THE HILL
 
comment Print

Romney criticizes Chief Justice Roberts on healthcare decision

By Alicia M. Cohn - 07/05/12 08:44 AM ET

Mitt Romney is criticizing Supreme Court Chief Justice John Roberts for his healthcare decision. 

In an interview on CBS on Thursday, Romney said Roberts's decision "gives the impression" it was based on politics, not the Constitution. 

He also said it was "not an appropriate conclusion" to find that the individual mandate passed constitutional muster because it is a tax.

"It gives the impression the decision wasn't made on the Constitution, but on political consideration between the branches of government," Romney said. "But we won't really know the answers to those things until maybe the justice speaks out sometime in history."

Roberts's decision shocked the GOP, which had expected him to be an ally in its push to eliminate the legislation known as "ObamaCare." Instead, Roberts sided with the court's four liberal justices and upheld the law. 

He did reject the government's argument that the Commerce Clause made the health insurance mandate constitutional, a ruling that could have huge future implications for government actions.

Romney previously had said he would seek to nominate justices like Roberts to the Supreme Court. 

But in the wake of the healthcare ruling, Romney said he wouldn't nominate someone "who I knew would come out with a decision that I violently disagreed with or vehemently disagreed with."

Of Roberts, Romney said, "He's a very bright person and I look for people who follow the Constitution."

According to leaks since the Supreme Court upheld the healthcare reform act as constitutional, Roberts initially sided with the conservative dissent in the decision but ultimately changed his mind and became the deciding factor in the court's ruling.

Roberts acknowledged the fallout last week when he told a judicial conference he is headed to Malta for two weeks now that the Supreme Court is adjourned. 

"Malta, as you know, is an impregnable island fortress. It seemed like a good idea," Roberts joked, according to The Associated Press. 


Source:
http://thehill.com/video/campaign/236245-romney-roberts-did-not-come-to-appropriate-conclusion-on-healthcare

In the News

View all »
Obama: I ‘did not know anything’ about IRS targeting before reportsObama: I ‘did not know anything’ about IRS targeting before reports WATCH LIVE: Hearing on IRS scandalWATCH LIVE: Hearing on IRS scandal Bloomberg-backed group goes after Flake on gun controlBloomberg-backed group goes after Flake on gun control 'Superman' actor: Obama administration puts up 'an iron curtain''Superman' actor: Obama administration puts up 'an iron curtain'
Gates defends Benghazi response, says critics have ‘cartoonish’ view of militaryGates defends Benghazi response, says critics have ‘cartoonish’ view of military Obama campaign hits Romney on what he 'didn't say' in TampaObama campaign hits Romney on what he 'didn't say' in Tampa VIDEO: EU officials say trade deal must be comprehensiveVIDEO: EU officials say trade deal must be comprehensive Baucus on IRS: 'I have a hunch that a lot more is going to come out'Baucus on IRS: 'I have a hunch that a lot more is going to come out'

More Campaign videos

View all »
Obama campaign hits Romney on what he 'didn't say' in TampaObama campaign hits Romney on what he 'didn't say' in Tampa OFA launches new video series to promote immigration reformOFA launches new video series to promote immigration reform Liberal group accuses Rove of 'misleading' public on Benghazi Liberal group accuses Rove of 'misleading' public on Benghazi Axelrod: GOP event was like 'open mic night for 2016 candidates'  Axelrod: GOP event was like 'open mic night for 2016 candidates'
Axelrod: GOP trying to bully Clinton out of 2016 White House runAxelrod: GOP trying to bully Clinton out of 2016 White House run Ex-Rep. Sestak announces rematch attempt against Sen. ToomeyEx-Rep. Sestak announces rematch attempt against Sen. Toomey New Obama ad uses Big Bird to hit Romney on deficit, Wall StreetNew Obama ad uses Big Bird to hit Romney on deficit, Wall Street Gomez internal poll shows him trailing Markey by 3 pointsGomez internal poll shows him trailing Markey by 3 points
Hilltube Twitter - Click to follow

More Videos »

bloglogo

More Briefing Room »

More Congress Blog »

More Pundits Blog »

More Twitter Room »

More Hillicon Valley »

More E2-Wire (Energy) »

More Ballot Box »

More On The Money »

More Healthwatch »

More Floor Action »

More Transportation »

More DEFCON Hill »

More Global Affairs »

More In The Know »

More RegWatch »

Get latest news from The Hill direct to your inbox, RSS reader and mobile devices.