Trump and Obama equally admired? Eight things popularity polls tell us

Trump and Obama equally admired? Eight things popularity polls tell us
© Twitter

Donald Trump tied with Barack ObamaBarack Hussein ObamaBiden breaks away from 2020 pack in South Carolina National Archives says it altered Trump signs, other messages in Women's March photo Climate 'religion' is fueling Australia's wildfires MORE as the most admired man in 2019 in a recent Gallup poll. Conducted since 1948, the survey of America’s most admired man and woman provides insight into the leadership attributes people deem important. Jimmy CarterJimmy CarterPolitical science has its limits when it comes to presidential prediction Mellman: Democrats — Buckle up for a wild ride Trump and Obama equally admired? Eight things popularity polls tell us MORE, Elon MuskElon Reeve MuskHillicon Valley: Barr asks Apple to unlock Pensacola shooter's phone | Tech industry rallies behind Google in Supreme Court fight | Congress struggles to set rules for cyber warfare with Iran | Blog site Boing Boing hacked Trump and Obama equally admired? Eight things popularity polls tell us Tesla is now most valuable US auto company in history MORE and Bill Gates came a distant third behind the presidents. First ladies Michelle ObamaMichelle LeVaughn Robinson ObamaSanders v. Warren is just for insiders Overnight Health Care: Trump reportedly lashed out at health chief over polling | Justices to hear ObamaCare birth control case | Trump rolls back Michelle Obama school lunch rules Trump to roll back Michelle Obama's school lunch rules on vegetables, fruits MORE and Melania TrumpMelania TrumpThe Hill's 12:30 Report: Trump beefs up impeachment defense with Dershowitz, Starr Trump welcomes LSU to the White House: 'Go Tigers' The Hill's Morning Report — President Trump on trial MORE were first and second, respectively, on the list of most admired women; Oprah WinfreyOprah Gail WinfreyTrump and Obama equally admired? Eight things popularity polls tell us Judge Judy rules in favor of Mike Bloomberg, will join him on campaign trail We must work to resist the culture of cruelty MORE, Hillary ClintonHillary Diane Rodham ClintonNYT editorial board endorses Warren, Klobuchar for Democratic nomination for president Sanders v. Warren is just for insiders Alan Dershowitz: Argument president cannot be impeached for abusing power a 'strong one' MORE, Greta Thunberg and Queen Elizabeth II followed, in that order, at a considerable distance. 

So, what does the tie between seemingly polar opposites tell us about leadership? Is this another indicator of a deeply divided country, or are there common kernels among this apparently vastly different group of leaders?

The biggest declines in popular support were for Hillary Clinton, falling from 21 percent in 2012 to 3 percent in 2019, and Barack Obama, whose popularity fell from 30 percent in 2012 to 18 percent. Trump’s popularity bounced upward 5 points from 2018. Despite his recent declining numbers, Barack Obama has finished in top place every year since 2008. George W. Bush finished first in seven of his eight years as president, whereas Bill ClintonWilliam (Bill) Jefferson ClintonImpeachment trial will need a 'Perry Mason moment' Meet Pelosi's 7 impeachment managers Trump lawyers attack House impeachment as 'brazen and unlawful' effort to overturn 2016 results MORE topped the poll every year from 1993-2000. 

ADVERTISEMENT

Americans clearly have a predilection for presidents — the only others to have topped the Gallup poll since 1952 are Henry Kissinger (1973-75) and Pope John Paul II (1980). 

Incredibly, Hillary Clinton was the most admired woman 22 times since 1993. The women’s category also has been slightly inclusive of international leaders; Mother Teresa (1995-96, 1986, 1980), Margaret Thatcher (1988-90, 1982-84), and Golda Meir (1973-74, 1971) have finished first.

At a global level, a survey conducted by YouGov found that Bill Gates was the most admired man and Michelle Obama, the most admired woman. This survey polled 42,000 people from 41 countries. The top five men included Barack Obama (a close second), Jackie Chan, Xi Jinping, and Jack Ma. Trump placed 14th on the list. Among women, Oprah Winfrey, Angelina Jolie, Queen Elizabeth, and Emma Watson rounded out the top five. Hillary Clinton finished eighth and Melania Trump entered the list for the first time at 19th place. 

