Our ‘Not Me’ politics of personal grievance

Our ‘Not Me’ politics of personal grievance
© Getty Images

In the mid-1970s, cartoonist Bil Keane’s popular comic strip “The Family Circus” featured a cute but devious little invisible gremlin named “Not Me.” This gremlin took the blame for various happenstances in the family household that the children denied having committed. “Not Me” often was seen translucently floating away from the scene of a broken vase, spilled milk or bad behavior, wearing an expression of innocence with shoulders in shrug.

Today, “Not Me” seems to have grown up to become the most influential figure in American politics. He’s also gotten a little louder, angrier and more bitter.

ADVERTISEMENT
This gremlin dominates the storylines of the Russia investigation, scurrying about to deflect blame from President Donald TrumpDonald John Trump20 weeks out from midterms, Dems and GOP brace for surprises Sessions responds to Nazi comparisons: 'They were keeping the Jews from leaving' Kim Jong Un to visit Beijing this week MORE. “Not Me” would have us instead look at special counsel Robert MuellerRobert Swan MuellerSasse: US should applaud choice of Mueller to lead Russia probe MORE and his “witch hunt hoax” as being responsible for all the headlines. Or, more intriguingly, “Not Me” points to Attorney General Jeff SessionsJefferson (Jeff) Beauregard SessionsSessions responds to Nazi comparisons: 'They were keeping the Jews from leaving' Laura Ingraham: Migrant child detention centers 'essentially summer camps' Senate chaplain offers prayer 'as children are being separated from their parents' MORE who, by virtue of accepting his appointment, doing his job and following the law, seems to be responsible for the entire probe.  

 

But the White House is far from the only place we find the “Not Me” gremlin scurrying about.  The campaign of the one-time aspirant of the White House, Hillary ClintonHillary Diane Rodham ClintonKoch brothers group won't back Stewart in Virginia Giuliani says his demand for Mueller probe to be suspended was for show Poll: GOP challenger narrowly leads Heitkamp in North Dakota MORE, spawned a colony of the gremlins bounding afoot. Why did you lose Hillary? “Not Me” says it was former FBI director James ComeyJames Brien ComeyGiuliani says his demand for Mueller probe to be suspended was for show Cuomo, Smerconish and Melber – Where facts matter Hillicon Valley: Supreme Court takes up Apple case | Senate votes to block ZTE deal | Officials testify on Clinton probe report | Russia's threat to undersea cables | Trump tells Pentagon to create 'space force' | FCC begins T-Mobile, Sprint deal review MORE’s fault. No, wait, it was Vladimir Putin’s fault! Or, most interestingly of all, it was Barack ObamaBarack Hussein ObamaFeehery: Betting on Trump Pew study finds Americans can’t tell fact from opinion Should President Trump, like President Obama, forsake human rights in pursuit of the deal with a tyrant? MORE who didn’t make James Comey more forcefully and publicly investigate Vladimir Putin! In any case, “Not Me!”

In the long history of duckers and dodgers in American politics, it is hard to pin the blame for the “Not Me” rampage on one person, but this week’s events remind us that one person does seem to have the unique capacity to showcase the little devil more so than any other. Unsurprisingly, it is the erstwhile candidate’s husband, former President Bill ClintonWilliam (Bill) Jefferson ClintonAfter FBI cleared by IG report, GOP must reform itself Bill Clinton hits Trump administration policy separating immigrant families in Father's Day tweet Trump's strategy for North Korea and beyond MORE.  

Clinton arguably brought the modern-day version of the “Not Me” gremlin to the White House with him from Arkansas. And despite the fact that Clinton is over 20 years now past his biggest “family incident,” he is still haunted by the specter of the invisible “Not Me” gremlin.  

Everyone knows about Clinton’s dalliances with former White House intern Monica Lewinsky, and his parsed denials uttered as “Not Me” shrugged and shuffled along. Yet, in spite of our knowledge of the biggest TMI in the history of U.S. politics, Clinton still can’t shake the “Not Me” ghost. When asked if he had changed his views of the Lewinsky matter, given the rise of the #MeToo movement and time to reflect, the “Not Me” gremlin demonstrated his great resilience. Clinton yet again dodged responsibility and politely reminded us of how he had been victimized and what a high price he paid for his actions.

The former president may not be sorry but the American people are. Sorry that we live in the “Not Me” era of politics. Sorry that we live in a time where it seems no one is willing to be held accountable for choices and actions.  

Instead we live in a time of “grievance politics,” where you succeed by framing other parties as those responsible for your personal travails. This politics of personal victimization was arguably invented by the Clintons but its power now permeates our politics like a team of Russian Olympians on steroids — a parody of itself, obvious to all in its phoniness yet persistent in its existence in a world that stopped taking it seriously some time ago.

Meanwhile, the honest brokers in our system are heading for the political retirement homes, leaving Washington like the pages of a comic strip where the “Not Me” gremlins are even freer to roam. At a time when America needs more men and women of character to step forward to help restore integrity to the system, fewer have the courage  to do so (Mitt RomneyWillard (Mitt) Mitt RomneyRomney backs Laura Bush on border: 'We need a more compassionate answer' ‘Three Californias’ plan would give Dems more seats Supreme Court polling place dress code decision is victory for free speech MORE being a prominent exception).

It’s hard to blame them for leaving when the adults in the room have to spend most of their time cleaning up behind the “Not Me” gremlins instead of working to solve the problems of our country. This ongoing American “Family Circus” is a strip that we should retire and replace with a new idea based on honesty, integrity and a focus on what really matters for the “readers,” the American people.   

Bruce Haynes is vice chair of public affairs and managing director for Sard Verbinnen & Co. in its Washington, D.C., office. He previously was founding partner emeritus of Purple Strategies. A former chief of staff to former Congressman Bob Inglis (R-S.C.), Haynes is a 30-year veteran of politics, public affairs crisis and corporate reputation management. He has consulted on political campaigns and provides counsel to political figures, Fortune 500 companies, leading trade associations and nonprofit organizations. Follow him on Twitter @BruceHaynesDC.