The views expressed by contributors are their own and not the view of The Hill

Trump should call Dems’ bluff in shutdown showdown

Government shutdowns are nothing new and have been going on for decades. Since 1977 there have been 22. None of them have lasted more than a month, and most did not even go a week. The longest shutdowns have been during the tenure of Democrats serving in the White House — Carter, Clinton and Obama.

The duration of the average shutdown tells you it’s a stunt. The lead-up to a shutdown always seems to follow the same protocols. Congress punts a continuing resolution for a matter of months and then waits for the last possible moment to vote on appropriations, thereby setting up the threat of a government shutdown in order to shakedown and extort the other party into making a deal that, again, will only last months before the whole process repeats itself.

No business and no family budget could operate the way Congress does business. 

This political game of Russian Roulette is getting tiresome and predictable. Holding government spending hostage for purely political purposes is gross negligence at best and extortion at worst.{mosads}

Shutting down the government over a $5 billion appropriation in a $4 trillion annual budget is as partisan as it gets. The visceral hate for this president, and the resistance by Democrats, is appalling.

Border security should be a “no brainer” and should enjoy wide bipartisan support. There was a time when it did: Republicans and Democrats came together and voted for the “Secure Fence Act of 2006.” That legislation appropriated money to build more than 700 miles of border fencing; Sen. Charles Schumer (D-N.Y.) and then-Sen. Barack Obama (D-Ill.) took to the floor of the Senate to champion border security.

There is no doubt America needs better and smarter border security — yet, as long as this president makes it a priority, Democrats will go kicking and screaming to approve any penny for border security that Republicans say will be spent for a border wall.

This game of semantics that is being played is transparently politicizing border security: Republicans call for a wall, and Democrats say we need fencing instead of “Trump’s wall.” Republicans call for a “border wall,” and Democrats say they are in favor of “border security.”

Is it any wonder the American people hold Congress in such low esteem? Congress enjoys a public approval of 28 percent.

Elections have consequences, and Congress has rules.

So, how will this one end? I hope President Trump sticks to his promises and principles on border security. The president has already shown good faith in the amount of funds he has requested for a fixed barrier along our southern border. He is being responsible in seeking “pay as you go” funding for border security. A $5 billion appropriation is more than fair, and needed.

The president needs to call the Democrats’ bluff. He perhaps needs to set a new, painful record for a government shutdown that will teach Democrats a lesson they will not soon forget.

Kicking the can down the road, only to create a crisis that is purely avoidable and political, is unacceptable. A long, protracted shutdown will make future shutdowns a third rail that no one will want to touch. There is no way the public sector workforce should be pawns in a political squabble that costs more in lost wages and revenue than the budget disagreement itself.

President Trump was elected on a platform that included immigration reforms and border security. For most Democrats, their opposition is to the president himself — not the subject matter or spending.

And for President Trump, this is a “read my lips” moment. He cannot retreat on a fundamental promise. He must stand his ground. He must deliver.

Promises made must be promises kept.

Bradley Blakeman was a deputy assistant to President George Bush from 2001 to 2004. A principal of the 1600 Group, a strategic communications firm, he is an adjunct professor of public policy and international affairs at Georgetown University and a contributor to Fox News and Fox Business.

Tags Barack Obama Chuck Schumer Donald Trump Donald Trump Government shutdowns in the United States United States federal government shutdown

Copyright 2023 Nexstar Media Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

More White House News

See All
See all Hill.TV See all Video

Most Popular

Load more


See all Video