Business groups pressing for repeal of ObamaCare employer mandate

Business groups pressing for repeal of ObamaCare employer mandate
© Getty Images

Business groups are pressing Congress to repeal ObamaCare's employer mandate to offer health insurance to their workers, but getting Republicans to act on the issue will likely be an uphill battle. 

After repealing the Affordable Care Act's (ACA) individual mandate in December, business groups are demanding Congress also take action on the employer mandate — which requires most employers to offer insurance to their workers or face fines — arguing that having one without the other is inequitable. 

“The whole legal basis for the employer mandate in the ACA was to support the individual mandate, and with the repeal of the individual mandate, there’s no legal or logical basis for the employer mandate,” said James Klein, president of the American Benefits Council, which lobbies for large companies like Apple and Bank of America.

“It’s inequitable to leave it all on the shoulders of the employers… In the absence of an individual mandate, you certainly don’t need the employer mandate.” 


Business groups aiming to repeal the rule face the challenge, however, of setting a fire under Republicans' feet during an election year, when health care is an especially thorny issue.

Repealing the individual mandate through tax reform at the end of last year was seen as a small way to achieve victory on a health care matter after several failed attempts to repeal and replace ObamaCare. 

But repealing the employer mandate was not part of that discussion. It also wasn’t attached to recent government funding, even though a delay of another unpopular ObamaCare component — a “Cadillac” tax on high-cost employer-sponsored insurance plans — was. 

Now, Reps. Devin NunesDevin Gerald NunesHouse GOP headed for showdown with DOJ over key documents Schiff: ‘Deeply disturbing’ that FBI gave Nunes confidential info on Clinton's emails Gowdy: House will use 'full arsenal' of constitutional weapons to get DOJ, FBI compliance on subpoenas MORE (R-Calif.) and Mike KellyGeorge (Mike) Joseph KellySelling government assets would be a responsible move in infrastructure deal Bipartisan lawmakers introduce infrastructure bill for poor communities Congress must take steps to help foster children find loving families MORE (R-Pa.) are pushing to have a suspension of the mandate included in an upcoming long-term spending deal March 22

Their bill would cancel any penalties incurred 2015 through 2018. 

“We are strongly pushing for the employer mandate suspension to be part of the omnibus,” said Kelly’s spokesman Thomas Qualtere. 

“Small businesses everywhere are counting on it, since the mandate will cause real harm to their employees. We know that its inclusion is a definite possibility and have high hopes it will happen.”

The IRS began sending notices in November to businesses that failed to comply with the requirement in 2015, with some facing penalties that are millions of dollars.

The fines apply to firms with at least 50 employers that don’t offer affordable health insurance. 

Some lobbyists hope this will spur Congress to quickly take action on the mandate, but say they're not holding their breath.

“Part of the lobbying challenge is the employer mandate has been particularly partisan and fraught with partisan baggage,” said Neil Tratwein, a lobbyist with the National Retail Federation. 

“The penalty letters may provide us the hook to broader the bipartisan appeal of this issue. But it’s a tough one to get up through the House and particularly through the Senate. Of all the radioactive ACA issues, this one is up there with the biggest ones.” 

Unlike the individual mandate, which was widely viewed as the most unpopular part of ObamaCare, the employer mandate is popular in the United States. 

According to the Kaiser Family Foundation, about half of Americans get coverage through an employer. And a January 2017 poll by the Associated Press-NORC Center for Public Affairs Research showed that 61 percent of Americans oppose repealing the employer mandate. 

On top of the mandate's support, Republicans are still reeling from multiple failures to repeal President Obama's signature law. It remains unclear whether a divided Republican conference would take up ObamaCare again, especially with a slim majority in the Senate.


But support for a repeal of the mandate appears to be growing in the House, where Republicans have a large majority. 

House Ways and Means Chairman Kevin BradyKevin Patrick BradyWill tax law help GOP? It’s a mystery six months in Lawmakers, businesses await guidance on tax law On The Money: Trump imposes B in tariffs on China | China blasts 'fickle' Trump, promises payback | Trump to name consumer bureau director next week MORE (R-Texas) told reporters this week he’s discussed a repeal or delay of the mandate with members of the committee and new Health and Human Services Secretary Alex Azar, but did not specify a timeline. 

“We want to make sure our businesses aren't caught up in some sort of fines or punitive measures for the past three years,” Brady said. 

“I think the goal would be to delay or repeal it in total, but retroactive as well.” 
But in the Senate, taking another crack at health reform during an election year might be unappetizing to leadership as they look to protect their slim Republican majority. 

“I think certainly if you mentioned it to Mitch McConnellAddison (Mitch) Mitchell McConnellPolitical figures pay tribute to Charles Krauthammer Charles Krauthammer dies at the age of 68 Overnight Energy: EPA declines to write new rule for toxic spills | Senate blocks move to stop Obama water rule | EPA bought 'tactical' pants and polos MORE, he’d become apocalyptic, if you mentioned health care to him again” said Rep. Phil RoeDavid (Phil) Phillip RoeTrump signs VA Mission Act — this is a health care win for vets Memorial Day 2018 — let's remember those who died as a result of VA's lack of accountability Senate must pass Mission Act to give veterans care they deserve MORE (R-Tenn.), chairman of the House Doctors Caucus, who said he would support a repeal of the mandate. 

Senate Finance Chairman Orrin HatchOrrin Grant HatchSenate panel to hold hearing next week for Trump IRS nominee On The Money — Sponsored by Prudential — Senators hammers Ross on Trump tariffs | EU levies tariffs on US goods | Senate rejects Trump plan to claw back spending Senators hammer Ross over Trump tariffs MORE (R-Utah) has called for the repeal of the mandate in the past, but appeared skeptical about addressing it this year. 

“I really wish I knew. I don’t know. I think they’ll try to avoid it if they can.”