Could Trump nomination put House up for grabs?

Could Trump nomination put House up for grabs?
© Getty Images

The most unpredictable GOP presidential race in recent memory is sparking questions about whether the huge House Republican majority could be jeopardized with Donald TrumpDonald TrumpMajority of Americans in new poll say it would be bad for the country if Trump ran in 2024 ,800 bottle of whiskey given to Pompeo by Japan is missing Liz Cheney says her father is 'deeply troubled' about the state of the Republican Party MORE on the ticket.

It would take nothing short of a catastrophe to wipe out the historic 30-seat advantage now enjoyed by Republicans.


Most in the GOP say they’re confident they’ll keep their majority intact in November no matter who their nominee is.

At the same time, even senior lawmakers couldn’t absolutely rule out the possibility of a wave election that hands Democrats control of the lower chamber.

“The truth is, nobody knows where this is all going. Anybody who says they do is either kidding themselves or lying to you,” Rep. Luke Messer (R-Ind.), the GOP policy chairman and a member of leadership, told The Hill.

Messer doubts his party will lose the House but said the top of the ticket always impacts the race.

“Of course, anything is possible,” he said, “but right now there is nothing indicating that sort of collapse.”

It’s not a sure bet Trump will win the GOP nod.

The New York billionaire and political newcomer is trying to quash a surge from Sen. Ted CruzRafael (Ted) Edward CruzOvernight Defense: Senate panel votes to scrap Iraq war authorizations | Police officer fatally stabbed outside Pentagon ID'd | Biden admin approves first Taiwan arms sale Senate panel votes to repeal Iraq war authorizations America's pandemic of COVID hypocrisy MORE (R-Texas), who closed Trump’s lead in delegates over the weekend.

Opponents of Trump are also hoping that Ohio Gov. John Kasich and Florida Sen. Marco RubioMarco Antonio RubioSenators highlight national security threats from China during rare public hearing Rubio presses DNI to investigate alleged unmasking of Tucker Carlson Senate holds sleepy Saturday session as negotiators finalize infrastructure deal MORE can pull off victories on March 15 in their own states. Such a result would make it more difficult for the celebrity businessman to clinch the 1,237 delegates needed for the nomination.

Not everyone thinks Trump at the top of the ticket will hurt the GOP.

One vulnerable House Republican told The Hill he’ll begin polling his swing district in May to figure out who might show up to vote if Trump is the nominee. The GOP front-runner has become enormously popular with many white, working-class voters.

“I’m going to have to spend money on ‘get out the vote’ and modeling to figure out who my voters are if it’s Trump, because Trump changes the turnout,” the GOP lawmaker said Monday. “You have to figure out who is going to be voting, who didn’t vote before and who’s not going to vote who normally would vote because they don’t like him.”

The vulnerable lawmaker, who requested anonymity to speak freely about campaign strategy, said he actually views Cruz as a bigger threat than Trump.

“I don’t have a problem saying where I disagree with Trump,” he said, “but Cruz represents the ‘Party of No,’ and I think that there are a lot of Republicans who don’t like him. There are voters who say, ‘If he’s your nominee, I will reject’ ” all Republicans.

Freshman GOP Rep. Carlos Curbelo, a top Democratic target, said voters in his heavily Hispanic south Florida district are savvy enough to separate him from Trump, who kicked off his campaign last year by calling Mexican immigrants “rapists” and other criminals.

“Most voters understand that Donald Trump is neither a Republican or a conservative,” Curbelo, who is Cuban-American, wrote in an email. “He’s an aberration and a fraud who is using the Republican Party to advance his opportunistic and narcissistic campaign.”

Most political pundits and prognosticators believe Democrats have virtually no chance to win back the House.

