The Hill's Morning Report - Fallout from day one of Trump impeachment hearing


Welcome to The Hill’s Morning Report. Happy Thursday! Our newsletter gets you up to speed on the most important developments in politics and policy, plus trends to watch. Alexis Simendinger and Al Weaver are the up-early co-creators. Find us @asimendinger and @alweaver22 on Twitter and CLICK HERE to subscribe!

House Democrats received a major boost during the first public testimony of the impeachment inquiry hearings on Wednesday as they continue to press the case against President TrumpDonald John TrumpSanders apologizes to Biden for supporter's op-ed Jayapal: 'We will end up with another Trump' if the US doesn't elect progressive Democrats: McConnell impeachment trial rules a 'cover up,' 'national disgrace' MORE over his withholding of military aid from Ukraine for investigations into his political rivals. 


While not much new was unearthed during the five hours of testimony from a pair of witnesses, William Taylor, the U.S. chargé d'affaires for Ukraine, told lawmakers that a member of his staff overheard a conversation between the president and U.S.


Ambassador to the European Union Gordon SondlandGordon SondlandTrump lawyers urge senators to swiftly acquit Trump in impeachment trial Parnas pressure grows on Senate GOP Five takeaways from Parnas's Maddow interview MORE, who has been at the center of the Ukraine situation, a day after the president’s July 25 call with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky.


The staffer told Taylor that Trump was interested in the news on “the investigations,” according to the longtime diplomat’s testimony, referring to the probes sought by Rudy GiulianiRudy GiulianiParnas attorney asks William Barr to recuse himself from investigation Poll: 51 percent of Americans say Senate should convict and remove Trump Hypocrisy is the currency of the realm for GOP in the age of Trump MORE, Trump’s personal attorney, into former Vice President Joe BidenJoe BidenSanders apologizes to Biden for supporter's op-ed Jayapal: 'We will end up with another Trump' if the US doesn't elect progressive White House appoints GOP House members to advise Trump's impeachment team MORE, his son Hunter Biden and 2016 election interference. Sondland replied that the Ukrainians “were ready to move forward,” Taylor said (The Hill).  


Taylor said that after the conversation, the staffer asked Sondland what the president thought about Ukraine.


“President Trump cares more about the investigations of Biden,” Sondland replied, according to the testimony (The Hill).   


Taylor told investigators that he did not bring up the episode during his Oct. 22 private deposition because he did not know about it then.


The Washington Post: Ambassador’s cell phone call to Trump placed from a Kyiv restaurant was a breach of security, former officials say.  


For Democrats, the information led them to request a closed-door deposition with David Holmes, the staffer in question. Holmes, who worked at the U.S. Embassy in Ukraine under Taylor, is expected to testify on Friday. Investigators also requested private testimony on Saturday from Mark Sandy, an official at the Office of Management and Budget. 


Trump denied any knowledge of the call when pressed about it by Fox News’s John Roberts after the revelation. 


“I know nothing about that. First time I’ve heard it,” Trump said. “I don’t recall [a July 26 call with Sondland]. … “There was no quid pro quo” (The Hill).


Trump, during a joint news conference with Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan, said he will release on Thursday a transcript of another phone call he had with Zelensky, which he said was, like his July 25 call, “perfect.”


John F. Harris: Trump exposed: A brutal day for the president.


The Washington Post: On Day One of the impeachment, the Trump Show continues to disrupt Washington.


Elsewhere, The Hill’s Scott Wong and Mike Lillis break down the opening day of public hearings and give their top takeaways. Among them was House Intelligence Committee Chairman Adam SchiffAdam Bennett SchiffWhite House appoints GOP House members to advise Trump's impeachment team Trump knocks authors of 'A Very Stable Genius': 'Two stone cold losers from Amazon WP' Democrats push back on White House impeachment claims, saying Trump believes he is above the law MORE (D-Calif.) and his firm grip on the hearing, which turned out to be a relatively civil event. 


Democrats prepared for distractions of all kinds, including audience protests, outbursts from lawmakers and other demonstrations of dissent from Trump’s GOP allies. However, they were far and few between. 


The questioning from the GOP side of the dais yielded mixed results. While Rep. Jim JordanJames (Jim) Daniel JordanWhite House appoints GOP House members to advise Trump's impeachment team Sunday shows preview: Lawmakers gear up for Senate impeachment trial Trump's legal team gets set for impeachment trial MORE (R-Ohio) was lauded by many on the right for his back-and-forth with Taylor and Deputy Assistant Secretary of State for European and Eurasian Affairs George Kent, others were not as successful, headlined by Steve Castor, the Republican counsel. 


