Democrats balk at Trump's payroll tax cut proposal

House Democrats on Monday night balked at President TrumpDonald John TrumpDonald Trump and Joe Biden create different narratives for the election The hollowing out of the CDC Poll: Biden widens lead over Trump to 10 points MORE’s proposed payroll tax cut designed to help shore up the economy amid the coronavirus outbreak.

After the worst day on Wall Street in more than a decade, Trump said he would ask Congress to pass an emergency economic package that includes both a payroll tax cut and relief for hourly workers to fight the economic fallout from the coronavirus.

But Democrats argued that cutting the federal payroll tax would not help people who have lost their jobs in this sudden downturn, or who are part of the gig economy and do not get paid by the hour.

ADVERTISEMENT

Asked if the payroll tax cut was dead on arrival on Capitol Hill, Rep. Gregory MeeksGregory Weldon MeeksA prescriptive path forward for saving struggling countries' economies Minority caucuses endorse Texas Afro-Latina for Congress NY, NJ lawmakers call for more aid to help fight coronavirus MORE (D-N.Y.) replied: “I think so.”

“I see folks who are being devastated, who are either losing their jobs temporarily or their hours are being cut, and there is nothing being done to help them get back on their feet,” Meeks said in an interview outside the Capitol.

“We have to figure out where we can get more revenue that can make a difference for them. Payroll taxes — I don’t know if that's the best way to go,” said Meeks, adding that rolling back the 2017 Trump tax cuts would raise more revenue to help affected workers. 

Rep. Don Beyer (Va.), the top Democrat on the bipartisan Joint Economic Committee, said he's "very suspicious that more tax cuts are going to do anything concrete."

And Appropriations Committee Chairwoman Nita LoweyNita Sue LoweyJulián Castro launches PAC to support progressive candidates Lawmakers call on VA to remove swastikas from headstones in veterans cemeteries House Democrats object to Trump sending ventilators to Russia MORE (D-N.Y.), who would have jurisdiction over pieces of any big spending package, called the tax cut a non-starter.

ADVERTISEMENT

“Democrats are trying to respond to the urgency of the average working people around this country who are worried about how they’re going to feed their families because their business has closed. You look at restaurants, other service industries; so that’s the priority right now,” Lowey said Monday night. 

Lowey noted that a payroll tax cut does nothing to help those who have lost their jobs as a result of the turmoil.

“Right now, if somebody loses their job as a dishwasher, I’m not sure the payroll tax cut will really help them,” she said.

Trump and his economic team will provide more detail about their package on Tuesday. But Speaker Nancy PelosiNancy Pelosi Sunday shows preview: Leaders weigh in as country erupts in protest over George Floyd death 5 things to know about US-China tensions over Hong Kong Pelosi calls Trump's decision to withdraw US from WHO 'an act of extraordinary senselessness' MORE (Calif.) and her fellow House Democrats are drafting their own stimulus package to help stave off a coronavirus-related recession during this critical election year.

That Democratic package is unlikely to include a payroll tax cut, which she described as “tax cuts for major corporations.” 

ADVERTISEMENT

Instead, it is expected to include paid sick leave for workers who need to self-quarantine due to the coronavirus; enhanced unemployment insurance for those who lose their jobs from the economic impact related to the epidemic; and free coronavirus testing to help control its spread.

“We have to be very targeted about making sure we get money into working folks’ hands and, and not general tax cuts that benefit a lot of people, including some that don't really need to be benefited,” said Rep. Pramila JayapalPramila JayapalExpanding tax credit for businesses retaining workers gains bipartisan support House punts on FISA, votes to begin negotiations with Senate Democrats press OSHA official on issuing an Emergency Temporary Standard MORE (D-Wash.), the Progressive Caucus co-chairwoman. 

“We really need to be very specific about how we address gig workers, people who can't work from home, people who are sick who don't have insurance,” Jayapal continued. “We need to be looking at the most vulnerable populations and targeting those folks in terms of any plans that we pass.”

When asked about a payroll tax cut, House Ways and Means Committee Chairman Richard NealRichard Edmund NealExpanding tax credit for businesses retaining workers gains bipartisan support House Democrats press Treasury on debit cards used for coronavirus relief payments House Democrats' bill would create a second round of direct coronavirus relief payments MORE (D-Mass.) reiterated that his desired way to stimulate the economy would be through infrastructure spending.

"We should have done something along the lines of expanding infrastructure six months ago when [Trump] said he was going to do it," Neal, who leads the powerful tax-writing committee, told reporters Monday evening. 

Mike Lillis and Naomi Jagoda contributed.