Republicans won their current majority during the Tea Party wave of 2010; in 2014, they expanded it to 247 seats — the largest GOP majority since the Herbert Hoover administration in the late 1920s (Speaker John BoehnerJohn Andrew BoehnerLobbying world A new kind of hero? Last week's emotional TV may be a sign GOP up in arms over Cheney, Kinzinger MORE’s resignation last fall put the latest tally at 246 seats).

To win back the House, Democrats would need to pick up seats in Florida, such as Curbelo’s, but also in New York, Maine, Illinois, Iowa, California and other states where the GOP made inroads in recent cycles.

NRCC officials argued that early signs in this cycle don’t point to a Democratic wave election. On New York’s Long Island, a recent Newsday/News 12/Siena College poll showed that Trump is much more popular than his GOP rivals and that he leads Democrat Hillary ClintonHillary Diane Rodham ClintonBriahna Joy Gray: Progressives like Turner should reconsider running as Democrats Biden wishes Obama a happy birthday Ohio special election: A good day for Democrats MORE in a head-to-head matchup. That may be why vulnerable freshman Rep. Lee Zeldin (R-N.Y.) is embracing Trump rather than running away from him.

“House races aren’t one size fits all,” said NRCC spokeswoman Katie Martin.

Patrick Murray, polling director at Monmouth University, agreed that it’s too early to tell how the eventual nominee might affect down-ballot congressional races. Other GOP candidates may be able to distance or “disassociate” themselves from Trump, causing voters to split the ticket, he said. But there’s also a concern that Trump’s heated rhetoric about things like immigrants, Muslims and torture could turn off a large swath of the GOP electorate.  

“A big fear for the party is that a sizable number of their voters may simply stay home because they can’t bring themselves to support the presidential nominee,” Murray said. “However, we simply won’t know until the nominee is set and any viable independent candidates potentially emerge.”

Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnellAddison (Mitch) Mitchell McConnellOn The Money: Trump asks court to block release of tax returns to Congress | Private sector adds 330K jobs in July, well short of expectations Senate panel advances first three spending bills McConnell lays out GOP demands for government-funding deal MORE (R-Ky.) has vowed to drop Trump “like a hot rock” if he’s the party’s nominee. His top deputy, Majority Whip John CornynJohn CornynWhite House trying to beat back bipartisan Cornyn infrastructure amendment Senate GOP shifts focus to fight over Biden's .5 trillion budget McConnell warns Schumer cutting off debate quickly could stall infrastructure deal MORE (R-Texas), has likened the real estate mogul to an “albatross” around the necks of down-ballot Republicans.

The bombastic candidate and former reality TV star has been more of a wild card when it comes to the House.

A poll conducted for party officials in December revealed that a plurality of voters would be less likely to cast their ballot for a GOP congressional candidate or incumbent with Trump at the top of the ticket. But Republican officials said they likely won’t spend money on additional polling until they have a nominee.

And Speaker Paul RyanPaul Davis RyanTo cut poverty and solve the labor shortage, enhance the Earned Income Tax Credit Wisconsin GOP quietly prepares Ron Johnson backup plans RealClearPolitics reporter says Freedom Caucus shows how much GOP changed under Trump MORE (R-Wis.) and his leadership team are drafting what they’re calling a bold, positive, conservative House agenda they hope candidates will be able to tout on the campaign trail.

“I really believe you are stronger when you have something positive to run on, especially when you get to the general election and when you are appealing to independent voters,” NRCC Chairman Greg Walden (R-Ore.) told The Hill last week. “In the House, it’s tough to punch through above and beyond a presidential megaphone. You can’t do it. But individually, in races, you can.”

Last fall, after Trump proposed banning Muslims from the U.S., Walden suggested such rhetoric was unhelpful and put “competitive seats in jeopardy.” But last week, he expressed hope that Trump might be able to work well with House Republicans.

“He said he’s the guy who can work with Congress to get things done. In the end he’s the consummate dealmaker,” Walden said. “Hopefully, if he is the nominee, we can have some ideas and concepts and reforms that he could adopt.”