By Ben Geman and Mike Lillis - 03/01/11 09:59 PM EST
Rep. Bill Keating (D-Mass.), who sponsored the oil tax proposal, wondered why taxpayers should be asked "to fork over" billions of dollars in subsidies to some of the most profitable companies on the planet — particularly as funding for law enforcement, medical research and education is on the chopping block.
"Let's put a stop to this welfare program for big oil," Keating said on the House floor.
But House Appropriations Committee Chairman Hal Rogers (R-Ky.) slammed the Democrats' proposal, arguing it would single out one industry "and increase their cost of doing business."
"This misguided policy can only lead to higher energy prices, continued reliance on foreign oil and economic hardship that hampers job creation," Rogers said.
The motion would have removed two weeks’ worth of incentives, according to Minority Whip Steny Hoyer’s (D-Md.) office, including the industry’s eligibility to claim a deduction on income from domestic manufacturing.
The Democrat’s proposal would have sent the two-week spending package back to the Appropriations Committee, with orders to redraft it with provisions ending the incentives.
The vote was 176-249. Thirteen Democrats opposed it, and no Republicans voted for the motion.
A spokesman for House Minority Leader Pelosi (D-Calif.) said that had the motion passed, it would have laid the groundwork for a longer repeal of the tax breaks.
“If it had passed ... and we did another extension of the same CR [continuing resolution], it would’ve carried through for the duration of the next CR. So it was tied to the underlying date that keeps getting amended,” spokesman Drew Hammill said in an e-mail.