Ex-CBO directors defend against GOP attacks on ObamaCare analysis

Ex-CBO directors defend against GOP attacks on ObamaCare analysis
© Getty Images

All former directors of the Congressional Budget Office sent a letter to congressional leadership on Friday defending the agency against attacks from the White House and Republican lawmakers.

“We write to express our strong objection to recent attacks on the integrity and professionalism of the agency and on the agency’s role in the legislative process,” wrote the eight former directors of the nonpartisan office, which analyzes legislation.

ADVERTISEMENT

The defense comes as Republicans have been ramping up their attacks on the CBO’s estimates of the effects of ObamaCare replacement legislation.

The CBO’s analysis of the latest Senate ObamaCare replacement bill finds that 22 million more people would become uninsured over a decade.

Republicans, though, have dismissed that number. Two White House aides wrote an op-ed in The Washington Post this month calling the CBO’s healthcare estimates “little more than fake news.”

Speaker Paul RyanPaul Davis RyanGOP leaders jockey for affection of House conservatives Five GOP lawmakers mulling bid to lead conservative caucus On The Money — Sponsored by Prudential — Trump walks back criticism of UK Brexit strategy | McConnell worries US in 'early stages' of trade war | US trade deficit with China hits new record MORE (R-Wis.) said Thursday that the CBO’s estimate of coverage losses is a “bogus number.”

Ryan argued that many people will choose not to buy coverage when they are no longer compelled to do so by ObamaCare’s mandate for people to have coverage.

The CBO did find that some people would choose not to buy coverage once the mandate is repealed, but it also found that reduced financial assistance and Medicaid cuts under the bill would result in some people becoming unable to afford coverage.

In a break from precedent, Senate Republicans are also considering voting on their replacement legislation next week without having a CBO analysis of a controversial provision from Sen. Ted CruzRafael (Ted) Edward CruzThe Memo: Trump leaves chaos in his wake in UK Beto O'Rourke is dominating Ted Cruz in enthusiasm and fundraising — but he's still headed for defeat GOP senators introduce resolution endorsing ICE MORE (R-Texas), which is included in the bill.

That provision allows insurers to sell plans that do not meet ObamaCare regulations, including protections for people with pre-existing conditions, if they also sell plans that do. It is aimed at allowing healthy people to buy cheaper plans. Many health experts have warned it would destabilize the market, though.

The CBO has not had time to score the provision, but Republicans are instead pointing to an analysis from the Department of Health and Human Services. That analysis has come under fire from outside experts, though, for its methodology and for keeping some key assumptions confidential.

Many Republicans have sought to discredit the CBO by pointing to its projections of enrollment in ObamaCare’s marketplaces, which were significantly higher than ended up being the case.

The former CBO directors acknowledged they are not perfect. But they added their analysis is “more accurate, on average, than estimates or guesses by people who are not objective and not as well informed as CBO’s analysts."