Minority lawmakers gain unprecedented clout amid pandemic

Minority lawmakers gain unprecedented clout amid pandemic
© Greg Nash

Minority caucuses in the House are gaining unprecedented political clout, spurred by unity between black, Hispanic, and Asian and Pacific American lawmakers.

Known collectively as the Tri-Caucus, the Congressional Black Caucus (CBC), Congressional Hispanic Caucus (CHC) and Congressional Asian Pacific American Caucus (CAPAC) encompass 131 House Democrats, or 56 percent of the most diverse House Democratic Caucus ever.

But the Tri-Caucus was not always effective in yielding its full voting power to move legislation or leadership battles.

ADVERTISEMENT

That dynamic began changing as minority legislators united around opposition to President TrumpDonald John TrumpHR McMaster says president's policy to withdraw troops from Afghanistan is 'unwise' Cast of 'Parks and Rec' reunite for virtual town hall to address Wisconsin voters Biden says Trump should step down over coronavirus response MORE’s policies and rhetoric on minorities and immigrants, but the move toward unity accelerated dramatically as COVID-19 disproportionately affected communities of color, leading to increased coordination among the minority lawmakers.

“We have much in common, and we started off the beginning of last year agreeing to work together much closer and have it be beyond the three chairs, because that’s what it has been historically,” said CBC Chairwoman Karen BassKaren Ruth BassPatients are dying unnecessarily from organ donation policy failures Hispanic caucus report takes stock of accomplishments with eye toward 2021 Bogeymen of the far left deserve a place in any Biden administration MORE (D-Calif.).

Bass said the Tri-Caucus was planning to focus on the upcoming once-in-a-decade census and the 2020 elections but was forced to pivot as communities of color became the hardest hit by the coronavirus.

Most recently, the Tri-Caucus pushed for economic relief for foreign taxpayers without Social Security numbers in the last House coronavirus package, including for many undocumented immigrants and their U.S. citizen spouses and children.

The measure was targeted by House Republicans, who attempted a last-minute legislative maneuver Friday to divide Democrats on the issue, claiming it would unfairly grant benefits to undocumented immigrants.

Although 13 House Democrats voted for the Republican measure, the maneuver was shot down and the House passed the relief bill, including the provision to include undocumented taxpayers in economic relief.

ADVERTISEMENT

“The pandemic has affected our communities of color so drastically that it’s caused us to come together to deal with it,” said CAPAC Chairwoman Judy ChuJudy May ChuLawmakers of color blast Trump administration for reportedly instructing agencies to end anti-bias training Lawmakers of color urge Democratic leadership to protect underserved communities in coronavirus talks Geraldo Rivera to Trump: Asian friends of mine say 'China virus' has 'racial overtone' MORE (D-Calif.), who leads the Tri-Caucus along with Bass and CHC Chairman Joaquin CastroJoaquin CastroHispanic Caucus members embark on 'virtual bus tour' with Biden campaign Hispanic caucus report takes stock of accomplishments with eye toward 2021 Democratic lawmakers call for an investigation into allegations of medical neglect at Georgia ICE facility MORE (D-Texas).

Chu said that health care issues are a natural causeway for the Tri-Caucus, which has from the onset focused on health disparities faced by people of color.

For instance, the Tri-Caucus has worked on exposing and preventing long-standing health care disparities among communities of color, which have now contributed to much higher coronavirus death rates among black, Hispanic and Pacific Islander Americans.

Immigration has also been at the top of the agenda for the group, but its component caucuses have conflicting priorities at times.

For instance, a top CHC priority is the regularization of 11 million undocumented immigrants in the country, while the CBC’s immigration focus is on the diversity visa program, also known as the visa lottery, and many of the CAPAC’s core constituents are concerned about backlogs in the legal immigration system.

The Trump administration in 2018 tried to exploit those differences, offering in immigration reform negotiations different combinations of immigration policies that could have benefited some minority groups over others.

