Castro: Iowa, New Hampshire should be replaced by more diverse states in nomination race

Castro: Iowa, New Hampshire should be replaced by more diverse states in nomination race
© Greg Nash

Former Housing and Urban Development Secretary Julián Castro, a 2020 Democratic presidential contender, is arguing that Iowa and New Hampshire should lose their status as the respective first-in-the-nation caucus and primary states because their populations don’t reflect the diversity of the Democratic primary. 

Speaking over the weekend to MSNBC, Castro said the racial makeup of the Democratic Party and the U.S. has changed substantially in the nearly 50 years since Iowa was tapped to be the first in line to vote back in 1972.


“Demographically, it’s not reflective of the U.S. as a whole, certainly not reflective of the Democratic Party, and I believe other states should have their chance,” Castro said.

“So yes, of course we need to find other states. That doesn’t mean that Iowa and New Hampshire can’t still play an important role. But I don’t believe that forever we should be married to Iowa and New Hampshire going first.”

Democrats are wrestling with the fact that their top four contenders in the presidential field — former Vice President Joe BidenJoe BidenBiden to meet with 6 GOP senators next week Arizona secretary of state gets security detail over death threats surrounding election audit On The Money: Five takeaways on a surprisingly poor jobs report | GOP targets jobless aid after lackluster April gain MORE, South Bend, Ind., Mayor Pete ButtigiegPete Buttigieg'Funky Academic:' Public has been 'groomed to measure progress by firsts' Biden administration in talks with LA Mayor Eric Garcetti for India ambassador post: reports Business groups target moderate Democrats on Biden tax plans MORE, Sen. Bernie SandersBernie SandersGOP is consumed by Trump conspiracy theories Manchin on collision course with Warren, Sanders Sanders on Cheney drama: GOP is an 'anti-democratic cult' MORE (I-Vt.) and Sen. Elizabeth WarrenElizabeth WarrenDebate over ICBMs: Will 'defund our defenses' be next? Manchin on collision course with Warren, Sanders Hillicon Valley: Broadband companies funded fake net neutrality comments, investigation finds | Twitter rolls out tip feature | Google to adopt 'hybrid work week' MORE (D-Mass.) — are all white, despite the racially diverse field of candidates and the party’s commitment to elevating racial minorities.

Some have pointed to the demographic makeup in Iowa and New Hampshire — the primary electorate was more than 90 percent white in both states in 2016 — as evidence that the deck is stacked against racial minorities seeking the party’s nomination.

Nevada and South Carolina, the third and fourth states to vote, are considerably more diverse. Black voters make up about two-thirds of the Democratic primary electorate in South Carolina.

And when the calendar turns to March 3 for Super Tuesday, Democratic voters will cast ballots in a slate of diverse states, including Texas, California, North Carolina, Virginia and Alabama.

Still, Castro has struggled to gain traction in the race and is barely registering in polls of Iowa, New Hampshire, Nevada or South Carolina. In his home state of Texas, Castro is only polling at 3 percent in the RealClearPolitics average.

Politico reported last week that Castro laid off staff last week in New Hampshire and South Carolina.

Warren, who appears to be the front-runner in the Iowa caucuses at the moment, was asked at an event in South Carolina over the weekend whether Iowa and New Hampshire should maintain their first-in-the-nation statuses.

“Are you actually going go to ask me to sit here and criticize Iowa and New Hampshire?” Warren responded.

“I’m just a player in the game on this one,” she added.