A crisis on the Korean peninsula reinforces the need for allies

A crisis on the Korean peninsula reinforces the need for allies
© Getty Images

When North Korea wants a crisis on the peninsula, it does not allow a peace process with the American president to get in the way. North Korea has announced it is cutting off all contact  with its southern neighbor during a month that marks the second anniversary of the Singapore meeting between President TrumpDonald John TrumpTrump rages against '60 Minutes' for interview with Krebs Cornyn spox: Neera Tanden has 'no chance' of being confirmed as Biden's OMB pick Pa. lawmaker was informed of positive coronavirus test while meeting with Trump: report MORE and North Korean leader Kim Jong UnKim Jong UnNorth Korea puts further restrictions on seawater entry to fight pandemic: state media South Korea: Kim Jong Un has executed citizens, shut down capital to stop COVID-19 spread Will Biden choose a values-based or transactional foreign policy? MORE.  

The recent North Korean action to halt all contact with the Republic of Korea is part of a longer arc, whose intended azimuth is always predictable: delegitimize the Seoul government, regardless of which party is in power, and reassure the North Korean people that they continue to carry the torch of Korea-ism, not the highly successful country to their south. 

However, given the twists and turns of the Trump administration, its whiplash-like   pronouncements of how it conducts relations with friend and foe alike, this latest gambit by Pyongyang represents another time-honored effort: to test how solid is the relationship between Washington and Seoul. 


What is important this time is that the same experiment actually may generate a different result.

Thanks to Singapore, and the February 2019 summit in Hanoi and one on the demilitarized zone between North and South Korea last summer, the North Koreans have reason to be pleased. They gave up little. Perhaps some missile tests, and a moratorium on nuclear tests, but in return they received international standing, helped rebuild their relationship with China (and Russia), and saw the sanctions regime further weakened.  

They also received a gold mine in terms of their understanding of Donald Trump. For starters, they confirmed that he is no stickler for detail, and that he appears far more interested in the marketing of a meeting than its actual result. They know that Trump is highly unlikely to read up on the negotiating history of the process, to ask questions of those who have gone before him, or show any interest in building on past achievements. His willingness in Singapore to embrace as his own the North Korean position that U.S. troops in South Korea are impediments to peace and should be withdrawn was breathtaking in the ease with which he used shopworn phraseology such as “hostile war games” in describing U.S.-ROK exercises.  

The North Koreans also have learned that, in addition to shunning details and background, Trump apparently has little interest in listening to his staff. Their treatment of Secretary of State Mike PompeoMichael (Mike) Richard PompeoBiden looks to career officials to restore trust, morale in government agencies Biden faces challenges, opportunities in Middle East O'Brien on 2024 talk: 'There's all kinds of speculation out there' MORE is a case in point. Pompeo, unlike just about any other adviser not in the Trump family, has a reputation for being influential with Trump. Thus, for Pyongyang, the task became to discredit anything and everything about Pompeo and to reinforce in Trump’s mind that he alone can solve the problem. They appear to have succeeded. 

The Singapore meeting of two years ago never created the promised momentum for peace, primarily because it was clear in its aftermath, as well in its lead-up, that this was little more than an effort to enshrine the U.S. president as a courageous and imaginative world statesman, willing to set sail into uncharted waters in pursuit of an elusive goal that none of his predecessors had achieved.  


In the meantime, as South Korea took on the COVID-19 pandemic with the vigor and competence that the Trump administration has lacked, Trump increasingly seemed to chafe at any mention of South Korea’s success, apparently seeing it as a competitor rather than a model in fighting the virus. The U.S. and South Korea had their first fatality from COVID-19 at about the same time in the latter half of February. Korea has held its cases to 232 per million, and deaths equaling 5 per million, while the U.S. has had 6,183 cases per million and 345 deaths per million.  

Rather than admire, much less learn from, South Korea’s relative success, the Trump administration has stepped up the pressure to force South Korea to pay more for the basing of U.S. troops, asking for an immediate increase from $1 billion to $4.8 billion. The unspoken threat is that the U.S. might start withdrawing troops from the peninsula if South Korea does not ante up the support payments. In early April, as a sign of possible additional measures, the Trump administration furloughed 4,000 Korean workers from U.S. bases, a move that caught public attention in Korea, if not in the U.S.

When North Korea tries to bully the South Koreans, the traditional response from the U.S. has been to support Seoul and show the importance it attaches to the alliance. To a limited extent, the State Department did some of that when it expressed “disappointment” with Pyongyang and urged them to return to talks.  But, while no one wants an overreaction from Washington, the Trump administration does need to do some clear thinking about the importance of having allies, and what needs to be done to hold them closer. 

Christopher R. Hill was a four-time ambassador including as U.S. ambassador to South Korea in 2004-05. He also served as the State Department’s assistant secretary for East Asian and Pacific Affairs 2005-09 and was chief U.S. negotiator with North Korea, 2005-08. He is now professor of diplomacy and chief adviser for global engagement at the University of Denver and a senior nonresident fellow at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. Follow him on Twitter @ambchrishill.