Benghazi suspect won’t be sent to Gitmo

Benghazi suspect won’t be sent to Gitmo
© Getty Images

The surprise capture of a suspected ringleader behind the Sept. 11, 2012, attacks in Benghazi, Libya, refueled a Washington debate Tuesday over whether those accused of terrorism should be sent to Guantánamo Bay as enemy combatants.  

The White House ruled out sending Ahmed Abu Khattala to the U.S. detention center in Cuba after several Republican lawmakers demanded that he be detained, interrogated and tried there.


The administration plans to bring Khattala to the U.S. and try him in federal court. He was charged with the Benghazi crime last year and is the first person arrested in connection with the attacks that killed U.S. Ambassador Chris Stevens and three other Americans.

President Obama has sought unsuccessfully to close the Gitmo prison since his first day in office, and while he made no mention in his public remarks of where Khattala would be imprisoned, his staff quickly ruled out the idea.

“The administration’s policy is clear on this issue: we have not added a single person to the GTMO population since President Obama took office, and we have had substantial success delivering swift justice to terrorists through our federal court system,” National Security Council spokeswoman Caitlin Hayden said in a statement. 

GOP Sens. Lindsey GrahamLindsey Olin GrahamThe Hill's Campaign Report: Arizona shifts towards Biden | Biden prepares for drive-in town hall | New Biden ad targets Latino voters Senate Democrats' campaign arm announces seven-figure investment to boost Graham challenger Graham: Comey to testify about FBI's Russia probe, Mueller declined invitation MORE (S.C.), Marco RubioMarco Antonio RubioFlorida senators pushing to keep Daylight Savings Time during pandemic Hillicon Valley: DOJ indicts Chinese, Malaysian hackers accused of targeting over 100 organizations | GOP senators raise concerns over Oracle-TikTok deal | QAnon awareness jumps in new poll Intelligence chief says Congress will get some in-person election security briefings MORE (Fla.) and John McCainJohn Sidney McCainThe electoral reality that the media ignores Kelly's lead widens to 10 points in Arizona Senate race: poll COVID response shows a way forward on private gun sale checks MORE (Ariz.) called for Khattala to be placed in Guantánamo within hours of the news of his detention.

They warned that reading Khattala his Miranda rights risked the U.S. losing valuable information about his accomplices in the Benghazi attacks, as well as other valuable intelligence.

“If they bring him to the U.S., they will Mirandize this guy, and it will be the biggest mistake for the ages to read this guy his Miranda rights,” Graham said.

McCain said it would be “totally inappropriate” to keep him anywhere but Gitmo.

But Hayden, backed by some Capitol Hill Democrats, argued the administration has already successfully tried suspected terrorists in federal courts.

“Indeed, since 9/11, we have used the federal court system to convict and incarcerate hundreds of terrorists. The effective use of the criminal justice system has resulted in the debriefing, conviction and incarceration of U.S. citizens and non-citizens for acts of terrorism committed inside the United States and around the world,” she said.

Senate Intelligence Committee Chairwoman Dianne FeinsteinDianne Emiel FeinsteinSenators offer disaster tax relief bill Democrats back away from quick reversal of Trump tax cuts Congress must save the Postal Service from collapse — our economy depends on it MORE (D-Calif.) said past cases against terrorists like Khattala “have shown that we can obtain intelligence, convict terrorists and lock them away for a very long time.”

The Sunday capture of Khattala by U.S. special operations forces was a significant national security victory for a White House team that has been heavily criticized in recent weeks over escalating violence in Iraq and the trade of five Taliban prisoners at Guantánamo for Sgt. Bowe Bergdahl, the last U.S. prisoner of war in Afghanistan.

The Benghazi attacks have also been an open wound for the administration, with Republicans repeatedly accusing the White House of not being clear about the origins of the attacks.

White House officials have repeatedly brushed back the criticism, and now they can point to the arrest of a top suspect in the violence. Khattala’s arrest and trial could also help former Secretary of State Hillary ClintonHillary Diane Rodham ClintonHillicon Valley: FBI chief says Russia is trying to interfere in election to undermine Biden | Treasury Dept. sanctions Iranian government-backed hackers The Hill's Campaign Report: Arizona shifts towards Biden | Biden prepares for drive-in town hall | New Biden ad targets Latino voters FBI chief says Russia is trying to interfere in election to undermine Biden MORE if she runs for the Democratic nomination for president in 2016. Republicans have frequently attacked Clinton over her role in Benghazi.

Obama, who ordered the raid that captured Khattala, praised U.S. troops and said it would send a message to the world that when Americans are attacked, “we will find you” regardless of how long it takes.

The Pentagon said Khattala was nabbed near Benghazi on Sunday by U.S. Special Operations forces who had worked with the FBI for months. The raid resulted in no U.S. or civilian casualties, the Pentagon said.

Khattala and at least a dozen others were charged in the U.S. District Court of the District of Columbia last year with playing a role in the Benghazi attacks.

Khattala faces three criminal charges, which Attorney General Eric HolderEric Himpton HolderThe Hill's Campaign Report: Trump's rally risk | Biden ramps up legal team | Biden hits Trump over climate policy Biden campaign forming 'special litigation' team ahead of possible voting battle Pompeo, Engel poised for battle in contempt proceedings MORE said the Justice Department could add to in the coming days. For now, he’s charged with providing material support to terrorists resulting in death, using a firearm in a crime of violence and killing a person in an attack on a federal facility.

If he’s convicted of the last crime, he could be eligible for the death penalty. On Tuesday, a Justice Department official declined to comment about what the agency plans to seek as punishment if he’s convicted.

In January, the State Department designated Khattala as a terrorist. Officials consider him to be a senior leader of the Benghazi branch of the militant group Ansar al-Sharia, whose members the U.S. believes were involved in the attack. 

Graham speculated that Khattala is likely on a U.S. ship. In the past, the U.S. has used such trips to interrogate terrorism suspects. 

Hayden suggested Khattala is under interrogation and that the U.S. will seek to get as much intelligence from him as possible.

“As to whether Abu Khattala will be debriefed for intelligence purposes, I can’t comment on the specifics, but as a general rule, we will always seek to elicit all the actionable intelligence and information we can from terrorist suspects taken into our custody,” she said.

Federal courts have completed nearly 500 cases related to international terrorism since 9/11, and 67 of those cases have involved individuals captured overseas, according to Department of Justice data obtained by Human Rights First. 

By contrast, military commissions have convicted only eight individuals since 9/11, with two of those convictions overturned on appeal, according to the group.


Martin Matishak contributed.