An extraordinary tale that is all too ordinary
He arrived in our country from the Philippines at age 12, but did not find out about his status until he tried to get a driver’s license—a normal occurrence for a 16-year-old boy. Once he learned about his lack of status, he faced an impossible choice. Would he persevere, pursue college and a career in the United States, or simply give up? What choice did he have really?
Reading Vargas’s story I was struck most by his equanimity. Like most undocumented immigrants, he is neither angry at the U.S. government for his situation nor blames Congress for its inaction. Instead, he acknowledges his own transgressions, and accepts responsibility for them. What he wants (and I suspect this is true of most undocumented immigrants) is not a free pass but a chance to become an equal member of society.
Not all undocumented immigrants have won a Pulitzer Prize, but neither are they the criminals that opponents of reform tell us they are. In fact, they are among us — our coworkers, our children’s friends, people we sit next to church or on the Metro. Most are hard-working people who, like immigrants for centuries before them, came here searching for a better life. Many of these people have been in the country for over a decade, set down roots, bought houses, and paid taxes.
So how can we achieve accountability and functionality in a system we all know is broken? Should we do more of the same? That isn’t working. Should we pass sweeping state immigration enforcement laws like Arizona’s harsh S.B. 1070? These laws come at a hefty price. To catch and deport 11 million undocumented immigrants would cost the United States $285 billion, money we do not have. States like Arizona are already feeling the pinch. Economic losses just from conference cancellations after the law’s passage have cost the state hundreds of millions of dollars.
The smart answer is to allow undocumented immigrants to take responsibility for their actions, and to get right with the law. This process would have undocumented immigrants register, pay any back taxes and a fine, pass background checks, and learn English. Bringing 11 million people out of the shadows would increase U.S. gross domestic product, the broadest measure of growth in our economy, by a cumulative $1.5 trillion over ten years. That’s a game-changer for our struggling economy. This process would also allow us to focus our national security resources more effectively.
Americans consistently support this approach. A recent Gallup poll found that two-thirds of Americans, including 57 percent of Republicans, support a tough but fair process of earned legalization. Restrictionists in Congress, though, ignore this reality, consistently blocking any chance at meaningful legislation.
Case in point: The failure to pass the DREAM Act, which would have granted legal status to people like Vargas who were brought here as children and who completed high school and some college or military service. It was narrowly defeated in the Senate in December, even after passing the House of Representatives.
Jose Antonio Vargas’s story reminds us just how much work still needs to be done on immigration reform. We hope this Congress finds the courage to pass an actual solution for the nation’s undocumented immigrants — to pass the newly reintroduced DREAM Act and Comprehensive Immigration Act of 2011 — rather than pursue more empty enforcement actions.
Angela Maria Kelley is vice president for immigration policy and advocacy at the Center for American Progress.