Senate confirms Trump pick labeled 'not qualified' by American Bar Association

 
Senators voted 49-44 to approve Sarah Pitlyk's nomination to be a judge for the Eastern District of Missouri. The vote was party line except for GOP Sen. Susan CollinsSusan Margaret CollinsThe Hill's Morning Report - Sponsored by AdvaMed - A crucial week on impeachment Senate braces for brawl on Trump impeachment rules Here are the Senate Republicans who could vote to convict Trump MORE (Maine), who opposed the nomination. 
 
Pitlyk ran into controversy for her previous statements on, and advocacy against, abortion as well as in vitro fertilization and surrogacy.  
 
Democrats railed against her nomination this week ahead of her confirmation. But with Republicans holding a 53-seat majority in the Senate, a nominee can lose three GOP senators and still let Vice President Pence break a tie in their favor. 
 
"Ms. Pitlyk defended a state law banning abortion at six weeks. She opposed the Affordable Care Act's coverage for contraception. ... Ms. Pitlyk has also filed multiple legal briefs that contain misinformation," Sen. Dianne FeinsteinDianne Emiel FeinsteinHouston police chief excoriates McConnell, Cornyn and Cruz on gun violence Life after Yucca Mountain: The time has come to reset US nuclear waste policy Giffords, Demand Justice to pressure GOP senators to reject Trump judicial pick MORE (D-Calif.), the top Democrat on the Senate Judiciary Committee, said during a floor speech.
 
 
Pitlyk — who serves as the special counsel for the Thomas More Society, a conservative law firm — told the National Catholic Register that "surrogacy is harmful to mothers and children, so it’s a practice society should not be enforcing."
 
She also defended Iowa's six-week abortion ban, which was subsequently struck down by a state court. 
 
Sen. Josh HawleyJoshua (Josh) David HawleyTikTok chief cancels Capitol Hill meetings, inflaming tensions Lawsuits pose new challenge for TikTok Tech finds surprise ally in Trump amid high-stakes tax fight MORE (R-Mo.), who is a member of the Judiciary Committee, praised Pitlyk on Wednesday, saying she would be a "a principled and fair judge for decades to come."

"Sarah’s strong legal experience, sharp intellect, and commitment to the rule of law make her an outstanding choice for the Eastern District. I was proud to recommend her to President Trump," he added in a statement.
 
Pitlyk also defended her advocacy work during her hearing before the Judiciary Committee, saying that she was part of a "long line of other people who have sat at this table who have had history in advocacy or in an issue-related advocacy or in politics and who have become very distinguished jurists."
 
But Collins, in a statement explaining her decision to oppose Pitlyk, questioned if Trump's pick would be able to separate her personal views from the rulings she will make as a judge. 
 
"My concern is not based on Ms. Pitlyk’s personal views on abortion or various medical decisions, which she has every right to hold. I do question, however, given her pattern of strident advocacy, whether she could put aside her personal views on these matters," Collins added.
 
Pitlyk was rated "not qualified" by the American Bar Association, according to a memo sent to Judiciary Committee leadership. The outside group's standing committee said it "believes that Ms. Pitlyk does not have the requisite trial or litigation experience or its equivalent." 
 
Collins also pointed to Pitlyk's lack of experience and concerns that the nominee would not be able to set aside her personal views on abortion as reasons she was opposing the nomination. 

"After a careful review of the Judiciary Committee proceedings and Ms. Pitlyk’s legal practice, I have concluded that she does not have sufficient experience to receive a federal district court appointment," Collins said.