The Hill's Morning Report - Dem dilemma on articles of impeachment




Welcome to The Hill’s Morning Report. Happy Thursday! Our newsletter gets you up to speed on the most important developments in politics and policy, plus trends to watch. Alexis Simendinger and Al Weaver are the up-early co-creators. Find us @asimendinger and @alweaver22 on Twitter and CLICK HERE to subscribe!

The House Judiciary Committee kicked off a new phase of the impeachment inquiry on Wednesday with a hearing featuring scholars to debate whether President TrumpDonald John TrumpWarren: Dershowitz presentation 'nonsensical,' 'could not follow it' Bolton told Barr he was concerned Trump did favors for autocrats: report Dershowitz: Bolton allegations would not constitute impeachable offense MORE’s actions concerning Ukraine warrant his removal from office as lawmakers debate what articles of impeachment to include in a potential House floor vote. 


The hearing, which quickly devolved into partisan bickering, featured three experts chosen by Democrats and one by the GOP minority to argue whether Trump committed offenses warranting his impeachment. The scholars’ testimony broke along partisan lines, giving lawmakers ammunition to support divergent views. 


“I will honor my oath, and as I sit here today, having heard consistent, clear and compelling evidence that the president has abused his power, attempted to undermine the constitutional role of Congress, and corrupted our elections, I urge my colleagues to stand behind the oath you have taken,” Judiciary Committee Chairman Jerrold NadlerJerrold (Jerry) Lewis NadlerPelosi says House will vote on bill to repeal travel ban Nadler to miss a day of impeachment trial due to wife's cancer treatment Impeachment manager dismisses concerns Schiff alienated key Republican votes: 'This isn't about any one person' MORE (D-N.Y.) said at the end of a long day of back-and-forth. “Our democracy depends on it.”


Speaker Nancy PelosiNancy PelosiHouse passes bill aimed at bolstering Holocaust education Hillicon Valley — Presented by Philip Morris International — NFL social media accounts hacked | Dem questions border chief over controversial Facebook group | Clinton says Zuckerberg has 'authoritarian' views Meadows: Republicans who break with Trump could face political repercussions MORE (D-Calif.) will deliver a statement on the “status of impeachment inquiry” at 9 a.m., her office announced early this morning. 


Democratic lawmakers on Wednesday gave their clearest indication of potential articles of impeachment that could be brought to the House floor ahead of Congress’s holiday break. As Scott Wong and Cristina Marcos note, the majority displayed placards during the hearing describing abuse of power and bribery, obstruction of Congress and obstruction of justice. 


“I’m for a keep-it-simple scope,” Rep. Eric SwalwellEric Michael SwalwellMartha McSally fundraises off 'liberal hack' remark to CNN reporter Enes Kanter sees political stardom — after NBA and WWE Swalwell pens op-ed comparing Trump impeachment to XYZ Affair MORE (D-Calif.), a Judiciary Committee member, told The Hill.


The Associated Press: Impeachment takeaways: History lessons, partisan feuds. 


The New York Times: Scholars call Trump’s actions on Ukraine an impeachable abuse of power.


House Democrats showed that they are pushing their chips into the middle of the table on impeachment. Pelosi held an all-caucus meeting on Wednesday morning prior to the hearing at which cell phones and staff members were banned (The Associated Press). According to Mike Lillis and Juliegrace Brufke, Pelosi posed a simple question to her caucus. 


"Are you ready?" Pelosi said, receiving an enthusiastic response, according to sources inside the room.


The Speaker called on her members to remain focused on key evidence and to read the 300-page report the House Intelligence Committee released on Tuesday after its two-month investigation. The report is based on private and public witness interviews. Politico reported that Pelosi urged her colleagues to stick with the Democrats’ assertion that Trump abused his office in an effort to have Ukraine investigate his political rivals. 


Some did not heed her message. Rep. Al GreenAlexander (Al) N. GreenThe Memo: Will Iran crisis sideline impeachment process? Green says House shouldn't hold impeachment articles indefinitely GOP set to make life difficult for Democrats on impeachment MORE (D-Texas), a longtime proponent of impeaching Trump, said any upcoming articles of impeachment should be expanded to include the president’s aggravation of U.S. racial tensions (The Hill).