When this survey is analyzed by country, Barack Obama (19.85 percent) was tops in the U.S., followed by Donald Trump (11.50 percent), Clint Eastwood (7.47 percent), Bill Gates (6.88 percent), and Dwayne Johnson (6.05 percent). Among women, Michelle Obama reigned supreme with 15.37 percent, followed by Ruth Bader GinsburgRuth Bader GinsburgEqual Rights Amendment will replace equality with enforced sameness SCOTUS 'TRAP law' case and the erosion of abortion rights Trump and Obama equally admired? Eight things popularity polls tell us MORE (10.43 percent), Melania Trump (8.30 percent), Ellen Degeneres (6.61 percent), and Queen Elizabeth (6.48 percent). 

Clearly, when it comes to men, the poll seems to reflect a preference for leaders in politics and business, whereas women are admired more in the entertainment and activist domains.

ADVERTISEMENT

Setting aside the evident fad for admiring celebrities that ebbs and flows through the longer horizons of these surveys, there are clear leadership lessons that emerge from examining these individuals. 

First, a leader needs a clear vision — in the case of Trump, it is an elegant and easy-to-comprehend vision of “America First.” For his supporters, this translates into a vision of American greatness, dominance and hegemony; his detractors perceive it as xenophobia and racist nationalism. Regardless of which side you are on, there is no lack of clarity. 

Second, a leader needs to communicate effectively. Obama was celebrated for his oratory, and other historic leaders such as Winston Churchill and Martin Luther King Jr. could move audiences through the power of their words. For example, Churchill's vow, “We shall fight on the beaches, we shall fight on the landing grounds, we shall fight in the fields and in the streets, we shall fight in the hills; we shall never surrender,” is one of the most powerful speeches ever delivered. Although Trump is not a master orator, he is the greatest exponent in history of media manipulation and politics as entertainment. 

Third, a leader needs unrelenting ambition and desire to succeed against all odds. Trump and Obama both exhibit this quality. When both their presidential campaigns were written off as lost causes, they refused to yield and eventually prevailed. Trump has defied all expectations that he would resign and endures despite impeachment. 

Fourth is the ability to build coalitions with opposing sides — for example, Trump’s willingness to deal with Kim Jong Un despite starting his presidency directing unprecedented insults at the North Korean leader. Churchill allied with the Soviet Union despite his hatred of communism. 

Fifth, a leader must be flexible, rather than driven by ideology. Obama demonstrated this with his approach to international relations, and Trump has done so with his episodic support for gun control measures. 

Sixth, a leader must be careful to lead close to his pack. Obama was not initially supportive of gay marriage because he did not believe the country was ready for it. Similarly, Trump’s non-dogmatic approach is one of the primary reasons Republicans may be skeptical of him. Trump may have accepted gun control legislation but recognized that his followers were not ready and retreated after claiming to bring the NRA along. 

Seventh, a leader needs courage of conviction to make unpopular decisions. A good example is the Iran nuclear deal: Obama showed courage in signing it, and Trump did so in rejecting it and ordering the strike that killed Iranian General Qassem Soleimani, despite many Americans’ unwillingness to get bogged down in another potentially endless war. 

Finally, authenticity comes into play. Trump and Churchill illustrate this best in their “warts-and-all” style: What you see is what you get.

It seems that, in some respects, Trump and Obama are not that different after all. They possess many similar leadership traits. The difference, of course, is perspective. As Tim Burton has said, “One person’s craziness is another person’s reality.”

Sandeep Gopalan (@DrSGopalan) is vice chancellor and executive vice president of academic affairs at Piedmont International University in North Carolina. He previously was a professor of law and pro vice chancellor for academic innovation at Deakin University in Melbourne, Australia. He has co-chaired American Bar Association committees on aerospace/defense and international transactions, was a member of the ABA’s immigration commission, and was dean of law schools in Ireland and Australia. He has taught law in four countries.