US wins trade case over 'dolphin safe' tuna labeling

US wins trade case over 'dolphin safe' tuna labeling
© Getty Images

The United States on Thursday won a case at the World Trade Organization (WTO) in a long-running dispute over dolphin-safe tuna labeling requirements.

Two dispute panels found that the United States took all the necessary steps to change its tuna labeling measures to ensure that they are in line with WTO rules. 


"I am pleased that WTO panels have finally agreed with the overwhelming evidence that U.S. dolphin-safe labeling requirements are accurate and fair,” said U.S. Trade Representative Robert LighthizerRobert (Bob) Emmet LighthizerPelosi casts doubt on USMCA deal in 2019 Pelosi sounds hopeful on new NAFTA deal despite tensions with White House On The Money: Economy adds 164K jobs in July | Trump signs two-year budget deal, but border showdown looms | US, EU strike deal on beef exports MORE.

Since 2008, Mexico has challenged the labeling, saying the policies discriminated against their industry.

"The compliance panels found that modifications to the labeling measures adopted by the United States in 2016 either removed discriminatory treatment to Mexican tuna products or were justified as exceptions to WTO rules on the grounds they were necessary for the conservation of exhaustible natural resources," the panel report said. 

Mexico is appealing the ruling.

During the past nine years of the fight, several WTO panels have determined that some portions of U.S. dolphin-safe requirements were inconsistent with trade rules.

The decision will likely stave off retaliatory measures by Mexico. In May the WTO said Mexico could impose $163 million a year in countermeasures after the United States failed to comply with a previous WTO ruling in 2013.

"Mexico acknowledged during the arbitration proceedings that it would be required to terminate these retaliatory actions if the second round of compliance proceedings were to result in a determination that the 2016 labelling measure brought the US into compliance with its WTO obligations," the report said.

The United States has long argued that its labeling requirements do not discriminate against any country.

House Ways and Means Committee Chairman Kevin BradyKevin Patrick BradyLawmakers under pressure to pass benefits fix for military families How centrist Dems learned to stop worrying and love impeachment On The Money: Senate passes first spending package as shutdown looms | Treasury moves to roll back Obama rules on offshore tax deals | Trade deal talks manage to weather Trump impeachment storm MORE (R-Texas) called the decision a "huge victory for both the United States and the WTO dispute settlement system."

"The WTO has made clear — once and for all — that U.S. regulations protecting the lives of dolphins are consistent with our international obligations," Brady said. 

“While today’s ruling is a positive step, dolphin-saving policies should never have been challenged as a trade violation in the first place,” said Ben Beachy, director of the Sierra Club’s Responsible Trade Program.

"With Mexico appealing today’s ruling, we’re still not out of the woods," Beachy said.

The decision comes a day after President Trump, who has regularly criticized the WTO, told Fox News that the U.S. never wins cases. 

"The WTO is a political institution, so this ruling may be motivated by a sense of self-preservation, given that the administration has spotlighted how WTO tribunals order countries to gut domestic policies based on unaccountable tribunals making up new obligations to which countries never agreed,” said Lori Wallach, director of Public Citizen’s Global Trade Watch.

Public Citizen has called on the Trump administration and the Mexican government to include language in the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) affirming the U.S. labeling program to avoid any future disputes. 

"To make sure that the attack on dolphin-safe tuna ends once and for all, a formal and final settlement of the case safeguarding the policy must be part of NAFTA renegotiations,” Wallach said.