Sixteen Democrats have signed onto a letter opposing Rep. Nancy PelosiNancy PelosiMcCarthy raised 0K after marathon speech Davis passes on bid for governor in Illinois, running for reelection to House Feehery: Why Democrats are now historically unpopular MORE (D-Calif.) for Speaker.
The letter, spearheaded by Rep. Kathleen RiceKathleen Maura RiceFive takeaways: House passes Biden's sweeping benefits bill Dems brace for score on massive Biden bill Democrats bullish they'll reach finish line this week MORE (D-N.Y.), had been anticipated for some time and ended up one signature less than the 17 names that had been expected.
Rep. Marcia FudgeMarcia FudgeButtigieg has high name recognition, favorability rating in Biden Cabinet: survey Biden, top officials spread out to promote infrastructure package Black Caucus eager to see BBB cross finish line in House MORE (D-Ohio), who had initially signed and is weighing a challenge to Pelosi, is not a signatory.
The letter argues that midterm voters handed Democrats the House majority with expectations of the party shaking up business-as-usual in Washington — starting with the party leader who’s been at the helm for 15 years. Maintaining control of the chamber, the insurgents say, will require keeping that vow.
“Democrats ran and won on a message of change,” they wrote. “Our majority came on the backs of candidates who said that they would support new leadership because voters in hard-won districts, and across the country, want to see real change in Washington.
Only two women are among the sixteen names on the letter. Allies of Pelosi have dismissed the opposition to her as coming from mostly men in the conference, and have coined the hashtag #fivewhiteguys on social media as a knock to the insurgent Democrats.
The number of signatories could shrink some more.
Utah Democrat Ben McAdams, the mayor of Salt Lake City who’s challenging Rep. Mia LoveLudmya (Mia) Love'The View' plans series of conservative women as temporary McCain replacements Black Republican advocates his case for CBC membership Black women look to build upon gains in coming elections MORE (R-Utah), is one of the letter’s endorsers. But the race remains too close to call, and the most recent tally has Love in front.
Anthony Brindisi, a New York Democrat who is also on the letter, is in another uncalled race, against GOP Rep. Claudia Tenney (N.Y.). Brindisi leads by several thousand votes as absentee ballots continue to be counted.
Pelosi's allies were quick to respond to Monday's letter, saying the insurgents are dreaming if their plan hinges on Pelosi dropping out of the Speaker race.
"If your strategy relies upon Nancy Pelosi giving up, you will lose every single time," said a senior Democratic aide. "Ninety-four percent of the Caucus didn't sign this letter."
The insurgents have been scrambling since even before the midterms to recruit more anti-Pelosi Democrats behind their cause. The letter, which has been circulating for almost two weeks, is the latest front in that campaign. It’s designed to demonstrate that Pelosi would lose the Speaker election on the House floor in January, making her candidacy futile even if she secures the Democratic nomination within her caucus later this month.
The insurgents have much more leverage on the House floor, where the Speaker must win the support of a majority of the entire chamber, versus in the caucus, where a simple majority of Democrats choose the party’s nominee.
The other lawmakers on the letter are Democratic Reps. Tim RyanTimothy (Tim) RyanDemocrats brace for flood of retirements after Virginia rout Ohio Republicans swing for fences in redistricting proposals Ohio redistricting commission gives up on US House map MORE (Ohio), Seth MoultonSeth MoultonBill seeks to aid families of Black WWII veterans deprived of GI benefits How lawmakers aided the Afghan evacuation GOP lawmaker says he did not threaten US Embassy staff in Tajikistan MORE (Mass.), Linda Sánchez (Calif.), Ed PerlmutterEdwin (Ed) George PerlmutterGroup aligned with House GOP leadership targeting nine Democrats on spending vote House GOP campaign arm expands target list after brutal night for Dems Equilibrium/Sustainability — Presented by Southern Company — China's president to video in for climate confab MORE (Colo.), Kurt SchraderWalter (Kurt) Kurt SchraderFive takeaways: House passes Biden's sweeping benefits bill House passes giant social policy and climate measure Democrats press toward vote on massive Biden bill MORE (Ore.), Filemon VelaFilemon Bartolome VelaDemocrats brace for flood of retirements after Virginia rout Showdown: Pelosi dares liberals to sink infrastructure bill Vicente Gonzalez to run in different Texas district after Abbott signs new map MORE (Texas), Jim CooperJim CooperHouse GOP campaign arm expands target list after brutal night for Dems Arkansas legislature splits Little Rock in move that guarantees GOP seats Cities become pawns in redistricting game MORE (Tenn.), Bill FosterGeorge (Bill) William FosterCongress's role in the AUKUS nuclear-powered submarine deal Overnight Defense: Senators reach billion deal on emergency Capitol security bill | House panel looks to help military sexual assault survivors | US increases airstrikes to help Afghan forces fight Taliban We must address the declining rate of startup business launches MORE (Ill.), Brian HigginsBrian HigginsFDNY 'sickout' intensifies drama over vaccine mandate Biden's keeping the Canada-US border closed makes no sense Biden administration stokes frustration over Canada MORE (N.Y.) and Stephen LynchStephen Francis LynchLawmakers seek answers on armed services' plans to address gun tracking Left warns Pelosi they'll take down Biden infrastructure bill Pelosi signals she won't move .5T bill without Senate-House deal MORE (Mass.).
Aside from McAdams and Brindisi, three other incoming freshman also signed the letter: Rep.-elects Jeff Van Drew (N.J.), Joe Cunningham (S.C.) and Max Rose (N.Y.).
The detractors praised Pelosi as "an historic figure," one "whose leadership has been instrumental to some of our party's most important legislative achievements." Still, they say they're "committed" to opposing her in both the caucus, and on the House floor in January.
Pelosi, who has led the Democrats since 2003, has widespread support within her caucus and is expected to clinch the nomination easily. Thus far, no one has stepped up to challenge her for the gavel, which she held between 2007 and 2011 as the country’s first female Speaker.
Fudge, though, is weighing such a challenge. She and Pelosi met on Friday in Pelosi’s office but neither lawmaker revealed the details of the conversation. Fudge said she’ll finalize her decision after Thanksgiving.
Fudge’s decision to remove her name from the letter is likely not an indication that she no longer supports the insurgency. Ryan, who challenged Pelosi unsuccessfully in 2016, had similarly removed his name from an anti-Pelosi letter leading up to his announced run — an effort to lend some breathing room as he mulled his decision.
Fudge’s office did not immediately respond to a request for comment Monday.
It’s unclear if the anti-Pelosi lawmakers have the numbers to topple the longtime Democratic leader. Democrats picked up at least 37 seats in the midterms, but four races have yet to be called, so it remains to be seen how high the number will rise.
If Democrats win all of the outstanding contests, Pelosi could lose 18 votes within her party and still clinch the gavel (assuming all Republicans oppose her). If Democrats lose all of those uncalled races, she could afford to lose 14.
Aside from the Democrats on the letter, a handful of incoming freshman have pledged to oppose Pelosi in the Speaker vote on the floor. Some of them have not ruled out the option of voting “present,” however, which would lower the number of votes Pelosi would need, since abstentions are not counted as voting members in tallying a majority.
The Democrats’ internal caucus votes are scheduled for Nov. 28.