The Democrats' generational battle

The Democrats' generational battle
© Getty Images

For all the kicking, screaming and eye gouging over “Medicare for All” and the Green New Deal, you may not have noticed that there’s a generational as well as ideological battle brewing within the Democratic Party. The face-off started in the 2018 midterm elections and continues into the presidential race.

A battle rages between the baby boomers who run the party and the millennials who are the strongest Democratic partisans.

The first big reveal in the Democratic battle for generational supremacy came in 2018. In Democratic congressional primaries that year, two young progressive challengers, Alexandria Ocasio-CortezAlexandria Ocasio-CortezDes Moines Register endorses Elizabeth Warren as Democratic presidential nominee Sanders faces lingering questions about appeal to women voters Moore defends Sanders's reputation: 'We don't want the fake, and the phony and the fraudulent' MORE (then age-28) and Ayanna PressleyAyanna PressleyThe Hill's Morning Report — Dems detail case to remove Trump for abuse of power Pressley says she 'would welcome the opportunity' to educate DeVos after abortion, slavery comparison Massachusetts governor apologizes after calling Pressley speech a 'rant' MORE (44), beat stalwart liberal incumbents, Joe CrowleyJoseph (Joe) CrowleyOcasio-Cortez defends decision not to pay dues to House Democratic campaign arm Hill.TV's Krystal Ball says Ocasio-Cortez has become a force in Democratic Party Ocasio-Cortez: 'In any other country Joe Biden and I would not be in the same party' MORE (56) and Mike Capuano (66) in Democratic primaries in New York City and Boston, respectively.


The insurgent primary victories were more generational than they were ideological. Both incumbents had very good liberal voting records that were no match for younger challengers.

This generational battle has since played out in the U.S. House of Representatives, where the Democratic leadership has seniority in more ways than one.

The big Democratic House majority has isolated the Republic minority so the real battle has been between the senior House leadership of Speaker Nancy PelosiNancy PelosiClinton says Zuckerberg has 'authoritarian' views on misinformation Trump defense team signals focus on Schiff Trump legal team offers brisk opening defense of president MORE (age 79) and Majority Leader Steny HoyerSteny Hamilton HoyerThe Hill's Morning Report - Trump trial begins with clash over rules House revives agenda after impeachment storm House poised to hand impeachment articles to Senate MORE (80) on one side and “The Squad,” Ocasio-Cortez (now 30) along with three other young women, Reps. Ilhan OmarIlhan OmarSanders wants one-on-one fight with Biden Jayapal: 'We will end up with another Donald Trump' if the US doesn't elect a progressive Media's selective outrage exposed in McSally-Raju kerfuffle MORE (38) of Minnesota, Rashida Talib (43) of Michigan and Ayanna Pressley (45) of Massachusetts.

The squad and their progressive allies have battled with the Democratic leadership over Medicare for All, the Green New Deal and the pace of impeachment.

The battle between millennials and boomers has now reared its head in the Democratic race for president.


In Iowa and New Hampshire, the states that are the first and second to select delegates to the Democratic National Convention, there are only four candidates who are in or close to being in double digits in the RealClearPolitics polling averages.

Three of the frontrunners, former Vice President Joe BidenJoe BidenDes Moines Register endorses Elizabeth Warren as Democratic presidential nominee Sanders faces lingering questions about appeal to women voters George Conway: Witness missing from impeachment trial is Trump MORE and Sens. Elizabeth WarrenElizabeth Ann WarrenDes Moines Register endorses Elizabeth Warren as Democratic presidential nominee Sanders faces lingering questions about appeal to women voters Sunday shows preview: Lawmakers prepare for week two of impeachment trial MORE (D-Mass.) and Bernie SandersBernie SandersKaine: Obama called Trump a 'fascist' during 2016 campaign Des Moines Register endorses Elizabeth Warren as Democratic presidential nominee Sanders faces lingering questions about appeal to women voters MORE (I-Vt.) are in their seventies. But the fourth candidate in the top tier, Mayor Pete ButtigiegPeter (Pete) Paul ButtigiegDes Moines Register endorses Elizabeth Warren as Democratic presidential nominee Candidates weighing using private jets to get to Iowa Biden nabs endorsement from Iowa Democrat in swing district MORE of South Bend, Indiana, is a baby at 38.

Early in the race, there were a few thirty-somethings in the Democratic presidential field. Rep. Tulsi GabbardTulsi GabbardJoe Rogan says he's probably voting for Bernie Sanders Gabbard tells Fox that Clinton's 'Russian asset' remark is 'taking my life away' Hillicon Valley — Presented by Philip Morris International — Bezos phone breach raises fears over Saudi hacking | Amazon seeks to halt Microsoft's work on 'war cloud' | Lawmakers unveil surveillance reform bill MORE (D-Hawaii) is in the race but hasn’t made a dent on the leader board. Rep. Eric SwalwellEric Michael SwalwellMartha McSally fundraises off 'liberal hack' remark to CNN reporter Enes Kanter sees political stardom — after NBA and WWE Swalwell pens op-ed comparing Trump impeachment to XYZ Affair MORE (D-Calif.) is long gone.

Why has Mayor Pete survived while the others have faltered? He has a gold-plated resume for a guy who is so much younger than the other frontrunners.

Buttigieg had to start early in order to build such a long resume so quickly. As a high school senior, he won a JFK Profiles in Courage essay contest. Coincidentally, the subject of the essay was one of his competitors for the Democratic nod, Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.).

The essay launched an impressive career. He went on to receive degrees from Harvard University and from Oxford University, where he was a Rhodes Scholar. He served in Afghanistan in Naval Intelligence for seven months, and he received a Joint Services Commendation Medal for his counter terrorism duty in a combat zone. He was elected to the first of his two terms as Mayor of South Bend, Indiana, when he was only 29.

Democrats would prosper with a young candidate like Buttigieg. His youth is a vivid contrast to the age of the other Democratic frontrunners and the Democratic leadership in the House of Representatives. Voters are in a nasty mood, which means they will want change. He is a change of pace for voters who are tired of the old political establishment, and his age makes him an effective contrast to the older frontrunners.

The age of the Democratic presidential frontrunners and the party’s congressional leadership does not reward the overwhelming support millennials gave the Democratic Party in 2018. Millennials were more supportive of Democratic candidates than voters in any other age group.

Much political turmoil and turnover is a function of a battle between an ascending generation, the millennials, who want political power, and a descending generation, the baby boomers, who have the power and don't want to give it up.

Generational political replacement is a recurring theme in American politics.

Until the 1970’s, members of the Greatest Generation ruled the roost in American politics. Then baby boomer candidates defeated older incumbents. Politicians who came of age during the Depression and World War II gave way to a new wave of upstarts who grew up in the wake of political assassinations, social turmoil, the Vietnam War and Watergate. Now the boomers are in the process of giving up power to young people who emerged in the shadow of 9/11, wars in the Middle East and the Wall Street economic collapse.

Demography is destiny. There are now more millennials than there are baby boomers. Millennials will soon take control from the boomers. It will be easier for Democrats to win the White House with a younger candidate who represents the future than with an older nominee who stands for the past.

Brad Bannon is a Democratic pollster and CEO of Bannon Communications Research. He is also the host of a radio podcast “Dateline D.C. With Brad Bannon” that airs on the Progressive Voices Network. Follow him on Twitter @BradBannon.