Dems to GOP: Help us fix ObamaCare

Dems to GOP: Help us fix ObamaCare
© Greg Nash

Democrats are beginning to talk about changing ObamaCare to fix what they acknowledge are growing problems in the law’s insurance marketplaces.

Insurers have been dropping out of ObamaCare or hiking their premiums this year due to financial losses, fueling Republican criticism of the law ahead of the November elections.


While Democrats are pushing back at the GOP attacks, they are also expressing hope that Republicans will work with them to make fixes to the law when the new Congress convenes in 2017.

“There are things we can do and need to do to address restoring competition in these exchanges, and my hope is when we’re through the elections and past the elections, we’ll do those,” Sen. Tom CarperThomas (Tom) Richard CarperDems slam EPA plan for fighting drinking water contaminants EPA to announce PFAS chemical regulation plans by end of year Overnight Energy: Zinke joins Trump-tied lobbying firm | Senators highlight threat from invasive species | Top Republican calls for Green New Deal vote in House MORE (D-Del.) said.

Carper pointed, for example, to improving the health law’s “three Rs,” which refer to programs that were created to shield insurers from high costs and losses. Republicans have attacked these programs as a “bailout” of insurers and have restricted taxpayer money from being used on them, putting a strain on insurer finances. 

Another potential change to the law would be to tighten the rules for special signup periods.

Insurers complain people are signing up only after they get sick. While Health and Human Services (HHS) Secretary Sylvia Mathews Burwell is trying to address that issue, Sen. Chris MurphyChristopher (Chris) Scott MurphyCongress closer to forcing Trump’s hand on Saudi support House passes bill to end US support for Saudi war in Yemen This week: Border deal remains elusive as shutdown looms MORE (D-Conn.) said her efforts might not be enough.

“There’s going to be ups and downs in these marketplaces,” Murphy said. “I think the secretary’s got some ability to try to smooth out these edges, and there are other things that ultimately we might want to talk about legislatively. She’s only got so much ability, but there’s clearly people getting into these exchanges mid-enrollment period that shouldn’t be, and that’s one of the things that’s upsetting some of the actuarial data.”

Asked if he was concerned that the situation could get worse on the exchanges, Murphy said: “You know, I think the Affordable Care Act [ACA] from the very beginning has been a roller coaster. There are a lot more ups and downs.”

Burwell spoke directly to Senate Democrats during their caucus lunch last Thursday and discussed ways that the healthcare law could be improved.

Sen. Chris CoonsChristopher (Chris) Andrew CoonsTrump got in Dem’s face over abortion at private meeting: report Live coverage: Trump delivers State of the Union Actor Chris Evans meets with Democratic senators before State of the Union MORE (D-Del.) said Burwell “answered many tough questions on how to improve the competitiveness of the marketplace, stabilize plans and improve access and affordability.”

HHS distributed a packet to the senators with slides highlighting statistics. One stated that 20 million people have gained coverage under the law, while another highlighted how employer plans have seen smaller premium increases since passage.

The packet also pointed out that the law’s financial assistance defrays the cost of premium rate increases for 85 percent of enrollees and gave examples of “Coverage of Administration Push-Back on Rates,” highlighting positive articles in the media.

HHS has already been taking some steps in trying to shore up the stability of the marketplaces. It has made changes to the formula for risk adjustment, which shifts money to insurers with higher-cost enrollees, and tightened the rules somewhat for the extra signup periods.

But many Democratic senators want to act much more ambitiously, through the legislative process. There are now 33 senators who have signed on to a resolution from Sen. Jeff MerkleyJeffrey (Jeff) Alan MerkleyGOP Green New Deal stunt is a great deal for Democrats The border deal: What made it in, what got left out Lawmakers introduce bill to fund government, prevent shutdown MORE (D-Ore.) calling for adding a government-run insurer, or “public option,” to ObamaCare. 

President Obama and Democratic presidential nominee Hillary ClintonHillary Diane Rodham ClintonRoger Stone shares, quickly deletes Instagram photo of federal judge on his case Barack, Michelle Obama expected to refrain from endorsing in 2020 Dem primary: report Why the national emergency? A second term may be Trump’s only shield from an indictment MORE have also called for versions of the public option in order to increase competition. 

While the administration downplayed Aetna’s announcement in August that it would drop out of many ObamaCare marketplaces, Merkley pointed to the company’s decision as highlighting the need for a public option. He said Aetna’s decision was made in retaliation to the Department of Justice blocking its merger. 

“I don’t think we need any more proof that a public option is critical to bringing more competition and accountability to the insurance market,” Merkley wrote in an email to members of the Progressive Change Campaign Committee last week. 

While a public option has no chance of passing Congress, as long as Republicans control the House or Senate, Democrats hope Republicans will join them to make smaller fixes, especially if Clinton wins the presidency in November.

The question is how Republicans would play their hand in that situation. 

Rep. Diana DeGette (D-Colo.) said at a hearing last week that some Republicans had spoken with her privately about fixing the law. 

“At this point, Republicans aren’t willing to admit to the public that the law has helped millions of people and simply needs fixing rather than being repealed,” DeGette said. “So far, they’re doing so only in private, in conversation with me, among others. It’s my hope that after the elections, we can all be more straightforward about what needs doing to get the ACA on the right course.”

There have been some signs that Republicans are willing to take actions short of repeal.

In June, Republicans on the House Energy and Commerce Committee surprised healthcare observers by holding a hearing on a range of bills making ObamaCare changes that — while opposed by Democrats — were a far cry from repeal. The changes were strongly favored by insurers as helping to shore up their business on the law’s marketplaces. 

Still, Republicans remain strongly opposed to the law. Senate Republicans have been making near-daily trips to the floor to bash ObamaCare, and the issue is cropping up on the campaign trail.

Calls for fixing the law have fallen flat in the GOP before. Shortly after Obama was reelected in 2012, then-Speaker John BoehnerJohn Andrew BoehnerOn unilateral executive action, Mitch McConnell was right — in 2014 Bill Clinton jokes no one would skip Dingell's funeral: 'Only time' we could get the last word Left flexes muscle in immigration talks MORE (R-Ohio) famously referred to ObamaCare as “the law of the land,” before quickly walking back his statement and saying that he was still committed to “full repeal.”

“I think it’s important to be vigilant, because like any complex area of policy, it’s going to require some changes,” said Sen. Bob CaseyRobert (Bob) Patrick CaseyGOP wants to pit Ocasio-Cortez against Democrats in the Senate Biden speaking to Dems on Capitol Hill as 2020 speculation mounts: report GOP senators: Trump should not declare border emergency during State of the Union MORE Jr. (D-Pa.). “What we haven’t had, though, is a bipartisan way to do that yet. Maybe 2017.”

Alexander Bolton contributed.