The strategy, which Democrats viewed as an attempt to drive a wedge between its constituent groups, backfired.

“We, the Tri-Caucus, have stood side by side on a pathway to citizenship, on fixing our legal immigration system and on the diversity visas — we will not be pitted against one another,” said Chu.

But historically, the caucuses were often at odds with each other, squabbling over committee assignments and legislative positions.

“In the past there was a rivalry between the black and Hispanic caucuses, and I recall that Speaker [Tom] Foley at the time tried to deemphasize the rivalry by appointing two deputy whips, one from the Hispanic Caucus and one from the Black Caucus,” said former New Mexico Gov. Bill Richardson (D), who during his 14-year House career chaired the CHC from 1983 to 1985.

Richardson said as the caucuses have grown, their impact on policy has expanded and their political clout has moved beyond the confines of the House of Representatives.

“In my day the focus of the caucus was helping members get good committee assignments; secondly, we established an institute; and third, we were trying constantly to bring the Republican caucus members as members of the Congressional Hispanic Caucus,” said Richardson.

“[Now] it’s not just a great bully pulpit, but it also helps shape important legislation,” he added.

The caucuses have not only grown in size, but they’ve also expanded their campaign footprint, with the CBC and CHC opening their own PACs, designed to expand the caucuses and to support allies in their election and reelection efforts.

And the unity afforded by the Tri-Caucus has allowed the three constituent caucuses to mold their policy provisions and coordinate tactics.

In 2001, Rep. Eddie Bernice JohnsonEddie Bernice JohnsonHillicon Valley: DOJ indicts Chinese, Malaysian hackers accused of targeting over 100 organizations | GOP senators raise concerns over Oracle-TikTok deal | QAnon awareness jumps in new poll House passes legislation to boost election security research Hillicon Valley: Twitter flags Trump campaign tweet of Biden clip as manipulated media | Democrats demand in-person election security briefings resume | Proposed rules to protect power grid raise concerns MORE (D-Texas) was chairwoman of the CBC and a member of the CAPAC — her district hosted nearly as many Asian Americans as African Americans — when she got the idea to start the Tri-Caucus.

“In 2001 when I was chair of the CBC, I started the Tri-Caucus because I thought it would give us more clout in issues common to the three groups,” said Johnson.

“Our issues have always been pretty much the same, and we go into different phases of experiences with nearly the same statistics,” she added.

ADVERTISEMENT

Still, some have criticized caucuses centered on shared ethnicity or national origin as expressions of identity politics, as Americans of all origins face similar issues.

Richardson said the caucuses should be gauged by the representation they afford their constituents.

“I think that’s healthy in my view. Nationally I’d like to see less identity politics, but within the House it’s a reality, it’s good,” he said.

And Castro, the CHC chair, said the Tri-Caucus, which now often collaborates with Reps. Deb HaalandDebra HaalandHispanic caucus report takes stock of accomplishments with eye toward 2021 Rep. Robin Kelly enters race for Democratic caucus vice chair OVERNIGHT ENERGY: Democrats push resolution to battle climate change, sluggish economy and racial injustice | Senators reach compromise on greenhouse gas amendment stalling energy bill | Trump courts Florida voters with offshore drilling moratorium MORE (D-N.M.) and Sharice DavidsSharice DavidsRaces heat up for House leadership posts GOP leader says he doesn't want Chamber's endorsement: 'They have sold out' US Chamber of Commerce set to endorse 23 House freshman Democrats MORE (D-Kan.), the two Native American women in Congress, also serves to protect the interests of communities that have historically come under attack in the United States.

Castro pointed to the historical experience of black Americans, the nativist attack against Hispanics in El Paso in  August and xenophobic attacks against Asian Americans during the coronavirus pandemic as examples.

“What some people misunderstand is that these communities of color have the same concerns as other communities, but they’ve also been especially vulnerable to attack over the years,” said Castro.