Dems seize on votes for Sotomayor by GOP retirees

Democrats are using the fact that four retiring Republican senators voted for Supreme Court nominee Sonia Sotomayor to argue the nominee was well-qualified and that the GOP base is outside of the American mainstream.

The Senate’s 68-31 vote on Thursday made Sotomayor the first Hispanic on the court and only the third woman, coming 72 days after President Barack ObamaBarack Hussein Obama'Forever war' slogans short-circuit the scrutiny required of national security choices Which Democrat can beat Trump? Middle East scholars blame Trump for an Iran policy 40 years in the making MORE nominated the New York native.
ADVERTISEMENT

Her supporters included nine of the 40 Senate Republicans: Mel Martinez (Fla.), George Voinovich (Ohio), Judd Gregg (N.H.), Kit Bond (Mo.), Lindsey GrahamLindsey Olin GrahamGOP group calls on Republican senators to stand up to McConnell on election security in new ads Cindy McCain says no one in Republican Party carries 'voice of reason' after husband's death Trump says he'll decide on foreign aid cuts within a week MORE (S.C.), Susan CollinsSusan Margaret CollinsCollins downplays 2020 threat: 'Confident' re-election would go well if she runs Cook Political Report moves Susan Collins Senate race to 'toss up' The Hill's Morning Report — Trump and the new Israel-'squad' controversy MORE (Maine), Olympia Snowe (Maine), Richard Lugar (Ind.) and Lamar AlexanderAndrew (Lamar) Lamar AlexanderThe Hill's Morning Report - How will Trump be received in Dayton and El Paso? McConnell faces pressure to bring Senate back for gun legislation Criminal justice reform should extend to student financial aid MORE (Tenn.). Of those, Martinez, Voinovich, Gregg and Bond are retiring.

“I think it was an exceptional nominee that garnered their support, but I also think that if you’re free from seeking re-election, you’re even freer from your party’s pressure or the NRA’s pressure,” said Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee Chairman Robert MenendezRobert (Bob) MenendezPelosi warns Mnuchin to stop 'illegal' .3B cut to foreign aid House passes temporary immigration protections for Venezuelans Senate panel advances bipartisan bill to lower drug prices amid GOP blowback MORE (N.J.).

The National Rifle Association had opposed Sotomayor, and had announced it was “scoring” the vote in its future evaluations of lawmakers.

Menendez also said the retirees’ votes for Sotomayor could come into play in next year’s Senate races — such as Florida, where centrist GOP Gov. Charlie Crist faces a primary from Marco RubioMarco Antonio RubioGOP group calls on Republican senators to stand up to McConnell on election security in new ads What the gun safety debate says about Washington Trump moves forward with F-16 sale to Taiwan opposed by China MORE, a former state House speaker who is considered far more conservative. Martinez delivered an eloquent Senate speech supporting Sotomayor, Menendez noted, but Crist had announced his opposition.

“Charlie Crist is going to have to explain why Mel Martinez can make all the comments he made and he’s appealing to the hard right,” Menendez said. “That may be great in a primary election, but it’s going to be troublesome in the general election with a huge Latino population. Those are the type of examples we’re talking about.”

Gregg, Bond and Voinovich all denied their re-election decisions were a factor in their votes on Thursday, noting that they have supported Democratic nominees in the past. Bond pointed to his vote for Ruth Bader Ginsburg in 1993, while Gregg noted he supported both Ginsburg and Justice Stephen Breyer in 1994.

“Our job is not to judge the political philosophy of the nominees,” Bond told The Hill. “I vote the same way whether I’m running for re-election or not.”

Likewise, Voinovich downplayed any suggestion of freedom from the GOP base.

“My conscience — I’m never free of that,” he said. “I try to call them as I see them, and I think the woman was qualified.”

Martinez announced Friday he intends to resign at the end of August, after previously announcing he wouldn’t seek re-election.

“I really do think it’s about feeling liberated,” Jennifer Duffy, a senior analyst at The Cook Political Report, said of the retirees’ votes. “The pressure from the base matters a whole lot less. Voinovich and Bond have seemingly been doing this for a while, but even more so lately. They’re clearly going to do what they want as long as they’re there.”

Voinovich, a well-known moderate, ruffled feathers last month when he told an Ohio newspaper the Republican Party “has been taken over by southerners,” which brought a backlash from conservative Sen. David VitterDavid Bruce VitterGrocery group hires new top lobbyist Lobbying World Senate confirms Trump judge who faced scrutiny over abortion views MORE (R-La.). Bond, for his part, delivered a well-received floor speech announcing his support for Sotomayor and warning that both political parties should not oppose Supreme Court nominees based on their philosophy.

“He was basically saying, ‘At some point it’s got to stop,’ “ said Duffy.

At least one Republican leader agreed that retirements likely played a role in the GOP vote for Sotomayor, although the party didn’t whip the vote beforehand.

“Everyone came to different conclusions, but I do think if you’re not running for re-election, you’ll vote more freely,” said GOP Policy Chairman John ThuneJohn Randolph ThuneSchumer blasts 'red flag' gun legislation as 'ineffective cop out' Lawmakers jump-start talks on privacy bill Trump border fight throws curveball into shutdown prospects MORE (S.D.).