By Gautham Nagesh - 12/05/11 09:10 PM EST
Supporters of the Stop Online Piracy Act (SOPA) are taking issue with a draft of alternate online piracy legislation circulated last week and predicting the bill would be unlikely to garner enough support to pass Congress.
A bipartisan group of lawmakers including prominent SOPA opponents Rep. Darrell Issa (R-Calif.) and Sen. Ron WydenRon WydenDems push for US, EU cooperation on China's market status Senate Dems push Obama for more Iran transparency Watchdog faults Energy Department over whistleblower retaliation MORE (D-Ore.) released a draft proposal last week that would task the International Trade Commission (ITC) with handling complaints from copyright holders about foreign websites dedicated to piracy.
Issa has argued that the ITC approach would be more effective at preventing sites from popping up with new names and avoiding imposing a burden on Web firms by targeting payment processors, online ad networks and other sources of revenue for rogue websites.
But a House Judiciary Committee aide said transferring intellectual property enforcement to the ITC from the Justice Department would result in "a dramatic and costly expansion of the federal bureaucracy." The aide argued the Justice Department has the expertise to handle such cases.
In addition, the aide noted the Issa-Wyden bill would have to garner the support of the relevant committee heads, which include the Ways & Means/Finance Committees in both chambers. Senate Finance Committee ranking member Orrin HatchOrrin HatchBacteria found ahead of Olympics underscores need for congressional action for new antibiotics Burr pledges to retire after one more Senate term Leaders appoint allies, adversaries to Puerto Rico growth task force MORE (R-Utah) is a co-sponsor of PROTECT IP, a companion bill to SOPA.
There is no legislative language available for the alternative bill, but its sponsors plan to publish a draft for public comment in the coming weeks.
Judiciary Chairman Lamar Smith (R-Texas) has said he plans to move on SOPA before the end of the year but the aide couldn't confirm a reported markup date of Dec. 15.