Politico: Moderate Dems warn against “kitchen sink” impeachment push.


The Hill: Rep. Devin NunesDevin Gerald NunesDemocratic lawmaker dismisses GOP lawsuit threat: 'Take your letter and shove it' House Democrats release second batch of Parnas materials Democratic lawmaker says Nunes threatened to sue him over criticism MORE (R-Calif.) accuses Democrats of promoting “conspiracy theories.”


Bloomberg News: Rudy GiulianiRudy GiulianiTrump lawyers offer defense of Giuliani on the Senate floor Giuliani: Bolton sacrificing his integrity 'to make a few bucks on a book' The Hill's Morning Report - Report of Bolton tell-all manuscript roils Trump defense MORE on Calls: “Remember, I’m the president’s attorney.”


There is no set schedule for future Judiciary Committee hearings, although two more are expected. Lawmakers have a little more than two weeks before they break for the holiday season to return again in January. 


The Hill: Trump's legal team huddles with Senate Republicans.


The Hill: Stanford Law School professor Pamela Karlan apologized on Wednesday for mentioning Trump's 13-year-old son, Barron Trump, during the impeachment hearing. First lady Melania TrumpMelania TrumpPro-Trump singer wears 'Impeached and Re-elected' dress to the Grammys The Hill's 12:30 Report: Trump beefs up impeachment defense with Dershowitz, Starr Trump welcomes LSU to the White House: 'Go Tigers' MORE, who was returning to Washington from London, strongly objected on Twitter to the professor’s remarks.





POLITICS & CAMPAIGNS: Democrats are venting, expressing frustration and searching for answers in the wake of Sen. Kamala HarrisKamala Devi HarrisBiden leads 2020 pack in congressional endorsements Harris on 2020 endorsement: 'I am not thinking about it right now' Panel: Is Kamala Harris a hypocrite for mulling a Joe Biden endorsement? MORE’s (D-Calif.) exit from the 2020 contest as their primary field — once exemplified by its diversity and extreme largesse — has been cut down to a top tier of white candidates. 


As Jonathan Easley writes, Harris’s exit from the race on Tuesday underscored the degree to which the candidates of color have struggled to gain traction. With Harris gone, the remaining six candidates who have qualified for the December debate are all white, an embarrassing development for a party that has described diversity as its greatest strength. 


While diverse candidates still remain in the race, including Sen. Cory BookerCory Anthony BookerSenate Dems to Pompeo: Comments about NPR reporter 'insulting and contemptuous' Black caucus in Nevada: 'Notion that Biden has all of black vote is not true' The Hill's 12:30 Report: House managers to begin opening arguments on day two MORE (D-N.J.), Andrew YangAndrew YangOvernight Energy: Sanders scores highest on green group's voter guide | Trump's latest wins for farmers may not undo trade damage | Amazon employees defy company to speak on climate change Majority sees no ties between business experience and political success Sanders scores highest on green group's voter guide MORE and former Housing and Urban Development Secretary Julián Castro, only a week remains for candidates to qualify, with Booker and Castro facing a steep climb to do so. However, finger pointing has begun for some Democrats as they accuse the media of going easy on the white candidates. 


Along with the lack of diversity in the top tier, Harris’s exit has other key effects on the race for the party’s nomination, as Niall Stanage lays out in his latest memo. While Harris drew only modest support by the end of her campaign, her endorsement would be valuable for any candidate in the field, especially in the push to win support from African American voters. She also stands as a potential vice presidential choice, which former Vice President Joe BidenJoe BidenWarren: Dershowitz presentation 'nonsensical,' 'could not follow it' Bolton told Barr he was concerned Trump did favors for autocrats: report Dershowitz: Bolton allegations would not constitute impeachable offense MORE noted during a campaign stop in Iowa on Wednesday (The Hill).


Along with VP speculations, questions also surround where her supporters, fundraisers and staffers will go, and whether she could have a particular impact on the primary outcome in her home state of California, where her endorsement could have a profound effect.


The Associated Press: Campaigns swarm Harris donors after she exits the 2020 race.


The Washington Post: On “No Malarkey” tour, Biden seeks to reignite Iowa campaign — and vents frustration.





