Protesters wearing blue fill hearing to protest Grassley ignoring ‘blue slip rule’


Demonstrators dressed in blue crowded into a Senate Judiciary Committee meeting on Wednesday to protest Chairman Chuck Grassley’s (R-Iowa) decision to ignore the so-called blue slip rule and move forward with a hearing for one of President Trump’s judicial nominees.

Grassley’s decision to hold the hearing for Milwaukee lawyer Michael Brennan, who is up for a spot on the Chicago-based 7th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, came despite Sen. Tammy Baldwin’s (D-Wis.) refusal to return a blue slip. 

The blue slip rule allows senators from a federal judicial nominee’s home state to essentially veto a nominee. Traditionally, the Judiciary Committee has declined to hold hearings for judicial nominees without approval from the individual’s home state senator.

Zoe Tillman, a reporter for BuzzFeed News, posted a photo of the protest on Twitter on Wednesday.


Grassley announced in November that he would ignore the blue slip rule to hold hearings for two other judicial nominees: David Stras, a nominee to the 8th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, and Kyle Duncan, a nominee to the 5th Circuit.

Protesters dressed in blue T-shirts similarly showed up at a Judiciary Committee meeting in November to oppose Grassley’s decision.

Grassley has said he will keep the blue slip policy in place, but will not let it be abused for partisan or ideological reasons.

The move to ignore Baldwin’s blue slip drew the ire of Democratic lawmakers on the committee, including ranking member Sen. Dianne Feinstein (Calif.) who argued in her opening remarks Wednesday that Grassley had upended a century of precedent by ignoring the blue slip.

She also suggested that Grassley’s decision was insulting to Baldwin. 

“I find it really very hard, and particularly for a woman senator who has tried so hard, who has worked with her state commission, for her view to be rebuffed in this manner,” Feinstein said.

Tags blue slip rule Chuck Grassley Dianne Feinstein Donald Trump Senate Judiciary Committee Senate Judiciary Committee Tammy Baldwin
See all Hill.TV See all Video

Most Popular

Load more


See all Video