Manchin-Schumer deal stuns business lobby
The climate and tax package unveiled by Senate Majority Leader Charles Schumer (D-N.Y.) and Sen. Joe Manchin (D-W.Va.) on Wednesday stunned K Street firms and big business groups that are now mounting a last-ditch effort to win concessions for their corporate clients.
The proposal to spur green energy investment, lower health insurance costs and reduce the deficit is funded by a host of provisions opposed by powerful industries. The bill would institute a 15 percent minimum tax on corporate profits, empower the government to negotiate the price of certain drugs, boost IRS enforcement and close a capital gains tax loophole.
Business lobbyists were confident that those tax proposals wouldn’t become law when Manchin said earlier this month that he would only support a slimmed-down reconciliation package that didn’t include climate spending or tax hikes.
Manchin’s reversal blindsided top Washington lobbyists, Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.) and even members of the Democratic caucus.
“If McConnell didn’t see it coming, people in the business community didn’t see it coming. Because if anyone on K Street knew about this, it would have been leaked,” said Al Mottur, a former Democratic aide and lobbyist at Brownstein Hyatt Farber Schreck. “What’s amazing is that they did this and none of the staff told anybody.”
Dubbed the “Inflation Reduction Act,” the bill’s survival hinges on whether Democrats can unite their slim Senate and House majorities behind a deal that will draw scorn from a wide-ranging list of corporate giants.
Many of those corporations will key in on the minimum tax, which would bring in an estimated $313 billion in additional tax dollars over the next decade from companies that make at least $1 billion in annual profits.
“This legislation includes taxes that would discourage investment and undermine economic growth, and price controls that would limit American innovation. Both will make our economic problems worse,” U.S. Chamber of Commerce Chief Policy Officer Neil Bradley said in a statement.
At least 70 public companies hit the profit threshold in 2020 but paid less than 15 percent in federal taxes, according to a report from Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.). The lengthy list includes Apple, General Motors, Bank of America, Intel, Verizon and FedEx.
Some manufacturers on the list paid little to no federal taxes.
National Association of Manufacturers CEO Jay Timmons said in a statement that the bill will “undermine manufacturers’ competitiveness at a time when the industry is reeling from supply chain disruptions and record inflation.”
Ever since the minimum tax was floated last year as part of a larger reconciliation bill, business groups inundated lawmakers with warnings that it would be too complex and would force companies to cut down on capital investments that spur growth.
On the other hand, the tax provisions represent a huge victory for retailers, which generally pay the full corporate tax rate, as they don’t benefit from as many incentives. The Manchin-Schumer bill keeps the 21 percent corporate tax rate from Republicans’ 2017 tax bill intact.
“The agreement struck accomplishes all the objectives retailers have set out to achieve throughout the debate on corporate taxes: permanent lower rates, fairness to ensure all are contributing, and better enforcement to collect what is legally owed,” said Michael Hanson, senior executive vice president for public affairs at the Retail Industry Leaders Association, which represents big box stores, such as Target, Home Depot and Best Buy.
Various small business advocacy groups have also been pushing for a corporate tax overhaul. Small Business for America’s Future found that 65 percent of small business owners support policies to ensure that large corporations “pay their fair share of taxes.”
In an interview with West Virginia-based radio station MetroNews on Thursday, Manchin said it is “ridiculous” that large corporations pay less than 15 percent in federal taxes and challenged companies to publicly oppose the minimum tax.
“We found out that there were some very, very large corporations that could basically take advantage of the tax code and pay nothing. I didn’t think that was fair, and I think most Americans don’t think that’s fair,” Manchin told radio host Hoppy Kercheval.
“They’re paying for the ability to be in this country with a defense that we have, protections we have, and opportunities, and they don’t want to participate?” he added. “I want them to come forward. Tell me who you are.”
Certain industries are lobbying against other key revenue raisers in the bill.
The proposal to boost IRS enforcement had previously drawn opposition from banking groups that argued it would spark privacy concerns and ultimately cause fewer Americans to put their money in banks.
The bill would attempt to close the so-called carried interest loophole, which allows wealthy fund managers to pay lower taxes on capital gains than most Americans pay on income taxes. That would hurt the bottom line of private equity giants.
“As small business owners face rising costs and our economy faces serious headwinds, Washington should not move forward with a new tax on the private capital that is helping local employers survive and grow,” Drew Maloney, president of the American Investment Council, which represents private equity firms, said in a statement.
Senate Democrats can pass the spending package with a simple majority using budget reconciliation rules that sidestep the 60-vote legislative filibuster.
Lobbyists see Sen. Kyrsten Sinema (D-Ariz.) — a reliable business community ally who did not attend Senate Democrats’ caucus meeting on Thursday — as likely the only lawmaker who could upend the bill.
Sinema previously backed the minimum tax but has expressed opposition to the carried interest measure. That could be a problem, given that on Thursday, Manchin insisted that the provision make it into the final bill.
A spokesperson for Sinema told reporters that she is still reviewing the text and will need to review the Senate parliamentarian’s ruling on whether the bill’s various provisions can be passed through budget reconciliation.
While around a half-dozen Senate Democrats have privately shared concerns about the minimum tax with industry lobbyists, none have publicly come out against the proposal.
Federal lobbying spending surpassed $2 billion through June, the largest first-half total on record, according to research group OpenSecrets. Business interests account for roughly 87 percent of the spending.
Copyright 2023 Nexstar Media Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.