> Democratic dough: While part of Harris’s downfall was due to a cash flow problem, others in the Democratic primary field have the opposite issue as the field has become filled with billionaire cash, angering the left and presenting new hurdles for candidates struggling to stay in the race. 


As Jonathan Easley and Max Greenwood write, former New York City Mayor Michael BloombergMichael Rubens BloombergSteyer would have owed M more in taxes under lawmakers' proposal: liberal group Majority sees no ties between business experience and political success Fifth congressional Democrat backs Bloomberg in 2020 race MORE and Tom SteyerTom Fahr SteyerSouth Carolina woman behind popular Obama slogan says she backs Steyer Overnight Energy: Sanders scores highest on green group's voter guide | Trump's latest wins for farmers may not undo trade damage | Amazon employees defy company to speak on climate change Steyer would have owed M more in taxes under lawmakers' proposal: liberal group MORE have combined to blow past the $100 million mark, leading to allegations that they're seeking to buy the nomination, which has infuriated progressives. 


Steyer has outspent everyone on digital ads this cycle and just qualified for the December debate, in part because his blanket of ads have propped him up in the polls and continued to push him onto the debate stage. Meanwhile, Bloomberg, who entered the race only two weeks ago, began with an astonishing $50 million ad buy that has blanketed the airwaves and social media. Prior to Harris’s exit, a new Morning Consult poll showed that he had moved past her despite the fact that she’d been in the race for nearly 11 months.


Progressives had hoped that the two candidates would stay out of the race and instead direct their big dollars at issues such as climate change and gun control. Instead, the ad buys by Bloomberg and Steyer could drown out last-ditch efforts by struggling candidates relying on more modest ad buys in an effort to stay in the race to Iowa and beyond.


The Associated Press: Booker’s critical test? Languishing campaign plots rebound.


Elsewhere in politics … After weeks of discussions, Georgia Gov. Brian Kemp ® appointed Republican Kelly Loeffler, a wealthy Atlanta financial executive, to replace outgoing Sen. Johnny IsaksonJohnny IsaksonCollins expected to announce Georgia Senate bid GOP senator: Romney trying to 'appease the left' with impeachment witnesses Overnight Health Care: New drug price hikes set stage for 2020 fight | Conservative group to spend M attacking Pelosi drug plan | Study finds Medicaid expansion improved health in Southern states MORE (R-Ga.) in the upper chamber. Loeffler is expected to drop at least $20 million on her 2020 bid to fill the remainder of Isakson’s term (Politico) … Rep. Tulsi GabbardTulsi GabbardYang qualifies for New Hampshire debate stage Poll: Bernie Sanders holds 9-point lead in New Hampshire The establishment scam of 'unity' MORE (D-Hawaii) is giving up the Hawaiian sunshine for the New Hampshire winter, for this year at least. Gabbard revealed that she is moving to the Granite State for the duration of the 2020 campaign, placing her bets on the first-in-the-nation primary in her bid for the party’s nomination while others have made similar moves in Iowa (ABC News) … Hillary ClintonHillary Diane Rodham ClintonDershowitz: Bolton allegations would not constitute impeachable offense Hillicon Valley — Presented by Philip Morris International — NFL social media accounts hacked | Dem questions border chief over controversial Facebook group | Clinton says Zuckerberg has 'authoritarian' views Clinton on Sanders comments: 'I wasn't thinking about the election' MORE sat down for a lengthy and wide-ranging interview with SiriusXM host Howard Stern on Thursday. During the extended discussion, the pair discussed Trump’s inauguration speech, Sen.
Lindsey GrahamLindsey Olin GrahamGraham says he wants to see Bolton manuscript Bolton upends Trump impeachment trial  Juan Williams: Democrats can't let Trump off the hook MORE’s “brain snatch,” and how she met former President Clinton, among other items (
Howard Stern).  


WHITE HOUSE & ADMINISTRATION: Trump cut his participation in a two-day NATO summit short on Wednesday, canceling a scheduled press conference in London to return to Washington early. The president held a series of bilateral meetings, including with German Chancellor Angela Merkel, and then took exception to a viral video clip captured during a Buckingham Palace reception on Tuesday night showing world leaders huddled in what they thought was a jovial private commiseration, apparently about Trump’s theatrical behavior.


