Chuck Grassley is the point man in our judiciary remake

Chuck Grassley is the point man in our judiciary remake
© Anna Moneymaker

When future Supreme Court Justice Brett Kavanaugh is confirmed later this month, the unsung hero of the battle will be Senate Judiciary Committee Chair Chuck GrassleyCharles (Chuck) Ernest GrassleyOvernight Health Care — Presented by National Taxpayers Union — Drug pricing fight centers on insulin | Florida governor working with Trump to import cheaper drugs | Dems blast proposed ObamaCare changes Drug pricing fight centers on insulin On The Money: Smaller tax refunds put GOP on defensive | Dems question IRS on new tax forms | Warren rolls out universal child care proposal | Illinois governor signs bill for minimum wage MORE (R-Iowa). Grassley, who is spearheading one of the most profound changes to the federal judiciary in modern history, had already played a central role in confirming a record number of circuit court judges and Supreme Court Justice Neil Gorsuch. Following Kavanaugh’s nomination, Grassley smoothly navigated through choppy political waters, running the hearings with aplomb and applying just the right touch for the brilliant, polished Kavanaugh to shine at his brightest.

This saga began two years ago, with the unfortunate and sudden death of iconic conservative Justice Antonin Scalia. In the face of enormous pressure, Chairman Grassley resisted demands for hearings for President Obama’s classy, well-qualified, Supreme Court nominee Merrick GarlandMerrick Brian GarlandGOP advances rules change to speed up confirmation of Trump nominees New battle lines in war over Trump’s judicial picks Mitch McConnell has shown the nation his version of power grab MORE.

Surrendering Scalia’s Supreme Court seat to Garland risked changing the philosophical balance of the Court for decades. Fast forward to President TrumpDonald John TrumpJustice Department preparing for Mueller report as soon as next week: reports Smollett lawyers declare 'Empire' star innocent Pelosi asks members to support resolution against emergency declaration MORE’s upset victory. Suddenly, Grassley’s gamble yielded a huge payoff in the elevation of Scalia-esque Justice Neil Gorsuch to the Supreme Court.

ADVERTISEMENT
Justice Anthony Kennedy’s June retirement announcement created yet another opportunity for Senator Grassley to step up to the plate. Early on, Senate Democrats vowed to block any nomination. When confronted with Judge Brett Kavanaugh, an accomplished and well-regarded senior jurist with a top-flight pedigree, Democrats were at a loss. Republicans’ numeric edge in the Senate rendered their early threats mostly bluster. However, for the next two months they attempted to delay, obstruct, and undermine this respected federal judge.

Senate Democrats’ already possessed all publicly released materials, Kavanaugh’s 300+ judicial opinions, law review articles and speeches. However, in an unparalleled attempt at delay, they unreasonably requested millions of pages of privileged and irrelevant presidential documents from Judge Kavanaugh’s time as a White House administrator, including six years of emails with hundreds of White House staffers. Throughout this battle, Chairman Grassley and his staff outmaneuvered Democrats at each step, diligently producing 483,000 documents for review, the largest number ever for a Supreme Court nominee and more than the five previous nominees combined.

During Judiciary Committee deliberations about Justices Elena Kagan and Neil Gorsuch, the Committee accepted protected documents for confidential review. These “Committee Confidential” materials were ineligible for immediate public disclosure under the Presidential Records Act because they potentially contained sensitive data like Social Security numbers, birthdays, addresses and banking information.  

Following past precedent and without the cooperation of Ranking Democrat Dianne FeinsteinDianne Emiel FeinsteinFeinstein says she thinks Biden will run after meeting with him Trump judicial nominee Neomi Rao seeks to clarify past remarks on date rape Bottom Line MORE (D-Calif.), Chairman Grassley agreed to receive Committee Confidential records. In the name of transparency and with extraordinary and unprecedented magnanimity, Grassley provided access to all Senators, not just those on the Committee. Given that no Democratic Senator saw fit to read ObamaCare’s 960 pages before destroying the individual health insurance market, it is unsurprising that not a single non-Committee Democratic Senator took Grassley up on his generous offer.

Chairman Grassley extended his hand to work with any Senator who wanted to use Committee Confidential documents to question Judge Kavanaugh during the hearing. Only a single Democrat requested materials. Grassley’s staff promptly made them available to her.  

All told, Grassley’s team logged over 5,000 hours on document review and Judge Kavanaugh’s hearing preparation. The Senator himself was at the Capitol on Labor Day, working over 12 hours preparing for the hearing that would take place fifty-seven days after Kavanaugh’s appointment, a week longer than those of Justices Gorsuch, Kagan and Sotomayor.

The grandfatherly Chairman Grassley was the perfect impresario for what turned out to be a Democratic Party spectacle. Hourly arrests of at least 227 Democrat-allied left-wing agitators, including avowed socialist and Women’s March organizer Linda Sarsour, formed the backdrop for Committee Democrats’ “resistance.” Unwilling to take the risk of a full-fledged walkout, Minority Leader Chuck SchumerCharles (Chuck) Ellis SchumerGOP Green New Deal stunt is a great deal for Democrats National emergency declaration — a legal fight Trump is likely to win House Judiciary Dems seek answers over Trump's national emergency declaration MORE (D-N.Y.) and Democrats opted for a strategy of “maximum disruption.”

Calmly, steadily, with a dogged fidelity to preservation of free speech, Grassley gave Democrats their rope. As their partners in the audience rudely and noisily disrupted the proceedings, Senators exhausted themselves and the American people with their persistent haranguing of Judge Kavanaugh, hurling accusations and badgering him as if he were a defendant in a criminal trial.

Whether Cory BookerCory Anthony BookerCoast Guard lieutenant arrested, accused of planning domestic terrorism Hillicon Valley: Microsoft reveals new Russian hack attempts | Google failed to disclose hidden microphone | Booker makes late HQ2 bid | Conservative group targets Ocasio-Cortez over Amazon Jussie Smollett officially a suspect in alleged Chicago attack MORE’s falsely proclaimed Spartacus moment — Grassley and his team worked until 4AM that day to release the documents Booker claimed were confidential Democrats’ false and misleading accusations about withheld records, phony insinuations about Roe v. Wade or deliberate misrepresentations of Kavanaugh’s judicial opinions and other writings, Chairman Grassley, unruffled, let Democrats put their pettiness, meanness, and foolishness on display for 300 million Americans.

At just the right moments he intervened to deflate misleading lines of questioning, correct fallacious assertions, and hold Committee members to account, solidifying Judge Kavanaugh’s spectacular performance.

Chairman Grassley has led an extremely fair and transparent process. President Trump’s outstanding judicial legacy, the indelible mark he is leaving on the federal courts including the confirmation of soon to be Justice Brett Kavanaugh, could not occur without the groundwork, persistence, and heroics of Senator Charles GrassleyCharles (Chuck) Ernest GrassleyOvernight Health Care — Presented by National Taxpayers Union — Drug pricing fight centers on insulin | Florida governor working with Trump to import cheaper drugs | Dems blast proposed ObamaCare changes Drug pricing fight centers on insulin On The Money: Smaller tax refunds put GOP on defensive | Dems question IRS on new tax forms | Warren rolls out universal child care proposal | Illinois governor signs bill for minimum wage MORE.

Dr. Roger Klein M.D. J.D.M, is a molecular pathologist and attorney in Cleveland. He is a member of the Regulatory Transparency Project’s FDA and Health Working Group. He is a former advisor to the FDA and HHS. Dr. Klein graduated from Yale Law School and completed his postgraduate medical training at Yale Medical School.