SPONSORED:

Democrats have a growing tax problem with SALT

A growing number of House Democrats are threatening to withhold support from President BidenJoe BidenWarren calls for US to support ceasefire between Israel and Hamas UN secretary general 'deeply disturbed' by Israeli strike on high rise that housed media outlets Nation's largest nurses union condemns new CDC guidance on masks MORE’s $3 trillion infrastructure proposal over a tax provision affecting state and local taxes.

Democrats from high-tax blue states are insisting on the repeal of a rule that limits state and local tax (SALT) deductions to $10,000, which was enacted as part of the 2017 tax law signed by President TrumpDonald TrumpSunday shows preview: House GOP removes Cheney from leadership position; CDC issues new guidance for fully vaccinated Americans Navajo Nation president on Arizona's new voting restrictions: An 'assault' on our rights The Memo: Lawmakers on edge after Greene's spat with Ocasio-Cortez MORE to help offset the cost of some of the tax cuts in the package.

Reps. Thomas Suozzi (N.Y.), Bill PascrellWilliam (Bill) James PascrellUS files first trade complaint against Mexico over tampered union vote at GM plant Senate Democrats offer bill to scrap tax break for investment managers America's Jewish communities are under attack — Here are 3 things Congress can do MORE (N.J.) and Josh GottheimerJoshua (Josh) GottheimerFinancial market transactions should not be taxed or restricted Manchin on infrastructure: 'We're gonna find a bipartisan pathway forward' House moderates signal concerns with Pelosi drug pricing bill MORE (N.J.) on Tuesday issued a joint statement vowing to oppose any efforts to change the tax code unless the SALT deduction is restored.

ADVERTISEMENT

The issue could prove to be a serious stumbling block for House Democrats, who can only afford three defections with their razor-thin majority and still pass legislation on their own without any GOP support. 

“No SALT, no deal,” Suozzi told The Hill.

Democrats from states hit hardest by the SALT cap have been pushing for the repeal ever since its enactment, arguing that it hurts middle-class taxpayers, encourages people to move to other states and thereby threatens states’ tax revenue.

“It's a body blow to my entire state. It's an existential issue. People are leaving my state because of the cap on the SALT deduction and it's only been exacerbated by the coronavirus. And when people leave the state because they lost the SALT deduction, then moderate-, low-income [taxpayers] and the rest of us are left behind holding the bag,” Suozzi said.

“Which means either our taxes are going to go up or our services are going to get cut. And neither of those are a good alternative for us.” 

The SALT issue is rearing its head after years of efforts eliminate the cap. In late 2019, House Democrats — joined by five Republicans — passed a bill to temporarily get rid of the SALT cap. 

ADVERTISEMENT

Its repeal was also included in House Democrats’ COVID-19 relief bill last year. Democrats pushing for the SALT cap repeal opted against drawing a red line in negotiations over the $1.9 trillion stimulus package that Biden signed into law earlier this month.

But now they’re laying down a marker as Biden prepares to unveil the first part of his infrastructure plan on Wednesday in Pittsburgh.

The plan, which will focus on physical infrastructure such as roads, bridges, ports, airports, telecommunications and manufacturing, with a heavy emphasis on tackling climate change and building out green infrastructure, is expected to cost upward of $2 trillion. Another plan focusing on “social infrastructure” such as child care and early education is expected to cost upward of $1 trillion.

White House press secretary Jen PsakiJen PsakiFrench police deploy tear gas on protestors supporting Palestinians in Paris White House says safety of journalists is 'paramount' after Gaza building bombed Washington showing signs of normalcy after year of restrictions MORE said Monday that Biden would propose ways to pay for the entirety of the physical infrastructure plan.

Potential options include increasing the corporate tax rate from 21 percent to 28 percent, upping the top income tax level from 37 percent to 39.6 percent, boosting taxation on corporate profits earned abroad, taxing capital gains as ordinary income for the wealthy and changing tax rules around inheritance. 

Transportation Secretary Pete ButtigiegPete ButtigiegInfrastructure deal imperiled by differences on financing Biden says he and GOP both 'sincere about' seeking infrastructure compromise The Hill's 12:30 Report - Presented by Facebook - Colonial pays hackers as service is restored MORE said it would not include a gas or mileage tax, which had been floated in recent days.

Estimates for repealing the SALT cap range from $185 billion to $673 billion over a decade, meaning its inclusion would require that much more in offsets to pay for the bill.

Maya MacGuineas, president of the Center for a Responsible Federal Budget, said the move would amount to a $40,000 annual tax cut for millionaires and billionaires, nearly as much as the estimated $51,000 they got from the Trump tax reform.

“Getting rid of the SALT cap is really one of the more regressive tax cuts we could think about. I don't know why it's on the table. It would leave huge — huge annual tax cuts for millionaires and billionaires,” she testified at a Senate Budget Committee hearing on tax policy last week.

But lawmakers from blue states that tend to have higher state and local taxes say the cap makes it harder for them to raise revenues, hitting their residents with higher tax bills.