When asked about the pool video snippet circulating on Twitter on Wednesday, Trump responded by calling Canadian Prime Minister Justin TrudeauJustin Pierre James TrudeauUnlikely duo Bill Maher, Megyn Kelly give #CancelCulture scolding it deserves Iran expected to send Ukraine the black boxes from downed passenger plane Poll: Most Canadian taxpayers don't want to pay for Prince Harry and Meghan Markle's security costs MORE “two-faced.” Trudeau’s private asides about Trump and his team could be heard in a conversation that included French President Emmanuel MacronEmmanuel Jean-Michel MacronGerman president expresses 'sorrow' for Holocaust, warns 'spirits of evil' are rising Hillicon Valley — Presented by Philip Morris International — Apple reportedly dropped plans to let iPhone users encrypt backups | Justices decline facial recognition case | Critics fear Facebook losing misinformation fight | Truce on French tech tax On The Money — Presented by Wells Fargo — Trump at Davos warns Europe on trade | President boasts about US economy to global elite | Experts say Trump trade victories may yield little growth MORE and Prime Minister Boris Johnson of the United Kingdom (The New York Times).





The president’s London trip underscored distance from his European counterparts at a time when he wants to showcase leadership on the world stage and international accomplishments heading into an election year and while fighting the threat of impeachment. NATO leaders, familiar with Trump’s pet issues and aware of his unpopularity among their constituents, appeared eager to challenge the American president in public (The Hill).


The New York Times: Trump was mocked abroad and is being assailed at home.


Biden launched a campaign digital ad on Wednesday tapping video seen during Trump’s London trip to make a political case that the president is not held in esteem abroad, to America’s detriment, and that Biden is. The ad calls Trump “the president the world is laughing at” (CNN).


In Washington, meanwhile, Trump got a withering reception from some industry groups to his new proposal to retaliate against France’s digital service tax using U.S. tariffs on $2.4 billion in French goods, including wine and cheese. U.S. consumers pay for such tariffs with higher costs, they argue (The Hill).


> U.S.-China: Today, the Chinese commerce ministry said U.S. tariffs must be cut if China and the United States are to reach an interim agreement on trade. Beijing is sticking to its stance that some U.S. tariffs must be rolled back for a phase one deal (Reuters). Although Trump suggested while in London that trade negotiations with China might not conclude until after the 2020 U.S. election, his trade advisers argued that Beijing was moving closer to a deal (Bloomberg News).


> Agriculture Department & food stamps: A new administration rule announced on Wednesday will tighten work requirements for recipients of the federal food stamp program, which feeds 36 million people. The plan will limit states from exempting work-eligible adults from having to maintain steady employment in order to benefit from food stamps. Effective on April 1, the rule is expected to end benefits for nearly 700,000 people and cut $5.5 billion in federal spending over five years (The New York Times). It is the latest administration policy change designed to scale back the social safety net for low-income Americans, and it’s the first rule to be finalized among three proposed regulatory changes to the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program, known as SNAP (The Associated Press).


> Pentagon: Trump is weighing whether to send an additional 14,000 U.S. troops to the Middle East to prepare for a growing threat from Iran, along with dozens more ships and military equipment. The president could decide this month whether he will expand the U.S. footprint in a part of the world in which he’s been eager to shrink the U.S. presence (The Wall Street Journal). U.S. military and intelligence agencies have fresh information that points to a rising threat from Iran (CNN). Tehran is secretly moving short-range ballistic missiles into Iraq. And while the United States has been expanding its troop strength in the Middle East since the spring, Iran’s latest actions suggest the U.S. efforts to deter Tehran with a show of force have been unsuccessful (The New York Times).

The Morning Report is created by journalists Alexis Simendinger and Al Weaver. We want to hear from you! Email: and We invite you to share The Hill’s reporting and newsletters, and encourage others to SUBSCRIBE!


