By Julian Pecquet - 10/13/11 03:03 PM EDT
A House panel voted along party lines Thursday to make it harder for Americans to become eligible for Medicaid and insurance subsidies under the federal healthcare reform law.
The law counts only the taxable portion of Social Security benefits when calculating Medicaid eligibility, allowing up to a million middle-income early retirees to potentially be eligible for a program meant to help low-income people.
Rep. Diane Black (R-Tenn.), the sponsor of the bill, called changing the law a matter of "fairness."
Without the change, she said, the law "could result in individuals, whose incomes are up to 425 percent of the poverty level, receiving Medicaid. This is unacceptable."
In order to avoid any gaps between Medicaid and the insurance subsidies, the law created a single formula for calculating people's revenue. Changing that formula to make it harder for people to qualify for Medicaid also would make it harder for people to qualify for the sliding-scale subsidies in the law.
Rep. Sandy Levin (D-Mich.) said some 500,000 people might lose eligibility for the insurance subsidies altogether — even though Social Security income isn't usually counted when calculating other tax subsidies.
"We need to proceed with care," said Levin, the top Democrat on the committee.
Rep. Joseph Crowley (D-N.Y.) said the bill could be "Republicans' first step on the slippery slope to limit middle class Americans' ability to claim certain deductions for retirement security, college tuition expenses or even adoption assistance."
"While this Congress begins the steps of peeling back tax benefits for the middle class," he said, "they refuse to even consider or debate a temporary surtax on people who make over $1 million a year. Shameful."
Update: This post was updated at 2 p.m. to add comment from Rep. Joseph Crowley.