The Hill: Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnellAddison (Mitch) Mitchell McConnellDemocrats: McConnell impeachment trial rules a 'cover up,' 'national disgrace' Romney pledges 'open mind' ahead of impeachment trial McConnell proposes compressed schedule for impeachment trial MORE (R-Ky.) discounts quick dismissal of Trump impeachment articles: “We'll have to have a trial.”


With today’s hearing in the rearview mirror, attention will now turn to Friday when Marie Yovanovitch, the former U.S. ambassador to Ukraine, will testify publicly before the panel about her removal from the post in Kyiv. Yovanovitch came up during today’s hearing as Kent described a “smear campaign” by Giuliani against her prior to her ouster.


The Associated Press: Next up in the impeachment hearings.


Reuters: In interviews, voters in two key states say impeachment hearings won’t change their views of Trump. 



POLITICS & CAMPAIGNS: The 2020 Democratic field is set to expand. Former Massachusetts Gov. Deval PatrickDeval PatrickPatrick backs reparations in unveiling 'Equity Agenda for Black Americans' Buttigieg to attend MLK Day event in South Carolina after facing criticism Deval Patrick knocks lack of diversity in Democratic debate MORE is expected today to announce a White House bid, The New York Times reports, leaping into the contest while some Democrats publicly fret about the party’s chances of defeating Trump next year.


According to multiple reports, Patrick told allies he will file for the New Hampshire primary ahead of the state’s deadline on Friday. The former two-term governor will play catch-up in a rollicking race with less than three months before the first caucus goers and primary voters head to the polls. 


While Democrats view Patrick favorably and consider him a formidable contender, some suggest the time crunch to raise money and build a campaign organization in key early primary states poses a steep challenge. Patrick faces only weeks to qualify under the Democratic National Committee rules for a debate in mid-December, as well as the debates that follow — events intended  to winnow the party’s crowded field.


“I think that Gov. Patrick is an incredibly talented politician, but I think it’s a hard road to put together the kind of staff and operations and raise the money in 100 days. … I think it’s a hard task,” said Rep. Katherine ClarkKatherine Marlea ClarkSanders, Warren battle for progressive endorsements Democrats ramp up calls for war powers vote after Iran strike Nearly all Democrats expected to back articles of impeachment MORE (D-Mass.), who has endorsed fellow Bay State Democrat Sen. Elizabeth WarrenElizabeth Ann WarrenJayapal: 'We will end up with another Trump' if the US doesn't elect progressive Former health insurance executive: Current system is bankrupting country The American disease and death bowls MORE (Mass.). “He’s always formidable. … He was a very successful governor. He’s a very talented politician. I think it’s really a question of timing.” 


Massachusetts Rep. Seth MoultonSeth MoultonOvernight Defense: Iran crisis eases as Trump says Tehran 'standing down' | Dems unconvinced on evidence behind Soleimani strike | House sets Thursday vote on Iran war powers Congress reacts to US assassination of Iranian general Key moments in the 2020 Democratic presidential race so far MORE (D), who ended his own presidential bid in late August, said on Wednesday that while he had not spoken with Patrick, he will consider a possible endorsement of the former governor. Moulton is one of three members of his state’s congressional delegation who has not endorsed a contender in the 2020 race. 


“We need someone who can win, and I’ve said from the very beginning: Beating Trump is not going to be as easy as people think, and I think that Gov. Patrick can make a compelling case there,” Moulton said, adding that he believes Patrick also has the ability to “bring the country together.


“It’s something that I’ll look at very carefully,” Moulton said of an endorsement, adding that he is also a fan of Biden and is close with his team.


With an announcement expected, Patrick is slated to appear on “CBS This Morning” at 8 a.m. today. 


Patrick’s entrance is another sign there is no clear front-runner for the nomination. Former New York City Mayor Michael BloombergMichael Rubens BloombergBloomberg, Steyer focus on climate change in effort to stand out I'm a conservative against Citizens United Trump scrambles to defend pre-existing conditions record amid ObamaCare lawsuit MORE, like the former governor from Massachusetts, is testing his theory that there’s room to influence a contest built around challenging Trump, according to Niall Stanage’s latest memo


The Hill: Warren goes local in race to build a 2020 movement.



> Settling an election: Kentucky Gov. Matt Bevin (R) is facing a critical moment today, as every county board of election in the state will convene and recanvass the results of his expected loss to Gov.-elect Andy Beshear on Nov. 5. 


Bevin, who has not conceded, is holding out hope that the recanvass, which involves officials looking at each voting machine to ensure that totals were correctly added, will help him narrow the gap against Beshear, who topped Bevin on election night by 0.38 percentage points. 


As the Lexington Herald Leader writes, the recanvass is unlikely to change the result.