Republicans need to face reality with hypocrisy on impeachment, by former Rep. Steve IsraelSteven (Steve) J. IsraelWith surge in anti-Semitism, political leaders need to be aggressive and reflective in response Pelosi and Schumer were right with the strategy to delay impeachment The Hill's Morning Report - Deescalation: US-Iran conflict eases MORE (D-N.Y.), opinion contributor, The Hill. 


Trump is wise to fear a socialist opponent, by John Iadarola, opinion contributor, The Hill. 


Hill.TV’s “Rising” program features Nina Turner, a former Democratic state senator from Ohio and national co-chairwoman for Sen. Bernie SandersBernie SandersGOP Iowa senator suggests Trump impeachment defense could hurt Biden at caucuses On The Money: Stocks close with steep losses driven by coronavirus fears | Tax season could bring more refund confusion | Trump's new wins for farmers may not undo trade damage Sanders launches first TV ads in Nevada MORE’s (I-Vt.) presidential campaign; Aaron Maté, host of “Pushback,” airing on The Grayzone, and a contributor to The Nation, to discuss the House impeachment inquiry; The Intercept’s co-founding editor Glenn Greenwald, who previews his interview with Evo Morales, recently forced out as Bolivia’s president; and Henry Davis Jr., a councilman in South Bend, Ind., who discusses his city’s mayor and presidential contender Pete ButtigiegPeter (Pete) Paul ButtigiegOvernight Energy: Sanders scores highest on green group's voter guide | Trump's latest wins for farmers may not undo trade damage | Amazon employees defy company to speak on climate change Sanders surges to first in New Hampshire: poll Majority sees no ties between business experience and political success MORE. Coverage starts at 9 a.m. ET at or on YouTube at 10 a.m. at Rising on YouTube


The House convenes at 10 a.m.


The Senate meets at 10 a.m.


The president will host a White House luncheon with the permanent representatives of the United Nations Security Council at 1 p.m. to mark the United States assumption in December of the rotating presidency of the Security Council. Later, Trump and the first lady plan travel a short distance to the Ellipse for the televised National Christmas Tree Lighting. The president is scheduled to deliver remarks at 5 p.m. before returning to the White House to host one in a series of invitation-only Christmas receptions scheduled this month. 


Treasury Secretary Steven MnuchinSteven Terner MnuchinThe Hill's Morning Report - Report of Bolton tell-all manuscript roils Trump defense Louise Linton, wife of Mnuchin, deletes Instagram post in support of Greta Thunberg Mnuchin: US 'focused' on reaching trade deal with UK by end of year MORE will testify at 10 a.m. about financial stability to the House Financial Services Committee. 


Secretary of State Mike PompeoMichael (Mike) Richard PompeoState Department removes NPR reporter from Pompeo trip Overnight Defense: US military jet crashes in Afghanistan | Rocket attack hits US embassy in Baghdad | Bolton bombshell rocks impeachment trial Please stop calling the impeachment proceeding a trial — it's a charade MORE is traveling in Lisbon, Portugal, and Rabat, Morocco today. This morning he met with U.S. Embassy staff and families in Lisbon, followed by a meeting with Portuguese Prime Minister Antonio Costa and Portuguese Foreign Minister Augusto Santos Silva. Pompeo held a joint press availability with Silva before flying to Morocco. In the afternoon, the secretary meets with Moroccan King Mohammed VI in Rabat, followed by a meeting with Foreign Minister Nasser Bourita. In Rabat, Pompeo will join Bourita for a press conference. In the evening, the secretary will meet Moroccan Head of Government Saadeddine El Othmani. Pompeo will also talk with Moroccan Internal Security Chief Abdellatif Hammouchi. The secretary’s official schedule will end with a dinner hosted by the Moroccan royal family.


Pelosi will hold her weekly press conference at 10:45 a.m. at the Capitol. She will also join CNN at 9 p.m. for a live town hall discussion, which takes place amid the historic House impeachment process (CNN).


Federal Reserve Vice Chairman for Supervision Randal Quarles testifies at 10 a.m. to the Senate Banking Committee. (The Hill’s Sylvan Lane reported that Quarles took some heat on Wednesday from both parties when he testified before the House Financial Services Committee.)