Eleven members of the House Ways and Means Committee sent a letter to Biden in late February asking for a meeting to discuss repealing the cap on the SALT deduction. The Democrats, from a variety of high-tax blue states, who signed the letter are Pascrell, Suozzi, Mike ThompsonCharles (Mike) Michael ThompsonGiffords group unveils gun violence memorial on National Mall Democrats urge Biden to take executive action on assault-style firearms Democrats have a growing tax problem with SALT MORE (Calif.), John Larson John Barry LarsonTo encourage innovation, Congress should pass two bills protecting important R&D tax provision Democrats have a growing tax problem with SALT On The Money: Social Security gives IRS data for COVID-19 relief checks | Senate passes bill heading off Medicare cuts MORE (Conn.), Danny DavisDaniel (Danny) K. DavisDemocrats have a growing tax problem with SALT Social Security gives IRS data to speed delivery of COVID-19 relief checks House Democrats demand answers on slow ,400 checks MORE (Ill.), Earl BlumenauerEarl BlumenauerUS files first trade complaint against Mexico over tampered union vote at GM plant Battle lines drawn over Biden's support for vaccine waivers Polluters: Clean up your own mess MORE (Ore.), Brian HigginsBrian HigginsHouse GOP campaign arm adds to target list Democrats have a growing tax problem with SALT Eighth person charged in alleged plot to kidnap Michigan Gov. Whitmer MORE (N.Y.), Judy ChuJudy May ChuHouse to consider anti-Asian hate crimes bill, protections for pregnant workers this month Padilla introduces bill to expand California public lands Democrats praise Biden for recognizing Armenian genocide MORE (Calif.), Brad SchneiderBradley (Brad) Scott SchneiderAmerica's Jewish communities are under attack — Here are 3 things Congress can do Lawmakers demand justice for Adam Toledo: 'His hands were up. He was unarmed' Democrats see opportunity in GOP feud with business MORE (Ill.), Jimmy PanettaJames Varni PanettaHillicon Valley: Parler app risks charges of selling out with Apple return | Justices hear First Amendment clash over cheerleader's Snapchat | Google pressed to conduct racial equity audit Lawmakers introduce legislation to create civilian reserve program to fight hackers To encourage innovation, Congress should pass two bills protecting important R&D tax provision MORE (Calif.) and Jimmy GomezJimmy GomezOcasio-Cortez on Taylor Greene: 'These are the kinds of people that I threw out of bars all the time' The Hill's Morning Report - Biden address to Congress will dominate busy week Democrats warn Waters censure move opens floodgates MORE (Calif.). 

“Although restoration of the uncapped SALT deduction is frequently cast as tax relief for the wealthy, in our districts, it is a middle-class priority. The capped SALT deduction discourages middle-class homeownership and charitable contributions, and it adds to the pressure on our state and local governments to make cuts to education, health services, public safety, and other community needs just when our constituents are suffering the most,” the lawmakers wrote in the letter obtained by The Hill. 

ADVERTISEMENT

But critics of eliminating the SALT deductions say it has no place in the infrastructure plan. Not only does it primarily benefit the wealthy, they argue, but it also would add to the plan’s cost rather than paying for roads, bridges, airports and broadband.

That puts centrist Democrats, budget hawks and even progressives in uncomfortable positions.

“There are some members that feel very strongly about it because they’re in a state where that’s a very big issue for their revenue,” said Rep. Pramila JayapalPramila JayapalBiden spending plans hit speed bumps Overnight Health Care: CDC approves Pfizer vaccine for adolescents aged 12-15 | House moderates signal concerns with Pelosi drug pricing bill | Panel blasts COVID-19 response House moderates signal concerns with Pelosi drug pricing bill MORE (D-Wash.), chairwoman of the Congressional Progressive Caucus (CPC).

While the CPC is not planning to take a formal position on the matter, Jayapal emphasized that progressives are focused on increasing taxes on the wealthy to help pay for the infrastructure plan.

“I will just say that our focus in terms of the revenues is bringing fairness to the tax system,” Jayapal said when asked about the effort to expand the deduction.

Whichever way the House proceeds on the issue, Democrats will still face problems across the Capitol, where Senate Majority Leader Charles SchumerChuck SchumerBiden 'encouraged' by meeting with congressional leaders on infrastructure Republicans welcome the chance to work with Democrats on a bipartisan infrastructure bill Cheney sideshow distracts from important battle over Democrats' partisan voting bill MORE (D-N.Y.) has been a major proponent of eliminating the cap, despite misgivings from centrists in the caucus.

ADVERTISEMENT

Those same centrists have also called for Biden to pursue the infrastructure bill on a bipartisan basis, negotiating out a deal that would win over at least 10 Senate Republicans, who are vehemently opposed to reversing the SALT cap.

Psaki said that Biden would include his list of revenue proposals on Wednesday, when he gives the details of the plan, but added that he was open to engaging with Congress on how to cover the costs.

“If they share a goal of building our infrastructure for the future but don't like the way he's going to propose to pay for it, we're happy to look at their proposals,” she said. 

“If they don't want to pay for it, I guess they can propose that too,” she added.