Acting Pentagon chief says he hasn't 'walked through' Space Force proposal with skeptical Dem chairman

Acting Pentagon chief says he hasn't 'walked through' Space Force proposal with skeptical Dem chairman
© Getty Images

Acting Defense Secretary Patrick ShanahanPatrick Michael ShanahanHouse Armed Services chairman expresses confidence in Esper amid aircraft carrier coronavirus crisis Boeing pleads for bailout under weight of coronavirus, 737 fallout Esper's chief of staff to depart at end of January MORE said he has not yet spoken about the Trump administration’s "Space Force" proposal with the Democratic chairman of the House Armed Services Committee, who in recent days threw cold water on the concept.

Speaking at the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS) on Wednesday, Shanahan said he hasn’t “walked through the proposal” with Chairman Adam SmithDavid (Adam) Adam SmithWhen 'Buy American' and common sense collide Overnight Defense: Marine Corps brushes off criticism of Marines' appearance in GOP convention video | US troops injured in collision with Russian vehicle in Syria | Dems ask for probe of Vindman retaliation allegations Democrats press Pentagon watchdog to probe allegations of retaliation against Vindman brothers MORE (D-Wash.), but added that, in general, conversations on Capitol Hill have found agreement on the military threats in space.


“The feedback I’ve received is worry about adding, building bigger government,” Shanahan added. “That part has been universal, and I don’t blame them.”

Shanahan is scheduled to testify next Tuesday before the House Armed Services Committee, where he is sure to get questions on Space Force.

Last week, Smith indicated his committee would not follow the White House plan for Space Force, saying it’s “too expensive and creates more bureaucracy.”

“I cannot imagine that what they proposed is going to happen,” Smith said.

Earlier in CSIS’s space forum on Wednesday, Rep. Jim CooperJim CooperHouse Democrat to DeJoy: 'Is your backup plan to be pardoned like Roger Stone?' House Democrats call on State Department for information on Uighur prisoner Ekpar Asat Pelosi weighing bringing House back from August recess early over USPS issues: reports MORE (D-Tenn.), who chairs the Armed Services Committee’s subpanel in charge of space, expressed optimism the chamber would pass some sort of Space Force plan this year. He sidestepped questions about specific changes the House might make to the administration’s proposal, however.

Noting the proposal the Pentagon sent to Congress was close to an idea the House passed in 2017, Cooper said “the prospects could hardly be brighter” for the House to pass something.

The Pentagon in February delivered Congress its legislative proposal to make President TrumpDonald John TrumpHR McMaster says president's policy to withdraw troops from Afghanistan is 'unwise' Cast of 'Parks and Rec' reunite for virtual town hall to address Wisconsin voters Biden says Trump should step down over coronavirus response MORE’s proposed Space Force a reality. Unlike Trump’s original pledge to have the service be “separate but equal” from the Air Force, the final proposal calls for Space Force to remain under the Department of the Air Force in a structure similar to the Marine Corps’s relationship to the Navy.

That proposal closely mirrors the House’s 2017 idea for a space corps, which the lower chamber approved as part of the National Defense Authorizations Act but was scuttled during negotiations with the Senate.

On Wednesday, Cooper said Trump’s original idea was “over the top,” but called the one actually sent to Congress “way more modest.”

“In fact, it’s about as close to our original House proposal as you can get,” Cooper added.

Asked about Smith’s comments and what changes the committee might make, Cooper did not answer directly.

“My guess is from the administration’s standpoint, they mainly care that we call it a Space Force, whatever we’re doing,” Cooper said.

Asked by The Hill after the panel whether he and Smith have talked about specific changes, Cooper said “no” and that he has yet to review the full budget proposal since the justification books were just released this week.

“I will see the budget book when [my aide] hands it to me right here,” Cooper said as an aide handed him a binder. “This is how late the process is.”

The Pentagon has requested an initial $72.4 million for fiscal 2020 to set up the service’s headquarters and is projecting it will cost a total $2 billion over five years to launch the service.

During the panel, Cooper called the $2 billion projection a “vast improvement” over the Air Force’s initial estimate of a $13 billion cost, which he said he thought was inflated. He also called $2 billion “chicken feed” when compared with an overall defense budget proposal of $750 billion. 

“We’re well within the ballpark of a reasonable compromise here,” he said.