“I would be very surprised if even one vote changes,” said Fayette County Clerk Don Blevins, adding that the process is the main reason. “It’s roughly the equivalent to checking to make sure a spreadsheet can add correctly.”


The Associated Press: Kentucky governor faces big decision in contested election.


WHITE HOUSE & ADMINISTRATION: Trump greeted Erdoğan on Wednesday for their first meeting following a month-long saga of hostilities and attempted reconciliation in the wake of Turkey's Oct. 9 attacks on Syrian Kurds in northeastern Syria (The Hill). 


The president and Republican lawmakers who participated in a White House meeting with the two leaders took issue with Turkey’s treatment of the Kurds and its purchase of an air defense system from Russia. Erdoğan said during a joint news conference that he rejected recent House actions meant to punish Turkey, arguing the rebukes damage his country’s relations with the United States. Trump sought to patch things up, noting he wants to seal a bilateral agreement that would increase U.S. trade with Turkey to as much as $1 billion (The Associated Press).



> Eight years of Trump’s tax returns can be obtained by Congress, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit ruled on Wednesday. The decision will be appealed by the president’s lawyers, pushing the challenge a step closer to the Supreme Court, where the president and his attorneys want it to be decided. The case on which the D.C. Circuit Court ruled centers on a House Oversight and Reform Committee subpoena from March seeking the president’s accounting firm records (The Hill). 


> Justice Department: “Project Guardian” is the name of a new administration initiative that Attorney General William BarrWilliam Pelham BarrParnas attorney asks William Barr to recuse himself from investigation Dems plan marathon prep for Senate trial, wary of Trump trying to 'game' the process Pentagon to place new restrictions, monitoring on foreign military students MORE said on Wednesday would add tougher federal enforcement to the U.S. gun background check system (The Associated Press). Barr said the improvements would better coordinate federal, state and local gun cases and help prosecutors who want to quickly update databases and determine when a defendant cannot possess a firearm because of mental health issues. 


The attorney general said Congress is unlikely to vote on gun legislation this year because of the pace of the impeachment inquiry, although he sidestepped the president’s reluctance to challenge the powerful gun lobby, the National Rifle Association, during his bid for reelection. 


“We are going forward with all the operational steps that we can take that do not require legislative action,” Barr said.

The Morning Report is created by journalists Alexis Simendinger and Al Weaver. We want to hear from you! Email: and We invite you to share The Hill’s reporting and newsletters, and encourage others to SUBSCRIBE!


Time to stop talking ‘quid pro quo’ and start looking at actual crimes, by Allan Lichtman, opinion contributor, The Hill.


Amid impeachment hearings, it’s worth remembering why Ukraine matters, by Daniel Fried, opinion contributor, The Hill.


Hill.TV’s “Rising” program features Donald Trump Jr.Donald (Don) John TrumpComedians post fake Army recruitment posters featuring Trump Jr. Trump Jr., Ivanka garner support in hypothetical 2024 poll FWS: There's 'no basis' to investigate Trump Jr.'s Mongolian hunting trip MORE to discuss his new book, “Triggered”; Rep. Jody HiceJody Brownlow HiceHouse GOP lawmaker wants Senate to hold 'authentic' impeachment trial GOP lawmaker reacts to Democrats moving forward on impeachment The Hill's Morning Report - Sponsored by AdvaMed - House panel expected to approve impeachment articles Thursday MORE (R-Ga.) to react to the impeachment hearings; and Ryan Clancy and Margaret White, senior advisers for No Labels, on their new book, “The Ultimate Guide to the 2020 Election.” Coverage starts at 9 a.m. ET at or on YouTube at 10 a.m. at Rising on YouTube.


The House meets at 10 a.m.


The Senate convenes at 10 a.m.


The president begins his public schedule at 2 p.m. when he meets with Jens Stoltenberg, secretary general of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization. Trump leaves the White House at 4 p.m. to headline a reelection rally in Bossier City, La., at 8 p.m. ET. He’ll return to the White House after midnight.


Vice President Pence, who is in California today, will visit the NASA Ames Research Center in Mountain View and speak to employees in the morning before returning to Washington.


Secretary of State Mike PompeoMichael (Mike) Richard PompeoCountries reach agreement in Berlin on Libya cease-fire push, arms embargo Trump Jr.: If 'weaker' Republicans only call for certain witnesses, 'they don't deserve to be in office' House Democrats may call new impeachment witnesses if Senate doesn't MORE meets with Saudi Foreign Minister Prince Faisal bin Farhan Al Saud at 8:30 a.m. The secretary meets with Syria Small Group Ministerial participants at the State Department at 9 a.m. An hour later, Pompeo delivers a speech to the participants of the Global Coalition to Defeat ISIS Small Group Ministerial held at the department. Pompeo meets with NATO’s Stoltenberg at 11 a.m., and at noon, he meets with New Zealand Deputy Prime Minister and Foreign Minister Winston Peters, followed by a working luncheon for the participants of the ISIS Small Group Ministerial. At 1 p.m., Pompeo meets with French Foreign Minister Jean-Yves Le Drian.