The Library of Congress today opens the first public exhibition of the Rosa Parks Collection, including personal writings, photographs, records and memorabilia. Parks became a civil rights icon after refusing to give up her seat to a white man on a city bus in Montgomery, Ala., in December 1955. The seamstress-turned-activist died in 2005; the archival collection has been available online at the library since 2016.


Economic indicator: The Census Bureau at 8:30 a.m. releases the U.S. international trade report for October.


Germany v. Russia: A brazen shooting in August of a Chechen-Georgian citizen who had survived previous assassination attempts but died in a Berlin park was a murder ordered by either Moscow or authorities in Russia’s republic of Chechnya, prosecutors in Germany alleged. Germany expelled two Russian diplomats on Wednesday as punishment. It’s the latest allegation of Russian-ordered killings on Western European soil. Great Britain blamed Moscow last year for an attempt to poison a former Russian spy and his daughter in the English city of Salisbury. Russia denies involvement in both incidents (The Associated Press).


Horse racing: A 6-year-old gelding named Bo Vuk and a 5-year-old mare named Aikenetta died in separate horse racing incidents at a Laurel, Md., track at the end of November, bringing to at least 14 the number of horses that died this year on Maryland race tracks (The Baltimore Sun). Animal welfare groups want Congress to pass the Horseracing Integrity Act, which would create standards for how racehorses are treated across the nation. Maryland's Sen. Chris Van HollenChristopher (Chris) Van HollenSteyer would have owed M more in taxes under lawmakers' proposal: liberal group Democrats step up pressure over witnesses after Bolton bombshell Fox's Napolitano: There is 'ample and uncontradicted' evidence supporting Trump's removal from office MORE (D) is one of 10 Senate cosponsors. At least 200 House members support the measure (


Baseball: The New York Mets could finally be getting a change in ownership. Steve CohenStephen (Steve) Ira Cohen2019 in Photos: 35 pictures in politics Gabbard under fire for 'present' vote on impeachment Gabbard votes 'present' on impeaching Trump MORE, a billionaire who owns a minority stake in the franchise, is moving toward a deal that would give him control of the team within five years from Sterling Partners, which is controlled by Fred and Jeff Wilpon. The Wilpons have held at least a 50/50 share of the team since 1980. Cohen would become the richest owner in Major League Baseball if the deal goes through. The Wilpons have faced financial troubles for more than a decade after they lost millions of dollars in Bernie Madoff’s Ponzi scheme (ESPN).





And finally … It’s Thursday, which means it’s time for this week’s Morning Report Quiz! ‘Tis the season for opulent White House decorations, which means we’re eager to see some smart guesses (and expert Googling) about Christmas trivia of yore at 1600 Pennsylvania Ave.


Email your responses to and/or, and please add “Quiz” to subject lines. Those who submit correct answers will earn some richly deserved newsletter applause on Friday.


Which first lady began the White House tradition of selecting a decorative theme for the official Christmas tree displayed in the Blue Room? (Hint: It was a “Nutcracker” theme.)


1)        Jacqueline Kennedy

2)        Lady Bird Johnson

3)        Pat Nixon


Which presidential canine broke new ground (and set a record for the most-watched White House video during his master’s first term) while filmed at floor level, dashing and prancing through White House rooms decorated for the holiday season?


1)        Buddy

2)        Barney

3)        Bo


Which state has eclipsed all others in terms of the number of its trees selected for Blue Room Christmas displays over the years?


1)        Montana

2)        Florida

3)        North Carolina


Which president publicly but cheerfully suffered from allergies he blamed on fresh Christmas trees displayed throughout the White House residence?


1)        Richard Nixon

2)        Bill ClintonWilliam (Bill) Jefferson ClintonDershowitz: Bolton allegations would not constitute impeachable offense Some considerations for the US-Iran political interchange Starr makes Trump team debut: We are living in an 'age of impeachment' MORE

3)        Barack ObamaBarack Hussein ObamaSouth Carolina woman behind popular Obama slogan says she backs Steyer Sanders surges while Warren wanes Buttigieg: America 'united in mourning' Kobe Bryant's death MORE


Who was the first president to place electric lights on a White House Christmas tree? (Hint: Electricity was installed in the White House in 1891.)


1)        Chester A. Arthur

2)        Grover Cleveland

3)        Theodore Roosevelt