06:15 PM ET

The key to healthcare reform may be in using the Internet to mobilize average voters to help craft a good bill, and then get it passed into law. But passing along rumors at the speed of light is not good for legislation or the reputation of the Internet. The information age should, and could, do more to spread the truth.

For example, a column in The Hill by Markos Moulitsas of Daily Kos (“Blue Dogs, beware,” Sept. 23) falsely accused me of being someone else. This otherwise trusted news source made a rookie’s mistake of attributing another congressman’s land deal to me.

Traditional journalism requires multiple sources and fact-checking before an article is printed. Usually the writer even interviews the subject of the article. But, unfortunately, Internet standards sometimes fall far short of those ethical guidelines.

Not only the Daily Kos but also Firedoglake has accused me of being against “the public option.” The truth is that I have been a leader in trying to define what a public option really could mean, and I have repeatedly stated that there are several definitions that I support. By my calculation, there are about 18 ways to define a public option and at least half of them could win my support and, in my opinion, a majority in Congress.

The trouble with complex issues like healthcare is that it is tempting to ignore the substance for the politics. In heated debates, it is even tempting to demonize others who may, or may not, disagree with you. Sometimes, advocates get angrier at their allies than at their opponents. Surely there is a more constructive way to conduct these debates.

There’s a Tennessee saying: “Any mule can kick a barn down; it takes a carpenter to build one.” I think it’s important for everyone who really cares about reforming our healthcare system to be in the carpentry business. We all need to be constructive in our criticism, inclusive in reaching out to those who have genuine concerns, and sensitive to the personal histories of others in dealing with our healthcare system.

I have taught healthcare policy at the Owen School of Management at Vanderbilt University for 12 years now, and have tried to read everything I can find on reforming our healthcare system. These are fascinating, thorny issues, but there are ways to solve them this year, on the president’s timetable.

There are ways to follow the president’s principles to “not add one dime to the deficit” and still get everyone covered. There are ways to get real bipartisan support so that we can more easily pass legislation in the House and the Senate.

I am committed to finding those answers and I hope that our netroots friends will be as well. But we need more quality control in reporting, just as we need more quality control in legislation. The truth will set us free and we all need to work harder to find it.

Washington


Globalization is hardly living up to its promise


From Michael Pravica

(Regarding op-ed, “The promise of globalization,” Sept. 15.) While globalism is, in theory, a net positive for global economies, it has hurt America greatly.

Almost daily, we hear of inferior and dangerous products manufactured elsewhere that contain toxic lead paint, kidney-destroying melamine in milk and pet food, cardboard-substituted buns, and other bizarre products (occasionally transported in substandard and dangerous Mexican trucks), that were made in the quest to spare quality (and safety) for the sake of profit. And when Americans have to travel halfway around the world to India (a developing third-world economy) for healthcare because their insurance won’t pay for their treatment, you know something has gone seriously awry with globalism and with our healthcare system.

On top of this, shipping manufactured parts from one nation across the oceans to be assembled in another nation and then shipping the finished product back across the oceans to Western markets is energy-squandering, inefficient, time-consuming, and illogical. We cannot sustain the economic culture in which Americans are mortgaging the future of their grandchildren to consume products as they continue to lose jobs to outsourcing, which frustrates their ability to pay for those products (amidst declining exports).

Las Vegas

Source:
http://thehill.com/opinion/letters/60091-in-journalism-lawmaking-quality-control-inadequate

Comments (3)

Wow, Jim Cooper thinks people are really, really stupid.Also, he keeps using the word "leader" but clearly has no idea what it means.And the barn door analogy is just pure projection on your part, Rep. Cooper. We know your role in 93-94.BY superfly on 09/24/2009 at 15:58
So Rep. Cooper has been teaching healthcare policy for nearly 12 years, which is nearly as long as it has been since he killed the last attempt to bring affordable universal health care to the citizens of the United States.Oh, and Mr. Cooper's disengenuous "18 different public options" fluff is nonsensical, here is what counts: Cooper has voted AGAINST the house legislation which includes the public option and FOR the legislation which did not.The only two questions for Mr. Cooper are (1) if supports a public option to keep obscene health insurance profits under control, and (2) whether he will support his constituents and the taxpayers in Tennessee, or if he will continue to support his corporate sponsors in the health care industry, which have given him more than $1,000,000 in campaign contributions and counting.Mr. Cooper you have a chance to be on the decent side of history, for once please vote on behalf of the people of Tennessee instead of for Blue Cross and Humana. Please, show that you have learned from your massive mistakes in the past decade and that you will vote on behalf of citizens instead of corporations.BY Jack Abramoff on 09/24/2009 at 16:11
I'm behind Cooper one hundred percent. Mr. "Abramoff", Rep. Cooper IS representing his constituents in Nashville. How about actually living in my district and understanding its culture before you pass judgment? If he wasn't doing a good job we wouldn't keep electing him.I would love for him to support a public option, but the fact is that he just can't do it if he wants to be reelected. We NEED Cooper in Congress lest we be left with a Republican. Sorry, but true progressives will never be elected in TN-05BY Interested Citizen on 09/27/2009 at 02:43

Add Comment

Name (required)

E-Mail (will not be published) (required)

Your Comments

You need Flash Player 8 (or higher) and JavaScript enabled to view this content

Get latest news from The Hill direct to your inbox, RSS reader and mobile devices.