With court pick fight, Democrats find their galvanizing issue

With court pick fight, Democrats find their galvanizing issue
© Collection of the Supreme Court of the United States

Democrats have never been adept at making the Supreme Court a campaign issue. I suspect that is about to change. 

For so long, Republicans have made picking Supreme Court justices and federal appeals court judges a galvanizing issue, even to the point that many conservative Republicans hold their noses and support Trump based on this matter alone. That is how much they prize having a conservative-leaning court that they hope, at some point, will overturn Roe v. Wade

The death of liberal icon Justice Ruth Bader GinsburgRuth Bader GinsburgCardinal Dolan hails Supreme Court decision on churches, COVID-19 Cuomo blames new conservative majority for High Court's COVID-19 decision Supreme Court blocks New York coronavirus restrictions on houses of worship MORE has agitated the political cauldron, and it remains to be seen just how this ingredient that was just poured into the election mix will affect the outcome.


A poll conducted prior to Ginsberg’s passing found that a majority of Americans, including most Democrats, believed that a vacancy should be filled by the current president. But that poll question was asked as a hypothetical.

A more recent poll, taken after the justice’s death, tells a very different story. Most Americans now believe the Senate should wait to confirm a justice until after the election. Only 28 percent of registered voters in this poll said Trump should fill the vacancy before the election.

Democratic presidential nominee Joe BidenJoe BidenTrump says he'll leave White House if Biden declared winner of Electoral College The Memo: Biden faces tough road on pledge to heal nation US records 2,300 COVID-19 deaths as pandemic rises with holidays MORE and other Democrats argue that what Republicans said during the more than 200 days that they denied President Obama’s 2016 Supreme Court pick Merrick GarlandMerrick Brian GarlandFeinstein departure from top post sets stage for Judiciary fight McConnell pushed Trump to nominate Barrett on the night of Ginsburg's death: report Feinstein to step down as top Democrat on Judiciary Committee MORE a hearing should apply now. Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnellAddison (Mitch) Mitchell McConnellAs Biden administration ramps up, Trump legal effort drags on Harris says she has 'not yet' spoken to Pence Kamala Harris, Stacey Abrams among nominees for Time magazine's 2020 Person of the Year MORE (R-Ky.) and Republicans argued that since it was an election year, “the American people” should decide who gets to pick the next Supreme Court justice.

But McConnell and many other Republicans are flip-flopping, urging Trump to make a quick pick and committing the Senate to a vote for Trump’s nominee. 

In a now awkward quote that’s gone viral, Sen. Lindsey GrahamLindsey Olin GrahamLet's give thanks to Republican defenders of Democracy Clyburn: Biden falling short on naming Black figures to top posts Feinstein departure from top post sets stage for Judiciary fight MORE (R-S.C.) told us to use his words against him as he argued that a Supreme Court vacancy should never be filled in an election year. In a show of shameless hypocrisy, he is reneging on that statement and urging a Trump nomination.


Democrats must use the moment to energize their base and talk urgently about what is at stake. The new poll mentioned above, and the record amount of money raised by progressive online fundraising website Act Blue – more than $100,000 per minute in the hours after RBG’s death – shows that this can finally be the galvanizing issue for Democrats that it has been for Republicans for so many years.    

Vulnerable Republican senators should be concerned. Sen. Susan CollinsSusan Margaret CollinsTwo more parting shots from Trump aimed squarely at disabled workers Trump transition order follows chorus of GOP criticism The Memo: Trump election loss roils right MORE (R-Maine), in a tough reelection fight, has already said she believes the next justice should be picked by whoever wins in November and opposes holding a Senate vote before the election.

Sen. Lisa MurkowskiLisa Ann MurkowskiTrump administration denies permit for controversial Pebble Mine Trump transition order follows chorus of GOP criticism The Memo: Trump election loss roils right MORE (R-Alaska) has also said she believes whoever wins the presidential election should nominate the next justice. 

Other vulnerable Republicans are no doubt eyeing these developments to see what would better improve their political fortunes — to support a president who lags in the polls or to oppose a vote until after the election.

Why would Democrats be energized now? Because so much is at stake, including the fate of the environment, of millions of “Dreamers,” of workers’ rights and of the Affordable Care Act and the millions who depend on it for health coverage, especially in the middle of a pandemic.

But reproductive justice is perhaps the most glaring right that is at stake with the next Supreme Court nomination. Since 1973, when the Supreme Court decided Roe, which struck down most state restrictions on abortion, many Republicans have been waiting to nix that decision.

Biden and Democrats should take nothing off the table. If Biden wins in November but Trump and Republicans succeed in ramming their nominee through during a lame-duck session, Democrats should expand the Supreme Court and the appellate courts. The backlog of court cases is enormous; more judges are sorely needed.  

Democrats will be galvanized and energized to fight for a Supreme Court that works for all Americans and a judiciary that protects the rights of everyone who lives in this great country.

Maria Cardona is a longtime Democratic strategist and was co-chair of the Democratic National Committee's rules and bylaws committee for the party's 2020 convention. She is a principal at Dewey Square Group, a Washington-based political consulting agency, and a CNN/CNN Español political commentator. Follow her on Twitter @MariaTCardona.