Dem senators accused of wanting it both ways on Planned Parenthood

A leading anti-abortion rights group on Wednesday criticized two Senate Democrats for voting to retain federal funding for Planned Parenthood while introducing legislation to oversee the money.

Sens. Joe ManchinJoe ManchinBiden to meet with CEOs to discuss Build Back Better agenda Hoyer says 'significant' version of Build Back Better will pass this year Gallego went to New York to meet Sinema donors amid talk of primary challenge: report MORE (W.Va.) and Ben Nelson (Neb.) have it backward, said Susan B. Anthony List President Marjorie Dannenfelser.


"The actions taken by Senators Manchin and Nelson show exactly what’s wrong with Washington," Dannenfelser said in a statement. "They voted to immediately send tens of millions in taxpayer funding to Planned Parenthood and then sought to implement safeguards to ensure that the money isn't being spent on abortion. Shouldn't it be the other way around?"

In fact, Manchin's office points out, the legislation was introduced the day before the vote.

The Republican-controlled House voted last week to terminate Title X family planning funding for Planned Parenthood, the nation's largest abortion provider. The legislation died in the Senate, 42-58.

Manchin said his "Title X Transparency and Verification Act" would make public the periodic, independent audits that seek to ensure that federal funding is not going directly or indirectly to abortion activities. Federal funding for abortion is prohibited under the Hyde Amendment, which is reauthorized annually.

"I believe there needs to be a strict firewall around the vital services that Title X funds provide — such as cancer screenings and family planning — so that those federal funds are never, ever used for a single abortion, except in the cases of rape, incest and life of the mother," Manchin said in a statement last week. "We must do everything in our power to strengthen and protect that barrier."

Dannenfelser said what the senators "won't admit is that money is fungible."

"Over a third of Planned Parenthood's revenue comes straight out of the pockets of the taxpayers," she said. "Commonsense says this frees up money for abortion … Beyond the fungibility argument, under current regulations, Planned Parenthood can use the tax dollars it receives to subsidize the facilities and staff used to perform abortions."

A former Planned Parenthood executive and lobbyist recently said that's the No. 1 myth about the organization. There isn't enough federal funding for family planning as is, Clare Coleman wrote in the Washington Post, and cutting it only hurts poor women without doing anything to reduce the abortion rate.

"A Title X grant is designed to help with costs, not to fully cover them," Coleman wrote. "So family-planning programs are required to find other money to support the Title X project — not the other way around."

This post was updated at 2:15 p.m.