Trump is still on track to win reelection

Back in December, I penned an op-ed here making the case that President Donald Trump would likely win reelection. At the time, Newsweek insinuated I was off my rocker. They were not alone; throngs of folks on social media and via email informed me that I probably rode the short bus to school in my early years and that everyone would be better served if I just went away.

Well, I’m here to tell you that Trump is even closer to winning reelection now than he was at the end of last year. I am not alone in this observation. The Cook Political Report’s Amy Walter is seeing the playing field much the same way I am.

Heading into 2020, Trump’s primary strengths remain incumbency — since 1900, nearly 80 percent of incumbent presidents have been reelected — and the economy.  Since FDR, every incumbent president, “who has avoided a recession in the lead-up to an election year was reelected.” A trade truce or deal with China will most likely ensure a recession does not occur before next November.

Contrarians point to national polls and the slew of battleground state surveys, including Florida, and argue Trump is losing “bigly” to a handful of candidates and is therefore toast. The situation is certainly not ideal for Trump, but early polling from previous presidential tilts suggests the media and anti-Trump forces are getting way ahead of themselves. Who can forget that in June of 1983, eventual Democratic nominee Walter Mondale was leading President Ronald Regan by 10 points or that in June of 2011 a generic Republican presidential candidate was leading President Obama by 5 points?

Unless something totally unforeseen happens such as a major military conflict, the global economy tanks, a Thomas Eagleton situation grips the Democratic Party, Trump becomes ill, etc., this is going to be a close race — the country is just that evenly divided, and thus the race will likely be decided by just a handful of states. (Florida, North Carolina, Arizona, Iowa, Pennsylvania, Wisconsin and Michigan.)

The biggest hurdle the Trump reelect faces is that his disapproval rating has hovered above 50 percent for quite some time. The Democrats can thank their willing accomplices in the press big time for that.

So what does Trump need to do to win reelection? His team can start by taking a page out of the 2012 Obama campaign playbook — and that is precisely what the Trump campaign is doing.

As Obama 2012 campaign aide Ben LaBolt points out, recent successful incumbent presidents prevailed “by executing a two-year campaign to exploit a contentious primary on the other side, reconnect with their base of supporters, and define the election as a choice, not a referendum.” After all, who can forget Mitt Romney being labeled a serial dog-abuser long before he received the 2012 Republican presidential nomination as a result of once taking a family trip with the dog riding in its crate on the car roof?

Yes, the Trump reelect didn’t officially kick off until mid-June of 2019 in Florida; a must-win state for Trump and the crown jewel of his campaign’s electoral strategy. But since March, the president has held numerous rallies in other key battleground states to remind his core supporters exactly what is at stake in 2020. Given that Trump is a dogged campaigner, this will most certainly continue.

What has been eluding the Trump campaign is how to best disqualify the 2020 Democratic field before the party is able to officially select a nominee — but the campaign’s prayers may have been answered thanks to an assist from Democrats themselves. Yes, the Democratic contenders have been on an insane race to the left in an effort to win over their primary voters. From single-payer health care and the elimination of private health insurance to free college and massive student loan debt forgiveness to letting imprisoned convicts vote, there seems to be no line they aren’t willing to cross in their pandering. Normally, all of this would be disqualifying on its face, but it hasn’t yet proven to be an albatross for the blue team’s general election chances.

That all changed during the second night of the first Democratic presidential debates in Miami. When former Vice President Joe Biden, Sen. Kamala Harris (D-Calif.), Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.), South Bend, Ind., Mayor Pete Buttigieg and the others on the debate stage all raised their hands indicating their respective government health plans would provide coverage for illegal immigrants, they gave the Trump reelect the opening it needed to move 2020 from a referendum on Trump to a choice election.

This came as part of a one-two punch to working-class voters given that in the previous night’s debate, former Housing and Urban Development Secretary Julián Castro called for the decriminalization of illegal border crossings.

Democratic National Committee Chairman Tom Perez can claim that government health care for illegal immigrants “is not a handout” until he is blue in the face. But what he and the 2020 Democrats fail to appreciate is exactly how tone-deaf their stance is in terms of the voters they need to recapture the White House in 2020; those residing in the more than 200 Obama-Trump “pivot” counties.

On illegal immigration, 2020 Democrats aren’t even trying to hide the ball. Their message is loud and clear: Every illegal immigrant who crosses the border for whatever reason should not be detained and just about all should get to stay indefinitely — complete with benefits from free health care to free education and maybe even free puppies by the time this campaign is over.

And when it comes to the taxpayer’s dime, what voters are hearing is that illegal immigrants come first and certainly before Americans citizens and the working class. Even New York Magazine’s Andrew Sullivan, who is no fan of Trump, is proclaiming that “the Democratic candidates are in a bubble on immigration.”

We are still a long way from Election Day 2020; things could certainly change. But at the rate the Democrats are going, it’s hard to see how Trump doesn’t win a close one. Stay tuned. 

Ford O’Connell served as director of rural outreach for John McCain’s 2008 presidential campaign; he runs a political consulting business, is an adjunct professor at The George Washington University Graduate School of Political Management, and is a regular commentator on FOX Business. O’Connell is also an attorney. Follow him on Twitter @FordOConnell.

Tags 2020 Democratic candidates Bernie Sanders Donald Trump Donald Trump 2020 presidential campaign Healthcare Illegal immigration Joe Biden John McCain Julian Castro Mitt Romney Pete Buttigieg Tom Perez

The Hill has removed its comment section, as there are many other forums for readers to participate in the conversation. We invite you to join the discussion on Facebook and Twitter.

More Campaign News

See All
See all Hill.TV See all Video

Most Popular

Load more


See all Video