Federal Reserve Chairman Jerome Powell will testify about the economic outlook to the House Budget Committee at 10 a.m. The Hill’s Sylvan Lane reports that lawmakers continue to ask Powell about economic headwinds including tariffs, a future recession and a few bemoan rising federal deficits and debt.


The Hill hosts a newsmaker event, “America’s Veterans: The Next Mission,” at 8:30 a.m. at the Newseum with guests Sen. Todd YoungTodd Christopher YoungIran resolution supporters fear impeachment will put it on back burner Senate GOP's campaign arm hauls in million in 2019 Sens. Kaine, Lee: 'We should not be at war with Iran unless Congress authorizes it' MORE (R-Ind.), a veteran of the U.S. Marine Corps; Sen. Jon TesterJonathan (Jon) TesterI'm a conservative against Citizens United Pelosi set to send impeachment articles to the Senate next week Pelosi says she'll send articles of impeachment to Senate 'soon' MORE (D-Mont.), the ranking member of the Senate Veterans’ Affairs Committee; and Gen. George W. Casey Jr., former U.S. Army chief of staff. Information and registration are HERE.


The National Archives hosts a World War II photography event at 7:30 p.m. in Washington at the McGowan Theater, showcasing 1945 U.S. Army Pictorial Center Signal Corps photographs from the Archives’s collection. The photos are part of the book, “Aftershock: The Human Toll of War.” Panelists include the authors, Richard Cahan and Mark Jacob; Erik Villard, historian with the U.S. Army Center of Military History; Rebecca Raines, author of, “History of the U.S. Army Signal Corps”; and the Archives’s Kaitlyn Crain Enriquez. The program is free; info  HERE.


Cyber: Disinformation circulating on social media targeting veterans has increased, prompting lawmakers and tech platforms to talk about ways to tackle the trend (The Hill).


Space: It’s going to take a year for a return trip, but a Japanese spacecraft is headed home after successfully completing its mission to gather soil samples from the asteroid Ryugu (“Dragon Palace”), which is about 180 million miles from Earth. The Japan Aerospace Exploration Agency, cheering an endeavor carried out over 18 months by the unmanned Hayabusa2 spacecraft, believes the data could provide clues to the origins of the solar system (The Associated Press).



Venice: Italy’s beautiful city on canals is “on its knees” after the second-worst flood ever recorded. Water reached higher than six feet above the average sea level on Tuesday, climbing to within two inches of the historic flood of 1966. The submerged piazzas, walkways and tourist attractions remained sodden on Wednesday. In Venice, the crypt beneath St. Mark’s Basilica was inundated for only the second time in its history. Damage was also reported at the Ca’ Pesaro modern art gallery, where a short circuit sparked a fire, and at La Fenice theater, where authorities turned off the electricity as a precaution after the control room was flooded (The Associated Press).



And finally … It’s Thursday, which means it’s time for this week’s Morning Report Quiz! Riveted by impeachment proceedings, we’re eager for some smart guesses about the Constitution and Congress’s role in the attempted removal of presidents from office.


Email your responses to and/or, and please add “Quiz” to subject lines. Winners who submit correct answers find their reward in newsletter fame on Friday.


How does the U.S. Constitution describe impeachable offenses?


  1. Treason
  2. Bribery
  3. Other high crimes and misdemeanors
  4. All of the above


Two-part question: How many U.S. presidents have been impeached by the House, and how many have been removed from office following impeachment and conviction?


  1. One and one
  2. Two and none
  3. Two and one
  4. Three and none


How many votes are needed to convict a president of articles of impeachment approved by the House and sent to the Senate, as specified in the wording of the Constitution?


  1. Majority
  2. Majority plus Supreme Court chief justice
  3. Two-thirds of the members present
  4. Two-thirds supermajority plus chief justice


What punishment does the Constitution specify as a judgment following a president’s impeachment and conviction?


  1. Removal from office and forfeiture of federal pension
  2. Removal from office and disqualification to hold any U.S. office
  3. Removal from office and imprisonment with a sentence determined by the Supreme Court
  4. Removal from office along with a financial penalty that must be recommended by the House impeachment managers and approved by a Senate majority, payable to the U.S. Treasury